Die Welt · Vol. VII, Separate Edition · 25 August 1903
17printed page
scan 17 of 20

Special Edition. No. 2 — "Die Welt" — Page 17

Dr. Nordau's Speech.

Dr. Max Nordau. (Greeted with thunderous applause.):

Honoured Assembly, forgive me if I first trouble you with a few personal remarks. My name was placed upon the Congress agenda in error. I came to Basle with the firm intention of asking for the floor only if the course of the debate should make me feel it my inescapable duty as the representative of several groups of electors. Without such a practical necessity I meant to keep my place in the ranks as a respectful listener, a silent member, and a voter with the rest. Well-disposed critics have in recent years kindly insinuated that I fancy myself something like the tenor of the Congress, whose part it is to arrive, sing a heroic aria, gather in the applause, and withdraw bowing on every side. I was resolved to avoid even the appearance that there was anything in this account of my work at the Congress, so evidently inspired by justice and brotherly love. I am, indeed, conscious of never having indulged here in vain fine speaking; I grant, however, that a descriptive survey of the past and present of the Jewish people might seem purely academic to one who did not grasp that we had to begin our Argonauts' voyage by taking the noon position. This indispensable work of the navigator is now done. Now we must concern ourselves with the course. Less than ever may this Congress be an academy. Mere rhetoric, art for art's sake, has no place here. Here only sober, coolly reasoned business speeches ought to be made. It is for such a speech that I have just asked for the floor.

Our President yesterday communicated to us two facts which shed a hitherto unknown brightness upon the road that lies before us. He disclosed to us that the British Government is prepared to grant the Jewish people a concession of land, not in the forms in which such concessions are usually granted, not for purposes of financial speculation and commercial exploitation, but with express emphasis upon the wish of the British Government to show sympathy to the Jewish people and to assist it in its efforts toward thorough self-help. The Chairman further informed us that the Russian Government had officially intimated to him that Russia is inclined to further our efforts toward the Jewish settlement of Palestine.

This, then, is the diplomatic situation in which the Zionist movement stands. Four Powers, among the greatest of those that share the dominion of the globe, have expressed friendly sentiments, if not toward the Jewish people, then at least toward Zionism. H. M. the German Emperor expressed his goodwill toward our movement at its origin. The British Government is prepared to give effect to its sympathy, accompanied by precious imponderables, in a very tangible and practical form, in the form of a grant of land. The Russian Government has declared its readiness to further our plans in so far as they concern the Jewish settlement of Palestine. The United States of North America have lately taken two diplomatic steps which justify the hope that at a given moment we should not appeal to their sympathies in vain. (Tumultuous applause).

The fourth point of the Basle Programme, on whose granite joinery the carpers and gnawers will break their teeth (thunderous applause), speaks, in its necessary and deliberate laconism, which permits no long-winded entering into details and no development of the ideas elliptically expressed in it, of "steps toward obtaining the consent of Governments which is necessary for the attainment of the aim of Zionism." This fourth paragraph has always had the good fortune to be felt by the adversaries of Zionism as a particularly sharp thorn in the eye. It is upon this fourth paragraph that the wit of our adversaries has ever exercised itself most. "This consent of Governments," it was mockingly repeated to us again and again, "you will never, never obtain. The Sultan will not and cannot ever open Palestine to you, for even were he inclined to do so — which will never be — he would meet with the opposition of Russia, and for the sake of your fine eyes the Sultan will surely never quarrel with his mightiest neighbour. Russia, however, will never, never permit that the soil over which the foot of the Founder of the Christian churches has passed should ever become Jewish..." Our critics have once again proved the truth and wisdom of the English saying that one should not prophesy unless one knows! (Applause).

Russia, in which we were to recognise and fear the insurmountable obstacle upon our path — Russia amiably declares to us that it has no objection whatever to the taking possession of Palestinian soil by Jews. (Applause)

And now, honoured Assembly, cast a glance at the road which Zionism, in its present form, has travelled in not quite seven years of existence. After not quite one year of work it created this Congress, which to-day, with the exception of a few obstinate Jewish adversaries, no one any longer disputes in its character as the lawful representative of the Jewish people. (Applause.)

All serious men recognise that we are the duly accredited advocates of the Jewish people. Six years have passed since that first deed. In these six years we have, all else apart, done one thing: we have formally laid the Jewish Question before the world. Contemporaries do not often render themselves an account of the historical significance of the events that take place before their eyes. Posterity is as a rule more just; it can be so, for it surveys things from a higher and wider standpoint; posterity will know how to appreciate what this fact signifies. For until the appearance of Zionism the non-Jewish world was always assured, by the persons who until then were alone recognised as the official representatives of Jewry, that there was no Jewish Question, that the Jews were happy and content. It had become, especially in the last decades since the emancipation of the Jews in the West, an iron tradition of official Jewry to assume a smiling, optimistic countenance at every contact with non-Jews. The attitude of our famous "great Jew" is this: he rubs his hands, when he has not either hooked them into the armholes of his waistcoat or is just using them to pay out handsome sums for public, and as a rule anti-Jewish, institutions or establishments.

Whenever a Minister, or even a Head of State, on his travels or on solemn occasions received the official representatives of Jewry, one heard