No. 11 — "Die Welt" — Page 7
(continued from page 6)
…are granted, from the day of notification onwards, for six months, weekly and in proportion to the means available, a relief to be determined in each individual case. They also receive medicines. And there are provisions which limit the sick relief. In practice even the sick-pay is precisely fixed by the week. The Fünfhaus Chevra Kadisha is exactly a sick-benefit society, like so many others in Vienna. The above provision is exactly the same as that of such societies. This is further clearly to be seen from § 49 of the Fünfhaus Chevra Kadisha, which deals with the dissolution of the society. Whereas all the other Chevra Kadisha societies state in this respect that the whole of the society's assets shall go to some special purpose, here it is laid down that three-quarters of the assets are to be paid out to the members in equal shares, a provision entirely parallel to that of the usual sick-benefit societies.
Yet the Fünfhaus Chevra Kadisha has no actuarial principle of sick relief as its foundation; distribution is made in proportion to the means. May this be done? Is it sound? Have the members well-founded rights? Where is the loyal check upon the board? This Chevra Kadisha has assets of 40,000 Kronen, and could therefore constitute itself as a sick-benefit society on an actuarial basis — indeed it would have to do so if all the members claimed the right to sick-pay. To be a sick-benefit society without a legal foundation gives cause for fear for the future. A mathematical foundation, however, is scientific and objective and offers a full guarantee of just dealing. It secures the continuance of the institution.
And if the poor relief of the Fünfhaus Chevra Kadisha were to cease, as the introduction of the "Elberfeld System" in the district will bring with it, the society would have the prospect of a large, flourishing, secure and beneficent sick insurance. Many businesses are no blessing. Limitation to one activity is wiser and economically better. To-day the poor relief claims almost as much money as the sick relief. The society itself would also prosper by taking up sick insurance, for this principle has won ever more adherents. Poor relief, however, must be carried on uniformly in order to be effective.
The Inner City Chevra Kadisha too should put itself on a mathematical foundation; it would then need to have no anxiety about income, nor to claim the forces of the people for itself — forces which would then really become free for a more widely extended measure. It could claim these means for new aims. Such aims, however, are lacking here as there, in spite of the progress of knowledge. Care of consumptives, the training of nurses, the feeding of infants, the strengthening of the young: none of this stands in the dictionary of our charitable societies. Charity is practised according to the old code: no progress, no scientific foundation, not provident care but alms.
This principle runs through all the societies in so far as they give mourning-pay and poor-money. It does not occur to them to develop and to advance. Why should not businesses be founded for widows, and insurances undertaken for children? Why always only gifts? Why not help and incitement to self-help? — One gives 14 or 40 Kronen and believes one has been good and wise. But one has only frittered away the society's assets unwisely for a momentary relief. Business men, who otherwise operate in Heller and calculate the exact and fruitful employment of their money, act for others in this unfruitful manner. Money is fruitfully invested only when it helps further; that must be the case with poor relief too.
The Chevra Kadisha societies, under the present order of the Vienna Israelite Community, have to do with burial matters only as supervisors. The entire burial system lies in the hands of the Community, which derives a large income from it. In the year 1899 this yielded a surplus of 184,758.01 Kronen. So be it. It should be united in one hand, all the more since this surplus is used for the Poor Office. But then the burial system must be well organised on business lines. The Chevra Kadisha societies may, over against this, have two humane functions. They can provide for and supervise the most dignified conduct of funeral rites. They can, finally, see to it that the poor man too, in death, receives the most dignified funeral in spite of non-payment, and for this the Chevra Kadisha can provide by organising a funeral insurance with small premiums. That I should consider a sound and good economy.
In London there exists, as the Jewish poor-law authority, the London Board of Guardians. It possesses a stately building of its own, its own asylums and nursing sisters, as well as a staff of hundreds of helpers, men and women. What this body accomplishes may be shown here by a few examples: 1200 Jewish dwellings of the poor were inspected in 2800 separate visits, and in particular the regular working of the water-closets was checked. The cleanliness of the clothing of the poor was promoted partly by instructive leaflets, partly by personal influence and moral pressure. Special attention was paid to consumptives. 527 visits were paid to 150 sick persons, the strictest measures for preventing the further spread of a contagion being impressed upon them and their relatives, and their execution supervised. To patients who had no bed to themselves the committee supplied one; it procured spittoons for them and trained them in the harmless disposal of the sputum; finally, after every death from consumption, it had a thorough disinfection of the sickroom and of the sick-linen carried out by its officers, etc. (See the report of Dr. Jeremias on questions of the physical elevation of the Jews at the 5th Basle Zionist Congress, Minutes, p. 129.)
Could not the old Inner City Chevra Kadisha become a like Board of Guardians? The objection that London is not Vienna is a false and idle one, for all success depends solely on firm will and energy.
To this I wish to summon by my words. They have shown the stagnation of old Jewish institutions destined for great things. They should also indicate how these might again become true popular institutions for the welfare of our people.
For this purpose I propose a conference of delegates of all the Chevra Kadisha societies existing in Vienna, with the object of deliberating how a single body might come into being which could, firstly, foster sick insurance on a large scale, secondly, carry on hygienic prophylaxis and provident care, thirdly, watch over ritual burial and make it entirely uniform by means of insurance, and finally train Jewish sick-nurses and found Jewish sanatoria.
Without official position I summon the Chevra Kadisha societies to reflection and to further building. Perhaps the modest member of the Community will succeed in finding a hearing and attention. Love of the Jewish people dictated my appeal.
World Chronicle.
The Miracle at Sinai in a Geological Light. Professor Dr. H. Gunkel in Berlin has recently attempted to explain the miracle at Sinai by a natural interpretation, putting forward the assertion that Sinai was an active volcano in the time of Moses. With this hypothesis the account in the Second Book of Moses is in fact well compatible. Thus 19, 16: "And it came to pass on the third day, when it was morning, that there were thunders and lightnings and heavy clouds upon the mount, and the sound of the trumpet exceeding loud; so that all the people that was in the camp trembled";