Die Welt · Vol. VII, Separate Edition · 24 August 1903
4printed page
scan 4 of 16

Page 4 — "Die Welt" — Separate Edition. No. 1

(continued from page 3)

…go and recall the civil wars between the Cavaliers and Roundheads and the Wars of the Roses. And yet, strangely enough, the English had fortune on their side and were able to govern not only themselves but the greatest empire, whose inhabitants belong to every colour and race. On the contrary, quarrelsomeness is rather a sign of health. I myself have a considerable quarrel with the Jewish Colonisation Association, and engaged in a friendly combat with Dr. Gaster, whose stimulating presence I miss this evening. I do not believe that Dr. Gaster and I are of one mind on any matter whatever, unless it be in the conviction of the necessity of a home for the Jews. Only on the platform of Zionism do Dr. Gaster and I stand wholly together; in a Jewish Parliament, however, he would sit on the bishops' bench and I with the anti-clerical party. In Zionism alone are all Jews brothers. Even the trustees of the Hirsch Foundation fall out with one another, without the colonies being one whit the worse for it — although, of course, they could hardly be worse. As the President, Mr. Narcisse Leven, lately declared, the differences mentioned even gave rise to the necessity of appealing to the British Parliament. It threw Mr. Leven into the greatest consternation that I pursued the Association even into the English Parliament. Mr. Leven is a very benevolent old gentleman, but these old gentlemen are so thoroughly accustomed to sit in dignity and dole out alms to schnorrers that they cannot grasp the idea at all that independent observers might call their policy to account. I assure Mr. Leven that the J. C. A. and its proceedings form a subject of laughter for the Christian English, who themselves belong to a race that truly knows what colonisation is. Had England attempted to found colonies at an outlay of 8 to 10,000 francs per family, even her wealth would not have sufficed. What the J. C. A. ought to buy with its millions is the right of the Jews to settle in a land that holds an attraction for them; the stream of immigration should dig its own bed. The Jew needs no gifts of money, no 8—10,000 francs per family, no alms, but a free field. If the political acumen of the J. C. A condemns itself in the following admission of the President — which is further supplemented by the fact that the colonisation has nevertheless not benefited the mass of our persecuted kinsmen — then the rest of my criticism of the J. C. A. is likewise justified by his own words. "Our purpose is above all: to colonise," he says, but he confesses: "We have also done other things." That is precisely what I complain of. What right had they "to do other things?" The administrators of a dead man's fortune, endowed for a definite purpose, have no right to spend so much as a Heller for other purposes. What those other purposes were is enumerated in the following sentences: "Our report tells you also what we have done in Roumania, Galicia, Russia and the East to better the condition of our co-religionists. We have regarded their development in the countries they inhabit as an important part of our task."

What these gentlemen have done is indeed praiseworthy, only they have had no right to do it, no more right than I have to take a piece of bread from a window and give it to a man whom I see starving. They have no right whatever to spend money in Roumania and Galicia. To advance the Jews of Roumania, Galicia and even in Russia in those countries themselves is to act contrary to the directions of Baron Hirsch. And in regard to the Act of Parliament which they have now obtained in order to justify such expenditure, I bring against them the charge that they knowingly misled Parliament by pretending that a real connection exists between these operations and colonisation outside Europe, which is their true task. Parliament, which has no time for Acts of Parliament that concern the public, still less for private ones, let the J. C. A.'s statement slip through without close examination, although its failure to create a point of attraction for the emigrants was in some measure to blame for the massing together in East London to which a Parliamentary Commission devoted nearly a whole year.

But the Act of Parliament is in fact useless to the J. C. A., for its own words compel it to bring every institution it supports into connection with colonisation, and since this connection is often comically hidden, the question of the lawfulness of its actions may still be raised at any time. Those gentlemen would have done more wisely had they not been so clever; for had they honestly said that colonisation was wholly or partly a mistake and that they needed the money wholly or partly for these other purposes, our overworked Parliament would have let the Bill slip through just the same, and the J. C. A. would have been for ever removed from my legal criticism. Fortunately, as things stand, it is impossible for the J. C. A., however angry its members may be with individual Zionists, to refuse its help to Zionism when Zionism comes before the public with a practicable plan of colonisation — when Zionism does the brain-work for those who are the guardians of millions. For they hold the millions as a public trust, with which they may not deal according to their personal whim. All that I actually accuse them of is that — like the people they help and the race to which they belong — they live from hand to mouth, without sitting down to consider a practical policy. The failure of the J. C. A. springs from the total want of a well-considered general plan. The misfortune of the Jewish people springs likewise from the total want of a well-considered general plan. It is to find and to frame this plan that we are going to Basle, and I thank you for sending us on our way with your good wishes.

Delegates' Conference of the German Zionists.

On the 20th of August, at 11 o'clock in the forenoon, the Delegates' Conference of the Zionist Federation of Germany was opened at St. Ludwig by the President, Dr. Bodenheimer, of Cologne.

In his address of welcome the President expressed his pleasure that since the last party conference he was able to record a doubling of the number of shekel-payers. These successes, he said, were chiefly to be ascribed to the division into districts. "We have the firm confidence," he concluded his brief address, "that if we continue along the path we have taken, we shall have further successes."