Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 11 · 11 March 1904
6printed page
scan 6 of 20

Page 6 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 11

(continued from page 5)

…befits the solemn Kaddish, this testimony to the bond between parents and children, to have it performed for money by professional recitation, I leave to the discerning to consider. And whether the old custom of collecting gifts after Maskir does not likewise mean an injury to feeling, may also be examined. The man of deep and inward feeling would surely dedicate gifts of his own accord. But that with others the gift will not replace remembrance and its moral exercise, one may confidently assume. A moral value should never be converted into a material one.

One further provision of the Chevra Kadisha relates to the religious work of love. When a co-religionist is near the end of life, at the wish of the relatives two persons qualified for the purpose are sent, who are to recite the prayers ritually prescribed at death. The whole misery of the modern development of our Judaism looks out at us from this § 4. It is not the board or the members of the society who render this last, most holy service of love. Two men are sent! There is no need to say openly that they are paid people. They must be qualified for it. But for what they must be qualified, "the minstrel's courtesy" passes over in silence. We know it only too well. They must be able to recite the prescribed prayers at death. That is their whole qualification. It was surely a praiseworthy institution in Judaism that every Jew had the same qualification to pray for the people and, as a "people of priests", to perform ritual functions; but to-day one must first search for the qualification to do so. It is not friends, or fellows of one's station or of one's society, who are the spiritual supporters in the last hour, but paid, strange, poor servants who still know something of the rites and prayers, whose appearance announces to the relatives with certainty the bitter expectations. We have degenerated. —

How highly, however, the Jews value this last support may be seen from the very fact that all the "Chevra Kadisha" societies in Vienna have taken over this function at death as one of their tasks. To be sure, in "Fünfhaus" and "Ottakring" too "two men are provided," or two "suitable persons" have to keep watch. In Simmering and Währing, however, it is not men and persons but "Israelites" who are to be called in, who are to recite the customary prayers. In these differing words lies, without any hair-splitting, the whole difference between a still Jewish feeling and a business concern.

Otherwise the undertaking of ritual burial is not quite that adopted by the Inner City Chevra Kadisha. The Ottakring society has since 25 June 1893 entirely dropped the supervision of ritual burial; its "religious work of love" consists, apart from the watch at death already mentioned, only in notifying the other members of the society of the death of a fellow-member and in the representation of a board member at the funeral ("as a rule"), but otherwise in the provisions on prayer for the departed, as the Inner City Chevra Kadisha lays them down with regard to the Kaddish prayer during the 30 days, the memorial service on the 7th of Adar, and the collections after Maskir. It does not, however, take payment for the Kaddish for a year, but has undertaken instead to provide, during the week of mourning for a member of the society, the society's Sefer and, if need be, a Minyan. — It is similar in Währing. Here too the notification of death, the representation at the memorial service on the 7th of Adar, but otherwise merely the provision of a Minyan during the week of mourning, no Kaddish during the 30 days, no collecting after Maskir, no society Sefer. New is the provision that at free funerals of members of the society a cantor is supplied as functionary at the society's expense. In Simmering there is the provision of a watch over the dead, notification of death, provision of the Minyan, of the Kaddish and a Jiskar place for deceased members of the society without collecting, also no arranging of the Kaddish, no society Sefer, no cantor for the poor.

While the Ober-Döbling Chevra Kadisha, in quite general terms, designates as its first purpose the burial of the bodies of members of the society and of members of their families, without giving any detail thereof, the "Fünfhaus" society is here too an exception compared with the others. In paragraphs 14—24 it has exact provisions on notification, on attendance, on the watch over the dead, on the fetching of the body, on the ritual washing, on order in the mortuary and in the funeral procession, on the last ceremony at the grave, on the claim to a carriage to accompany the body, on the Kaddish at the cemetery. It also gives, however, in proportion to the society's assets, a contribution towards defraying the funeral costs, is to have Kaddish said on the anniversary of the death of every member; where there is no male descendant, it has in this case to have Kaddish said for the whole year without charge, and provides five men for the Minyan for the week of mourning. Five men only! Again a measure of expediency. Can no more be found?

The "Fünfhaus" Chevra Kadisha is thus certainly also a burial society. It exercises this function more broadly than those for the provision of Minyan and prayers.

In general the religious work of love is carried out by all the Viennese Chevra Kadisha societies only in a representative capacity. It is a public support, not an independent regulation and management of burial matters, nor any extension, under the statutes, to non-members of the society, nor any general, uniform procedure of all the societies towards full equality in the care of the dead and in the ritual functions during and after burial.

For the visiting of the sick and the relief of the poor the Ottakring and Währing Chevra Kadisha also provide; the Simmering society visits the sick and gives relief during the week of mourning and to the bereaved. The Fünfhaus society, however, has sick-visiting, sick-pay, mourning-pay and poor relief. The Ottakring society has kept closely to the Inner City Chevra Kadisha. It gives mourning-pay, poor relief and sick relief.

With regard to visiting the sick, the Inner City Chevra Kadisha wishes, it seems, to make no distinction between members and non-members. The purpose is comfort and encouragement, noble aims. This visiting is made a duty of the members of the society; in Währing, Simmering and Fünfhaus it must be provided for.

Nursing and relief of the sick extend, with the Inner City Chevra Kadisha, in the first place to needy members of the society, further to poor, sick, convalescent co-religionists resident in Vienna. The board may, however, also grant relief, in proportion to the means available, to poor, sick, convalescent co-religionists who have come to Vienna from elsewhere. The society gives, in proportion to its means, orders for medicines and spectacles, and gives contributions towards the cost of bandages and the like.

That is all! According to the annual report for 1902 this activity extends to allowances to applicants, to contributions towards cures, to bandages, appliances, optical articles, to contributions to 8 hospitals, to the support of the "Holiday Home" society, of the Women's Society for Lying-in Women, and to a contribution for the ritual board of the patients maintained outside the Tedesco Institution in Baden. A principle according to which these reliefs are made is not apparent. It always says: "In proportion to the means available," that is, always at discretion. It is similar in Ottakring, different in Fünfhaus. There, members of the society who have already belonged to the society for six months, have duly made the prescribed payments, and credibly prove their illness and incapacity for work,