Page 10. — "Die Welt" — No. 3.
(continued from page 9)
…that O. sees in it not merely a change in views but rather a change in the forms of production of mankind. This change — here too, I believe, I speak in O.'s sense — is certainly proceeding in the direction of a form of communal economy, of whose nature we admittedly know not much more than what the theorists, from Marx down to Oppenheimer, have told us. So much, however, is certain: that it will be a communal economy of such a kind that the competitive struggle is to be reduced to a minimum or even eliminated altogether. Now experience already teaches us today that, in order to establish an economic unity of this sort, unity in the conditions of production is first of all necessary. But unity in the conditions of production exists only where, on the one hand, the stubbornness of nature does not present too many differences and, on the other, the needs of men, the psychical conditions, their — if one will so call it — standard of life, are approximately equal. These psychical conditions, however, change by way of adaptation only very slowly, particularly where a sufficiently numerous collective body furthers their preservation. That is the case with the Jews in the countries of Eastern Europe; there the psychical conditions of production differ so greatly between Jews and non-Jews that a uniform — that is to say, communal — form of economy is quite inconceivable, since the Jews form a collective body numerous enough to withstand the onslaught of the other individuals of the population, who are alike among themselves.
I therefore sum up my remarks to this effect: that precisely by being Zionists we not only promote social development, but that our endeavours positively belong to it as a part of it.
If we are asked, to be sure, why we are Zionists, we answer: not because we are Socialists, but because we are Jews.
Jewish Distress in South Africa.
The following letter, placed at our disposal by the President of the Zionist Federation in South Africa, Mr. Goldreich, surely needs no lengthy commentary. One usually speaks only of the misery of the emigrants at their departure. In Mr. Cohen's letter to Mr. Goldreich one receives a description, as vivid as it is saddening, of the condition in which the emigrants arrive. All this misery will last as long as the planless and inadequate attempts of the so-called benefactors and the disunity in the ranks of the Jews. We now give the letter from Durban in full:
Durban, 13th December 1903.
S. Goldreich Esq. Johannesburg.
Dear Mr. Goldreich,
Many thanks for your prompt intervention, which enabled us to free the detained passengers from the Burgermeisten. There are now 12 detained Jewish passengers here, who had all gone to Cape Town; but as they were turned back and not permitted to land there, they were brought to Durban. When this fact became known to us, we endeavoured at least to get into communication with the passengers, but without success, since the Immigration Officer had instructed the guards escorting these people to allow no one to approach them; even the brother of one of these passengers was not admitted. I succeeded in getting on board the ship. Now I must tell you that the scene which presented itself to my eyes was indescribable; the people were huddled together with about six coolies in a suffocating and horribly stinking space. They rushed at me like hungry wolves, and every one of them lamented, begging that they might be freed, and asked that I telegraph to friends in the various parts of South Africa; some of the immigrants were white-bearded old men. The luggage of all the passengers had been taken away at Cape Town, so that most of them were left without a shirt. It was a dreadful scene, and the most dreadful thing about it was that one could imagine no possible means of relief. When, some months ago, I had the honour of attending a meeting of the Federation, I proposed that the Federation should not interfere in the immigration restrictions in Natal, since I was still thinking of the time when the restrictions bore only a local character and also demanded a local remedy; but my calculations appear to have been wrong, and I must confess, not without shame, that we in Durban grasped this complicated problem very badly, that it was not only a mistake, but that even the good we may formerly have done was more than destroyed by our subsequent ill-considered conduct. I believe you also know that several prominent members of the Federation came to Natal, doubtless with the best and purest intentions, and attempted on their own initiative to free the detained passengers of our faith, but met with a humiliating failure.
The regular consequence of these representations to the high authorities for the withdrawal of the severe measures, and of the fruitlessness of these representations, is always still rougher treatment and greater injustices than before.
I therefore take the liberty of making you the following proposals:
-
The Federation should impress upon all South African Zionist societies that severe restrictive measures have been taken at all ports; the chairmen of the societies should make known to their members that, if they have friends who wish to come to South Africa, they must warn them to come so equipped that they fall under the restriction clauses of the various Acts.
-
The Federation should report to the Actions Committee in Vienna that severe immigration laws have been enacted at all ports in South Africa, and the Actions Committee should call upon the European Zionist societies to warn people against travelling to South Africa unless they have some money, can read and write, and have friends in South Africa.
-
The Federation should make these conditions known through the newspapers.
-
The Federation should send to the various South African societies and to the Vienna Actions Committee copies of the Immigration Restriction Acts of the Cape Colony and Natal.
Dear Mr. Goldreich! The time has come when some definite step must be taken, and since the alteration of the immigration laws is impossible, it is therefore our duty to warn our co-religionists clearly and openly against letting themselves be lured by the false pretences and machinations of the unscrupulous Continental shipping agents into buying tickets for South Africa. In any case I believe that this question must be laid once more before a meeting of the Federation, and I hope that your deliberations will know how to prevent the evil which I cannot possibly describe in words.
With Zion's greeting and the highest esteem, Yours most devotedly, Cohen.
