Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 48 · 27 November 1903
5printed page
scan 5 of 20

No. 48 — "Die Welt" — Page 5

(continued from page 4)

…his opponents, for he makes short work of it and says: "You need not be taken into consideration at all; you do not belong here in the least." That is indeed a weapon for momentary success with the masses, but it gives cause to reflect that he who uses such weapons is not quite sure of his cause. It reminds me of a fish of which Sir John Lubbock speaks, which likewise has a dashing manner of fighting, and this fish happens to be called "crematogaster." I should like to know by what right Dr. Gaster sets himself up as an authority on Zionism. I grant that he is a great authority, but I deny that he has the right to lay under the ban all those who do not see a single phase of the great question with his eyes. Dr. Gaster wrote to the Jewish newspapers that for Zion's sake he will not rest; yes, and for Zion's sake Dr. Gaster did not appear at the last Congress. He had, to be sure, the right to come or to stay at home, but he certainly has not the right to strike the heterodox from his chair with the thunderbolt of his epistles. Dr. Gaster further says in the article: How very different is the Zionism which we preach and to which we do homage. However good the position in which the Jew finds himself may be, he must yet remember the old homeland with heart and mind, and regard his sojourn among the nations as the fulfilment of the divine threats and punishment, and at the same time hearken to the hopeful message that the divine promises too will be fulfilled. We strive for the regeneration of the Jews within Judaism and only through Judaism. Not in order to form a political State, not in order to create a Jewish bureaucracy, do we long for the land of our fathers, but in order that there we may for the first time live wholly and fully as men and as the people chosen by God... That is Zionism... If that and that alone is Zionism, then I should like to ask: Where is the national idea in Judaism, and what has become of it? If Zionism merely means going to Palestine and living there, if Zionism merely means going to the East, then there are already in Palestine 60,000 people who enjoy all the blessings of Zionism according to the Chacham's version. But the matter does not stand so. I miss in Dr. Gaster's definition the real core of the Zionist movement, namely the endeavour to resettle the Jews in Palestine, not as individuals, but as a political nation. I maintain that Dr. Gaster's Zionism is only a political dream. And I do not wish to die for Zion; I wish to live for Zion. Palestine is for us no holy relic; it is no glorified "Road of the Covenant" that we wish to lay there in the future, but a modern Jewish State which shall afford the Jews economic and political security. But the chief purpose of Dr. Gaster's article was to give grounds for his opposition to the East Africa project. He brought forward several arguments which others use against Palestine, and I am sure that many of his words will recoil upon himself. His chief argument, however, is that the thought of East Africa is a turning away from Palestine. He does not seem to perceive that this question stands in no connection whatever with Palestine. We can at the same time work for Palestine and, with the East Africa project, not merely advance our movement but bring benefit to the whole of Jewry. Dr. Gaster's next objection is that, once a settlement has been founded in East Africa, all the nations will say that all the Jews may go there. This argument was also brought into the field against Palestine. He then holds that the work for East Africa will keep us for whole generations from the work in Palestine, etc. But I will not enumerate his reasons further, since he himself, a week later, said at a meeting that "he would be very glad if the Ica would examine the East Africa question." If that is so, why then does he consider this plan harmful to Jewry and to Judaism? If the plan is bad in the hands of the Zionists, it will be so in the hands of the Ica as well. Dr. Gaster wishes to bind the Zionist movement to Palestine alone and regards every other attempt as a betrayal. But when this same Dr. Gaster was reproached with having come to Roumania not as a Zionist but as a member of the Association, he answered that he had gone there merely as a Jew fulfilling his duty towards the Jews, without regard to the party to which he belonged. May not the Zionist body likewise take the East Africa question into consideration without being traitors to its fundamental principles? It is a mere play upon words to maintain that what Dr. Gaster may do, others may not do without falling under the thunderbolt of excommunication on his part.

Dr. Gaster has further told us something which has escaped general attention. He related, namely, that a similar offer was made to him on the part of Cecil Rhodes through a mutual friend, but that various causes prevented him from turning the offer to account. If such an offer was made to Dr. Gaster, I should like to know why he has concealed it so long. Had he, then, so entirely forgotten the misery of his own brethren in Roumania that he did not accept the offer of Cecil Rhodes? I believe the cause of his silence on this matter and of his inactivity in this respect lay only in the "various circumstances which intervened and prevented the offer from being turned to account." Otherwise he would gladly have availed himself of the offer. If a similar offer was tendered to Dr. Gaster, not merely of a settlement but of a considerable tract of land with Jewish self-government, and Dr. Gaster declined it, then a heavy responsibility lies upon him. But one passage in his article touches one most painfully. I mean the one in which he touches upon the motives of the English offer. He says that the true cause of this offer was the Government's wish to carry the Immigration Restriction Bill more easily. That is an unworthy insinuation. The Government can carry the Bill without that, if it wishes, and the tiny handful of Jews cannot influence it. The true kernel of Dr. Gaster's article appears to be the passage in his article where he points plainly enough to the fact that the leaders of the movement cannot serve two ideas at the same time. But this endeavour of Dr. Gaster's, too, to push the leaders, and especially the Leader, out of the movement, will come to nothing. I believe that, whether the East Africa plan is accepted or not, Dr. Herzl will always remain Leader." The speaker then passed to the address of Dr. Max Bernstein and took issue with it, declaring that Bernstein's assertion that he (Greenberg) had given up Palestine was sheer nonsense. East Africa, he said, was only a night shelter, a station on the way to Zion. The settlement in East Africa would facilitate the negotiations regarding Palestine. He closed his speech with the renewed assurance that he did not give up Palestine, but that East Africa was a necessity which would bring great benefit to the Jewish people. After Greenberg, Mr. Zangwill spoke, likewise championing the East African project.

*

South Africa on East Africa.

(After the "Jew. Chron.")

Some weeks ago a great Zionist mass meeting took place in Johannesburg in the Zionist Hall. The hall was overcrowded. Mr. B. Danziger, chairman of the Zionist Association, presided; the address was delivered by Mr. Max Langemann, President of the Jewish Board of Deputies (Landesrepräsentanz) for Natal and the Transvaal.