Page 18 — "Die Welt" — Special Edition. No. 2
(continued from page 17)
...the same song: "We are happy under your government, or under your administration; we are deeply grateful for the gracious protection that you extend to us; we shall most humbly strive to make ourselves still further worthy of your favour and grace."
The Governments are not to be blamed if, with an appearance of good faith, they answer the Jews who now complain to them in astonishment: "What, you are not content? You complain? That is something quite new! Your lawful representatives have always assured us of the contrary!" I claim it as a great merit of Zionism that it has put an end to this hypocrisy of contentment and this comedy of gratitude (prolonged applause). We were the first to say loudly and clearly: We are not content, we consider our situation a very bad one, we feel our treatment to be unworthy and undeserved, we hold a fundamental change in our situation to be a vital necessity; after the humiliating experiences we have had with our attempts at assimilation to other peoples, we have bethought ourselves of ourselves and wish to live our lives to the full after our own manner, by our own right, on our own soil. We have, I repeat it, formally laid our wishes before the world; we have spoken to the nations as a people that suffers injustice and demands justice; we have stepped before the Governments and, without veiling anything and without beating about the bush, have said something like this:
We are an ancient historic people of nearly 12 millions. We consider ourselves as good as any other people on earth. (Stormy applause.) If necessary, we are ready to prove it. Nevertheless, with vanishingly few exceptions, we are pursued by hatred, or at least by aversion and mistrust. Here the most elementary human rights are expressly refused us. There they are granted us on paper, but for the most part taken back again in practice. In this situation we will not go on living. We can compel no one to love us: but justice we may demand, because we bear a human countenance (thunderous applause). It is not just, however, that we should be treated as pariahs, or at best as citizens of the second class, and everywhere as grudgingly tolerated alien intruders. We are no pariahs and will not let ourselves be pressed down into such. We wish to be citizens of the first class in Palestine (thunderous, long-continued applause), with the historic right of original inhabitants acknowledged on all sides, and we ask the Governments to help us toward the attainment of this aim.
That, I repeat it, may seem little to contemporaries; in fact it is a turning-point in the history of the Jewish people.
We have demanded. Old as the world has grown, it has so far found only two methods of getting. These two methods are called: taking and demanding.
Take we cannot and will not; there remains, then, only the second method: demanding. Strange, but literally true: before the appearance of Zionism we did not in fact demand. Among ourselves we heaved deep sighs, expressed yearning wishes in prose and verse, pressed one another's hands with meaning, enthusiastic glances; but we never stepped before all the Powers and told them openly and clearly, in positive terms, what we want. For this neither we ourselves nor others may reproach us. The Jewish people was chaotic; it formed no organism; it was a dust of human beings; it did not itself know what it wanted: it had no appointed representation that could speak in its name; and since it did not itself know what it wanted, the Governments naturally could not know it either. To have changed this seems little, but in reality it is very much. We have demanded! We have demanded that Palestine be opened to us — with the self-evident preservation of the sovereign rights of the Sultan, with the equally self-evident extraterritorialisation of the Holy Places, to which all Christendom clings with its deepest feelings of veneration and love, but at the same time with the guarantee of that indispensable minimum of rights of self-government without which we could not live out our national life even in Palestine.
From more than one official quarter, albeit wrapped in a polite form, we have been answered something like this: "You are discontented and wish to emigrate. We pay you our compliments on this resolve, which testifies to your self-respect and your energy. But surely no acts of government are needed for that. We place not the slightest obstacle in the way of your emigration, and even give you our best wishes for the journey" (laughter). There, perhaps for the first time in our lives, we could not allow ourselves a sense of humour, but had to reply with unshakable, respectful earnestness: Pardon us, it is not enough to open the leaves of the door when the doorway is walled up on the outside. You permit us to depart, but no one permits us to enter. As we do not suppose that you are making sport with the life of a people of 12 millions, we ask you not to rest content with the permission to emigrate, but to open to us also the entrance into the land that we have fixed upon as our goal.
Not from competent quarters, not from official posts, but from the numerous amateur diplomats with whom the ranks of our adversaries swarm, there came to us thereupon this scornful rejoinder: "Well, children, how do you actually picture it? Are the Powers to say to the Sultan, perhaps: Give the Jews Palestine, or you will have us to reckon with?"
To this too we reply with an earnestness which the objection scarcely deserves: That has never been our thought, our wish. The sovereign rights and the dignity of the Sultan shall be infringed from no quarter. The day on which we enter a Turkish province shall be for all the future a great and happy date in the history of the Ottoman Empire. All that we wish is that we be brought into official communication with the Sultan by the Great Powers, and that, after thorough conversation with His Majesty, in which we trust ourselves to convince him that it is to his advantage to come to an understanding with us, we may have those same Great Powers present at the concluding discussion as participants, witnesses and guarantors of our agreements. Should it nevertheless prove impossible to arrive at an understanding with His Majesty the Sultan, should his inflexible will close Palestine to us, then we should simply have to possess ourselves in patience and wait, solemnly maintaining our imprescriptible historical claims to the land of our fathers, and standing with both feet unshakably upon the ground of the Basle Programme. We can wait.
Understand me rightly: we cannot wait if we give ourselves up, if we despair of our future, if we throw