Page 10 — "Die Welt" — Separate Edition. No. 2
The rising youth above all is filled with national enthusiasm, with love and hope for Zionism.
Not only will the future be ours; the present is ours already, for as against the individual particles of Jewry we are the only organisation embracing the whole. (Storm of applause.)
On the report of the A. C., the first speaker to take the floor was Dr. Camille Levy, the representative of the Swiss Landsmannschaft. He spoke approximately as follows:
"I speak here as representative of the Swiss Landsmannschaft. I believe it will be more correct in point of form if in this debate the representatives of the several Landsmannschaften are chiefly allowed to state their standpoint; otherwise the debate will run on without end. It interested us to hear in Dr. Herzl's opening address his communications, or rather those of the Actions Committee. We have taken no position on the report itself; for on the one hand it is a matter of figures in the financial report, on the other of Herr Marmorek's report on the satisfactory development of the Zionist movement. We concern ourselves only with the most burning question, the question of East Africa, which, one may say, is the crux of the whole Congress. I think indeed just as those do who will say: Palestine only and nothing more; but on the other hand we see the sad situation of the Jewish people, chiefly in Eastern Europe. We can convince ourselves daily of the enormous emigration, of the ruin of the Jewish people. One must live in a Swiss town to see the misery that prevails among the Russian emigrants. It is not only an economic misery, but a moral one. These people are unskilled labourers who know no trade, and are a misfortune not only to themselves but to others as well. Proceeding from this point of view, we say: in the near time and future it is almost impossible for us to speak of a great colonisation in Palestine or in a neighbouring country; on the other hand we know from the report that there is a possibility, under certain conditions, of obtaining a tract of land in East Africa. We must at last take a position in order to remedy this misery; for a veto here would be a crime. You all remember the Biblical passage: 'The voice of thy brother's blood crieth unto me from the ground.' We can say: 'The voice of our brothers' blood crieth unto us from the ground,' and that of the brothers who are perishing in every respect. We must now attain what we can. In this sense the Swiss Landsmannschaft puts forward the following motion: The Congress shall elect a commission consisting of 21 persons, which shall examine the question of East Africa and submit report and motion to the Congress. The Actions Committee shall furnish the commission with all information it desires.
Herr Trietsch: I beg you to recall as exactly as possible what Dr. Herzl told us. Those among you who know me know that I shall remain in this party so long as there is need of work on the land question. Nevertheless it touched me unpleasantly that Dr. Herzl said: "We shall lose those in whom there is nothing to lose." We have worked earnestly in our party. I consider this expression wrong and out of place. Dr. Herzl spoke of those who remain loyal to the movement, to whom one can tell everything and from whom one can conceal everything. I believe it is time that one began to tell everything, just as Dr. Herzl has to-day only hinted at it. He mentioned the following from the negotiations with the Sultan: "I could naturally enter into nothing that was not compatible with our programme." This surprises me in Dr. Herzl, for in the "Welt," where these negotiations were spoken of, the following stood: "Dr. Herzl formulated the conditions of Jewish settlement in a contiguous part of Palestine and other territories of Asia Minor on the basis of a Charter." The speaker then comes to speak of the changes which in his view have been made in the Basle Programme, which has thus undergone an extension, and then remarks concerning El-Arish:
"The town of El-Arish, which lies quite close to the Palestinian frontier, which was the frontier town of ancient Mizraim, had 1000 inhabitants 100 years ago, and has 5000 to-day and exports vegetables and other things. And no irrigation on a grand scale has come there. Who tells us, then, that in El-Arish the 5000 cannot within a quite short time become 10000 and a great many more? It seems to me that a Congress might have been consulted, that a far-reaching investigation ought to have been undertaken as to whether what can be done there does not suffice; and we must not forget that it needs only an impulse to win the great mass of Jewry for us. There has been talk only of East Africa. I am for a greater Palestine. I am for extending the boundary of the land in our programme, too, so that we include possibilities of work within our boundary. For so great a Palestine, beside which neighbouring countries come into consideration: El-Arish, the Sinai Peninsula, Cyprus, parts of Asia Minor and of Syria. I am rather for Cyprus, because it is near and because it is already open to us to-day; but what has been done to ascertain whether in a reasonable, in a logical, indeed historically greater Palestine we have greater possibilities of work to-day? What has been done before we went so far as East Africa?
Dr. Herzl has said: This, to be sure, is not Zion and can never become it. That is the crucial point. But what does Dr. Herzl mean by this: and can never become it? Perhaps he will explain his thoughts to you otherwise than I explain them to myself? He means that East Africa cannot become Zion because Jewish settlement in Palestine will not reach so far as that. Against this, we have had times in the past when the Jewish population grew. At that time there were Jewish: parts of Lower Egypt, of Cyprus, of Asia Minor, indeed even Cyrene and Mesopotamia.
You see, there is a difference in principle between a greater Palestine, which I have advocated, and the very remote East African affair.
The neighbouring countries of Palestine of which I have spoken are such countries as are not Zion, but can become it; that holds for every land near Palestine. But it does not hold for East Africa, and in this I agree with Dr. Herzl. There has then been talk of negotiations with Russia, and these have shown us the light of hope that through the negotiations of our leader in Russia we may come nearer to our aims. Herzl said at an earlier point of his speech: One should neither twist nor quibble at an Emperor's word; should one also neither twist nor quibble at Herzl's word? Are we to let ourselves be caught, is that to be an argument at
