Die Welt · Vol. VII, Separate Edition · 24 August 1903
3printed page
scan 3 of 16

No. 1 Separate Edition. — "Die Welt" — Page 3

(continued from page 2)

…the Commission, especially since Dr. Herzl's statements and Major Evans-Gordon's experiences of travel were at its disposal, did not set the whole subject in its proper light — that it did not propose a Conference of the Powers for the solution of the Jewish Question, or at least a conference between Russia, America and England, the three countries chiefly concerned.

The objection which every country raises against any larger number of Jews is, to be sure, illogical and bespeaks no particular civilisation, but it is grounded in human nature. Why do I feel annoyed when, on the journey to Basle, I am sitting in the railway carriage and some stranger gets into my compartment? My reason will tell me that I have no right to be put out, that the new passenger has just as much right to the carriage as I, but I shall be put out none the less. You yourselves, were you in Palestine, might be considerably agitated if strangers came streaming in by the crowd, competing with your poor for work and crowding them in their dwellings, keeping their shops open on the Sabbath and closing them on Sunday, striving to become members of your Parliament or your Sanhedrin, to study at your universities and to appear as counsel before your courts, and all the while cultivating their religious institutions and keeping themselves apart as a separate tribe. It would be unjust not to grant the desire of the strangers. Nevertheless I have the feeling that in Palestine we should have a highly protectionist party. Therefore we must not call the outcries of the English against us inhuman either. England has behaved more generously towards us than any other nation, and I hold the firm conviction that, if we were to make a serious effort to solve our own question, we should find in England our first, best and most generous friend.

I am entirely certain that England, before it would let the tyrannical proposals of the Immigration Commission, so unworthy of England, come into force, would rather itself depart from their principle and help us to solve the Jewish Question otherwise. I am sure that the time has come to make some beginning, even if it be only a step in the direction of Palestine. We must not wait for a second Kishineff. Anything but that! Kishineff is the turning-point of our history. The martyrs have not died in vain, and the resolve no longer to live in exile is written and sealed with their blood. To attain this happy end, all the Jewish energies of the world must be gathered in one place, which is to be at once a refuge and a place of preparation for Palestine — if we do not begin with Palestine itself. But where is this land to lie? As I read yesterday, a correspondent of the "Jewish Chronicle" holds that the solution would be found if the Russian Pale of Settlement were itself transformed into a Jewish State. Years ago I spoke of this idea to Madame Novikoff, the Russian political agent; she seemed taken with the idea and declared it good. But I have heard nothing further since. By the Pale of Settlement I understand the whole territory, which is larger than France, not merely the towns in which the Jews are imprisoned. For Israel needs for its redemption the open country as well, the right to spread out and to own and till land. In this way a free and manly population will develop, which might one day take up and carry through the negotiations concerning Palestine, and send the surplus of its population across the Black Sea to settle the Holy Land. But I fear these unpractical visions are only a dream-fabric, fit to provoke anti-Zionists.

Dr. Herzl, as you know, is at present in Russia, at the cost of his hard-earned summer holiday. We may therefore expect to receive at the Congress a first-hand report of how matters stand in that country. And if Russia will not solve the Jewish Question within her own borders, another home must of necessity be sought for her Jews. At the Second Congress a member proposed Cyprus as a place of refuge. A great deal can be said in favour of Cyprus. It is an island in the East, quite near to Palestine; it offers the political advantage of being under British rule, and it disposes our feelings favourably because it came under British rule through a Jew, through Lord Beaconsfield. The Congress would not listen to Davis Trietsch at that time. Mr. Trietsch, however, has pursued his idea, though to my regret on his own account, and in a pamphlet which he sent me he proposes to solve our immigration question by diverting the stream towards Cyprus, which for its part gains considerably by receiving a new population. And yet the matter is not so easy as it appears. For on Cyprus, half-desolate though it is, there dwells nevertheless a considerable number of Christian Greeks, and only lately they assembled in their villages and published a patriotic manifesto in which they proclaim that the Greeks were the first inhabitants of Cyprus, and speak of how much blood they have shed in its defence, and remind the world of what their very remote ancestors, the ancient Greeks, did for the civilisation of the world — just as we plume ourselves upon the Bible, which was given to the world by our very remote ancestors.

Since there are on Cyprus 185,000 Greeks and only 45,000 members of other nationalities, a settlement there might bring about political complications. The complications in Palestine will naturally be infinitely greater than those on Cyprus, but in that struggle we shall at least enjoy the satisfaction of fighting for our ancestral fatherland. And I am sure that many of you would prefer Palestine and comparative poverty to another land and accustomed comfort. But the one resolve of the whole Jewish people is unshakable: no more Kishineffs! We are accustomed to hear so much about the impossibility of our organising a State, even when an open country is conceded to us. "Jews are so quarrelsome, you know," it has been said. I could easily prove to you that the English too, if they were not living in their own country, could not dwell peaceably side by side. I could point out that Englishmen would rather submit to distraint than pay the education rate which other Englishmen have laid upon them; I could draw attention to the present electoral battles between the Radicals and the Tories; I could point to the Pro-Boer party, which parted from its countrymen even during a great war. I could, in history, further back-