Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 48 · 27 November 1903
11printed page
scan 11 of 20

No. 48 — "Die Welt" — Page 11.

(continued from page 10)

…and the directives of the D.-K. He also regards the founding of societies for the colonisation of Palestine as an important task of the D.-K.

On the motion of fellow Zionist Leon Reich, the D.-K. was charged with the duty of sending speakers into the provinces, of calling more public meetings on Jewish affairs, and of arranging Jewish-national festive evenings in Lemberg and the provinces.

Dr. Korkis moved the founding of a centre in Lemberg for the deepening of Zionism. (Adopted.)

At the second night sitting fellow Zionist Adolf Stand, member of the A.-K., spoke on colonisation and East Africa and set up the watchword: To Zion without East Africa!

To-day we have an idea, we have money, we have a leader. It would be a sin if we sought to use this moment for any other land than our holy Palestine.

Fellow Zionist Dr. Gabel spoke on the attitude of the Zionists towards the Jewish communities, laying down the principle: "The communities must become popular organisations," and putting forward a whole series of reforms. The Zionists must conquer the communities, in doing which the avoidance of compromises with other Jewish parties should be observed.

The new D.-K. is formed by Messrs. Adolf Stand, Dr. Löwenherz, Leon Reich, Dr. Pordes, J. Philipp, Gustav Bader, Z. Aschkenasy and Herz.

An Anti-Organ Meeting in Berlin.

The agitation prevailing over the projected new synagogue for the northern district of Berlin in the Rykestrasse — whether the house of God should receive an organ or not — and the decided aversion to an organ and to the form of worship bound up with it that exists among the great majority of the residents concerned, found most energetic expression at an exceedingly well-attended meeting which the "Central Union for the Interests of the Jewish Community in Berlin" had called for the 19th of November; the hall of the Königsstadt Brewery could not hold the number of those who came, so that many were unable to gain admission.

At the meeting, over which Privy Sanitary Councillor Dr. Blumenthal presided, Mr. Aron Hirsch delivered an excellent address. The speaker explained that he did not wish to decide the organ question for Berlin, since it had in a certain sense already been decided by the existing organs; the question was simply whether this synagogue should receive an organ. On the basis of exact statistical figures he showed that both the places of worship of the private synagogue societies and those fitted up by the great Community for the High Festivals are fully attended without an organ, from which the feeling against the organ plainly appears. The emptiness of the objections of the Community's Board, that devotion without an organ is not possible in a large synagogue, is proved by a whole number of large communities; nor does the argument of having an organ out of regard for weddings hold good, since only the smallest part of marriages take place in the synagogue. He closed with the appeal to give the conservative representatives, by a unanimous vote against the organ, the opportunity of making a serious stand against the demand of the Board, in the interest of the Community itself.

In thanking the speaker, Privy Councillor Blumenthal declared that the meeting had been called in order to stiffen the backbone of the representatives.

The discussion was taken part in chiefly by Messrs. Klausner (editor), Hartmann, Ludwig Behr, Wedell, Weinberg, Dr. Rosenberg and Bernstein, who, with the exception of Mr. Hartmann, spoke against the organ.

Mr. Behr regretted having to speak after a speaker such as Mr. Hartmann, since that gentleman understood how, by the form and manner of his speech, to lower the level of even the most serious meeting. Mr. Behr turned in particular against the speaker on the point where he said that the organ question was settled for Berlin. He showed that the organ had been introduced at a time when men strove everywhere to imitate non-Jewish customs. Now there was everywhere the endeavour to return to what is specifically Jewish. He showed how writers of the 'forties had expressed themselves most disparagingly about this mania for imitation, and demanded that in our Jewish institutions of worship we should be guided only by ourselves, in accordance with the ancient precept of the Torah: Uwchukkaussom lau ssêlêchu. We want no Israelite churches, no Christianised synagogues, but a purely Jewish synagogue, in which one rejoices to find again the old usages of traditional divine service; he therefore demanded an absolutely unaltered service.

Mr. Klausner spoke against the organ, but reproached the representatives present with not having prevented the space for the organ from being left free, with not having taken up a position on this question sooner, and moreover with not yet having made good their promise to introduce the parochial system. Were this system introduced, there would be no occasion at all to discuss the question of an organ for the North, perhaps not even for the West.

Dr. Cohn, barrister, to be sure repelled Mr. Klausner's attacks, which this time were quite mild in form, declaring that the representatives were working in earnest for the parochial system; moreover, the organ question had already been thoroughly discussed at a meeting called in connection with the general meeting of the Central Union, and that at the instance of Mr. Behr. The representatives had been reproached with needing to have their backbone stiffened first; but the members of the Community should bear in mind that part of the rabbinate, among them a very influential gentleman, as well as almost the whole Board, had declared for the organ; they had therefore been obliged to get in touch with the electors, in order to convince themselves of the feeling in the districts themselves, and having now taken note of the unanimous feeling, they would continue firmly to maintain their position on the question in the sense of the meeting.

Mr. Klausner explained a second time that he was against the organ solely because it was chukkos hagauim, and when Mr. Behr called out that the organ was a symptom, he accepted the expression and said that was precisely why he was against it.

After the unanimous adoption of a resolution moved by Mr. Behr, in the following terms:

"The meeting held on 19th November 1903 in the Königsstadt Brewery, attended in very great numbers by ladies and gentlemen of the Jewish population of Berlin residing in the Schönhauser, Prenzlauer and Königstor districts, protests against the intention of erecting an organ in the synagogue in the Rykestrasse, and expresses the decided wish that divine service in this synagogue be arranged in the time-honoured manner." the meeting was closed towards 11 o'clock, leaving in those who took part the consciousness of having, it is to be hoped, contributed to a cause that is of importance not only for the Community of Berlin but for many other communities as well. For there are still a number of small communities which believe they must not lag behind great Berlin in the installation of an organ, as an indispensable requirement befitting modern times. It is to be hoped that it will continue to react upon the provincial communities in future, when they see that in Berlin the delusion that one cannot do without an organ is at last being broken.

The authority of the rabbinate, however, and above all of the "respected member of the same" who declared for the organ, has truly not gained by the course of the meeting. This applies, of course, to those in whose eyes the authority of the present rabbinate as a whole could still lose anything at all; for there is many a simple Jewish housewife who, when she wants a ruling on religious law, does not appeal to these gentlemen, but seeks and finds instruction somewhere else entirely.

We assume that the Board of the Jewish Community will not persist in its proposal, unless it wishes to draw upon itself the justified reproach that it knows how to do spiritual violence to a large part of the Community. X. Y. Z.