No. 17. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.
The Revision of the Statutes of the Odessa "Society for the Support of Jewish Agriculturists and Artisans in Palestine and Syria."
For a considerable time the Committee of the Society had been at work upon a revision of the statutes, by which the programme of its activity was also to become a different one.
The Committee's activity hitherto is characterised by the former § 1 of the statutes as follows:
"§ 1. The Society is founded for the exclusively charitable purpose of supporting the Jewish artisans, and chiefly the agriculturists, resident in Palestine and Syria."
Recent events brought the Committee to the resolution to alter this paragraph. The emigration of the Jews from Russia is assuming ever greater dimensions. People are going — or rather fleeing — to every quarter of the globe. The Committee then began to consider whether it might not be possible to promote the emigration of Jews to Palestine as well. After several months' work the Committee convened an extraordinary General Meeting for the 3rd/16th of March, in order to lay before it the statutes as revised in this sense.
The revised § 1 was now to read as follows:
"§ 1. The Society is founded for the exclusively charitable purpose of supporting the Jewish artisans, and chiefly the agriculturists, resident in Palestine and Syria and settling there."
The other paragraphs were, of course, altered accordingly. Thus, for example, the Committee proposed that § 2 as well, which formerly read:
"§ 2. The Society supports the artisans and agriculturists resident in Palestine and Syria with money and with the necessary agricultural implements and tools," should be altered as follows:
"§ 2. The Society supports the artisans and agriculturists resident in Palestine and Syria and settling there with land, money, tools, and in their needs of a social character."
The Committee thus retained the principle of charity and wished only to assist new settlers with land as well. There were, to be sure, voices in the Committee (Disenhof) in favour of converting the Relief Society into a Colonisation Society. They were, however, overborne by the majority.
General Meetings are ordinarily preceded by preliminary conferences, at which the whole work of the General Meeting is in fact done and at which instructions are given to the Committee. This time no preliminary conferences were expected, since it was assumed that no delegates would come from other towns. Contrary to expectation, however, some 30 delegates did come, who met together with the Odessa "Chowewe-Zion" in a preliminary conference, which was opened on Tuesday, the 2nd/15th of March, by the member of the Committee Herr Disenhof. Ussischkin was elected chairman of the preliminary conference, and as secretaries Dr. Leo Kohan of Kischenew and Dr. M. Scheinkin of Balta.
Ussischkin opens the debates with the following address: "The founders of the Society had very far-reaching intentions. Gradually, however, the Society, which was to serve the rebirth of our people, sank into a philanthropic society whose whole work consists in relief and the distribution of alms. Not only must the statutes be altered, but the whole direction of its activity must become a different one. The statutes were written sixteen years ago and are now good for nothing. Today everything here is to be altered from the ground up, and tomorrow we shall lay our resolutions before the General Meeting."
Scheinkin's question, whether it was true that the Committee wished to reduce the minimum membership subscription from 3 Rbl. to 1 Rbl., is answered in the negative.
The Chairman requests Dr. Raimist (member of the Committee) to give the reasons for the Committee's proposals, and Herr Disenhof to justify his motions.
Dr. Raimist defends the position that the Society cannot possibly carry on colonisation on a large scale, since it lacks the means for it, and proposes for his part that § 2 be altered to the effect that the Society should support the Jews emigrating to Palestine only with land and counsel, but not with money.
Disenhof declares: "Our Society has a philanthropic character. The members pay their subscriptions without asking about the Committee's activity. Every petition for relief from the colonists is granted at once, which breeds a schnorrer spirit among them. How could it be otherwise, when according to the statutes the Society is a charitable one and serves only those Jews who already live in Palestine? Formerly people still turned to the Committee now and again for information concerning settlement and the purchase of land in Palestine. But even this has ceased of late, and the Committee has only the one occupation left: to collect money and distribute it among the poor of Palestine. The opinion that conversion into a Colonisation Society will direct a stream of poor emigrants to Palestine is not correct, for it will be known that we have once and for all ceased to practise charity, and those who have no means of their own will no longer apply to us. We, however, wish to become a Colonisation Society and to keep the following aim before our eyes: 'to investigate the country and its inhabitants, and to inform those who wish to emigrate to Palestine at their own expense about the plots of land offered for sale and about the terms of their purchase and sale.'"
Drujanow speaks against the motions of Raimist and Disenhof. He is of the opinion that everything should remain as before, since Palestine at the present day can satisfy no one materially, while the adoption of either motion would certainly call forth a stream of emigrants to Palestine whom we shall not be in a position to support.
Dr. Sapir (member of the Committee): I propose that we adopt the draft laid before us by the Committee. Above all for a formal reason. Only two days remain to us before the General Meeting. In so short a span of time it is impossible to work out radical changes. The Disenhof motion, according to which our Society is to begin a colonising activity, demands just such a radical revision of the statutes.
How, then, are we to alter everything from the ground up in two days? Further, our whole activity hitherto has shown us that we are powerless to create anything grandiose, for we lack the means and the men of energy. In Palestine we can play only the part of a moral factor — but no more. Our want of strength goes so far that we members of the Committee have spent whole sittings searching for means to meet the pettiest needs. And now it is proposed that we undertake a grandiose enterprise, under whose burden we shall surely sink.
Finally, an important reason why we cannot adopt the Disenhof motion: the Zionists work gladly in our Society because their activity in it does not contradict the Basle Programme, but on the contrary accords with the resolutions of the Third Congress. If, however, we now begin to transfer the Jews from Russia without a Charter, we place ourselves in contradiction with the Basle Programme, which must call forth a protest from the Zionists, and the Society will lose their support.
Ch. Ettinger (member of the Committee) points to the danger of revising the statutes from the ground up.
Goldberg (Vilna) is for striking out the principle of charity.
Achad Haam: Our Society is an exclusively charitable one, and for that reason all its attempts have failed. Colonisation succeeds only when a government colonises, or when a syndicate wishes to earn money by colonisation. But a society such as ours, which collects money and distributes it again without self-interest, cannot create anything useful. The activity of such a society leads to sad and demoralising results, for it presupposes recipients of alms. Of self-help, then, there can no longer be any question. The revision of the statutes will be of no help, for our Committee itself no longer has any raison d'être; it is merely a relic of the time when men still thought of far-reaching colonising activity and not of the distribution of alms. That a society is founded with a definite purpose and afterwards assumes quite another aspect is a long-familiar fact. As an example one might cite the Paris
