Page 6. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 12.
Mendelssohn, however, did not draw this consequence, and having reconciled faith and knowledge, he remained all the days of his life a Jew faithful to the Law. He never thought of dethroning the revealed law of his nationalist God, and he would certainly no longer have been in agreement with that Mendelssohnian of the purest water, the Rabbi Reggio, when the latter writes in a letter to S. D. Luzzatto (Jost, israel. An. 1839): "It is enough for me if you grant me that these precepts (of the revealed legislation) are not by their nature fitted to earn for him who observes them the name of a Supranaturalist." Such an utterance must not, of course, be misunderstood as though that Rabbi had been unwilling, on grounds of nationality, to tamper with any traditional detail of the Law. That thought lay very far from him. The honest Moses of Dessau would in any case have claimed to count as a Supernaturalist in the above sense, and he would have left it to the letter-writer to appear suspect, not of Supranaturalism, but of quite another thing, totally different from Supranaturalism.
Thus Mendelssohn succeeded, in his own person, in dispensing sweet consolation even to the opponents of his endeavours. It was soon forgotten that his very next descendants "went far — in Christianity," and his memory is held in honour by all parties.
But Rabbi Ezechiel, who shuddered at such rapid advancement, bears the ban as an Orthodox, and is thereby judged.
The victory of Mendelssohn over R. Landau was complete; the very next future, the age of Reform, showed it with terrifying clearness, in such wise that the intellectual father of the movement would surely have grown sore afraid had he lived to see this victory.
But the stone once set rolling could no longer be stopped, and the road from Dessau to Berlin could no longer be undone, however fervently the pathfinders of that day may have wished it. What was the consequence of Mendelssohn's having forced Judaism into the Procrustean bed of dogmatic philosophy?
The same phenomenon came to light that set its stamp upon the Alexandrian age. The Christianising Philos found now also their Pythagoras and their Plato. Theologians and atheologians vied with one another in carrying into the Synagogue reforms wholly parallel with those of the Christian theology of the moment, in simply replacing by Christian forms of worship those customs and views which bore any analogy, however remote, to them. That was the way out of the Ghetto.
As the first in the series of proud names whose bearers saved German Judaism — it was a question of its salvation — S. R. Hirsch stood forth against this pernicious principle. Hirsch attempted to lead the imperilled Judaism of Germany through the stormy sea of the time, whose waves had already swallowed so many brethren in this hasty exodus from the Ghetto. He wished to save what was still to be saved. Thus he wrote, in his powerful manner, the pathetic words: "Even in the midnight of science and of life the spectres of the night do not affright us; we gaze with unaverted eye not towards the West that has gone down, but towards the morning coming from the East." His remains the merit of having been the first to set himself against the general rout, a courageous fighter and, by virtue of his personality, a tower in the battle.
Having seen whither reforming forwards had led, he wished to reform backwards, back as far as Rabbi Ezechiel. With much deliberation he took once more the whole yoke of Judaism upon his shoulders, and despite this burden of three thousand years he walked upright, in his own person a protest against the flight from Judaism under the banner of Reform.
With the friends of Reform, to be sure, he shared the sheer want of any national feeling, which he, like all the champions of Emancipation, had suppressed. For so the harmony of things and Herr Schleiermacher demanded. And as yet no Emperor, whose word one must neither twist nor quibble over, had uttered the high-minded thought that the avowal of a nationality is independent of good and loyal citizenship.
The national idea arose in another place out of other conditions. Between the first writings of Hirsch and Hess's "Rome and Jerusalem" lay almost a generation, and this his last question of nationalities sounded to his contemporaries like unadulterated Sanskrit. — The development of the national idea simply took an entirely different course.
This negative attitude towards the principle of Jewish nationality, as taken up alike by the opponents and the friends of Reform, by no means justifies, however, the timid withdrawal of those who proclaim themselves the heirs of those struggles. On the contrary, it were time at last to clear away the worn-out nags on which men paraded half a century ago.
It is by no means in the spirit of Hirsch, for example, to await, in primeval-forest undisturbedness and with the astonished mien of the Philistine, the things that are to come. One should not parrot the words of the masters, but work in their spirit; yet one proves oneself but a poor intellectual heir of a man if one scatters single ideas of his, like drops of fat, into one's own thin broths. Verily, did they know their Hirsch, they would hearken to his lament: "That even those who recognise our national body to be sick yet stand at its sick-bed with nothing but pious wishes, that is, I confess, what has ever since seemed to me the saddest thing of all." (Napht. Correspondence, I.)
As with his predecessor Landau, so to Hirsch's heels too the annihilating verdict, the reproach of Orthodoxy, has fastened itself like an ineffaceable curse. Men forget very soon — and that is a fine human quality — the evil things, in order to keep the good ones in memory instead. That, as we have shown above, has greatly benefited the historical memory of Mendelssohn, and who would begrudge it him!
But in the case of that Rabbi of Prague it was forgotten that he hated the shears with which the hitherto unconquered giant was shorn of the locks that lent him strength, in order then to deliver him defenceless to the Philistines of Reform.
And when men sought, by Philistine hands, to maim the enfeebled Samson into an ailing cripple, to let him die a slow death, then Hirsch hurled the thunderbolts of his eloquence.
But the one was a Ghetto man in the flesh, the other seemed to gravitate back thither — into the grave of the Ghetto — and at the right moment the word presents itself wherewith one lays "the spirits," the clattering catchword of Orthodoxy.
* * *
Remarkable! Even in Mendelssohn's lifetime the lightning struck that buried his philosophy in eternal night. He himself coined for the man who hurled the lightning the title of the All-crusher. — Of course, Kant "crushed" the three a priori proofs of God's existence of dogmatic philosophy, and that was "all." And yet Mendelssohnian rationalism triumphed, not "although, but because" it was so philistinely trivial as to fit itself comfortably into the new situation. There was no more Ghetto air to be felt, everything so clean and modern, no more memory of the insipid customs of the fathers — and that was its downfall.
