Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 46.
For the rest, the appeal contains a series of grave reproaches against the duly constituted organs of the Land Synagogue, in particular the Supreme Council, of whose import the signatories have probably not themselves become sufficiently aware; but it contains no facts to substantiate them and no proposals for improvement. In this connection, however, the following may further be remarked:
The members of the Synod and substitute members of the Synod who have co-signed the appeal received at the time the above-mentioned circular of the Supreme Council of 7th October 1897, by which they were given the opportunity to state openly and without reserve at which points the Supreme Council, in concert with the Land Synod, should set an improving hand, and what particular measures might be proposed in that direction. At that time the men who now indulge in the gravest accusations against the Supreme Council had no positive proposal to make. And just as little did the two co-signing Synodal deputies, at the Synods of 1898 and 1901 to which they belonged, whether on their own account or in conjunction with other deputies of their tendency, bring any abuses to discussion or propose measures for the furtherance of religious life, as it would have been their duty to do had they had legitimate grievances to assert or useful suggestions to offer.
The signatories of the appeal acknowledge without reserve the exemplary order in the organisation of the Land Synagogue. Upon this unified and well-ordered organisation rest the strength of Baden Jewry to safeguard its religious interests and the ability to draw upon the wealthier parts of the whole, in particular the town congregations with their predominantly more liberal-minded population, in favour of the less capable members. May those who believe it necessary to rally "law-abiding Judaism" in Baden be conscious of the responsibility they take upon themselves when, by putting forward incorrect and wounding assertions and by arousing mistrust, they drive a wedge into the organisation of the Land Synagogue and estrange its members from the duly constituted organs, the conservative from the progressive tendency, and vice versa. In contrast thereto, the Supreme Council will, as heretofore (cf. Verordnungsblatt 1897, page 57), endeavour to work towards the end "that both tendencies, each in its own way, in mutual respect and forbearance, may vie with one another in satisfying the religious needs and in the moral advancement of their co-religionists." In the consciousness of this fulfilment of duty it can leave the judgment of the complaints directed against itself to the Synod. On the other hand, the reproach of neglecting the cultivation of religious life, which falls in the first instance upon the rabbis and teachers as well as upon the Synagogue Councils, must, with full recognition of the faithfulness to duty of these officials and colleagues, be most emphatically repudiated even now.
Karlsruhe, 26th Oct. 1903.
Grand-Ducal Supreme Council of the Israelites.
The Ministerial Commissioner Becherer. Vdt. Driesen.
The General Hebrew Encyclopaedia.
An assembly interesting and significant both by reason of its purpose and of its particular composition took place on Sunday, the 8th inst.:
In conjunction with Prof. Dr. M. Philippsohn and Prof. Dr. Otto Warburg, Professor Dr. Leopold Landau had invited to his house the most eminent Jewish scholars in the fields of general and of specifically Jewish learning who are at present active in Berlin, in order to give them the opportunity of hearing an address by Mr. N. Sokolow, editor, of Warsaw, on the Hebrew Encyclopaedia which he has undertaken, and of expressing themselves on their own scholarly collaboration in this grandiose work. It was perhaps the first time that so select a circle of representatives of general and Jewish learning had come together in Berlin for an enterprise Jewish in the truest sense of the word. If this heightened interest of our men of intellect in Jewish matters may in itself fill us with satisfaction as an unlooked-for advance, as a hopeful sign of the times, it may be called still more gratifying with what warmth and inner sympathy they adhered to the plan of the Encyclopaedia, precisely because it concerned a purpose of Jewish culture and popular education.
The chair at the conference was taken by Prof. Dr. M. Philippsohn, assisted by Dr. Hirsch Hildesheimer as secretary; after cordially greeting those present, he gave the floor to the editor of the Encyclopaedia, Mr. N. Sokolow, editor of the "Hazephira." From many points of view the speaker was able to set forth the usefulness, the importance, nay, the necessity of the projected work. For the masses of the Jewish people who are still rooted in the Hebrew language, the Encyclopaedia would be a means of culture and instruction in the grandest style, all the more essential since at present, through insufficient knowledge of other languages or owing to the inadequacy of the small scholarly works in the Hebrew language, they must forgo such opportunities for self-education. The Encyclopaedia would form the culminating point of the astonishing development which in recent decades had carried the living Hebrew language across journalism, belles-lettres and poetry over into science. In the very fact that it would be possible to turn the most precious possession of the people, the Hebrew language, to the highest and most modern achievement, a great cultural deed would be accomplished, which would fill our brethren of the East — oppressed indeed by the direst want, but intellectually astonishingly alert — with just pride.
In the enterprise, which is to unite the best intellectual forces of Jewry in the work — the speaker further explained — the object was to present the sum of general and Jewish knowledge, in the extent and in the form corresponding to the needs and the aptitudes of the Jewish masses, in a work which, as regards scientific exactness and originality, should take the best encyclopaedic achievements of other nations as its model. It would therefore be the chief concern of the editor and of his editorial bureaux to enlist the most eminent Jewish specialists, for the general as well as for the Jewish part, for counsel and collaboration. In such participation of our ablest Jewish forces lay the best guarantee for the success of the great enterprise, which, now that its material preconditions were assured, must also be supported as firmly as possible with regard to its scholarly foundations.
In this sense the speaker, in the name of the future readers of the Encyclopaedia and with reference to the ideal purpose of the enterprise, addressed to those assembled the cordial invitation to join the work of the Encyclopaedia as a scholarly advisory board. The address of the speaker, which was very kindly received, was followed by an interesting discussion, in which Privy Councillor Pinner, Prof. Berliner, Prof. Zabludowski, Dr. S. Bernfeld, Prof. Landau, Prof. Meyerhoffer, Prof. Baginsky, Dr. Elbogen and Eduard Bernstein took part. There was no lack of various references to the difficulty of the enterprise, but most of the speakers, while developing their personal views and counsels, did not fail to give warm expression to their particular sympathy for the projected work. Professor Berliner defined the attitude of the Rabbinical Seminary towards the enterprise in a concise declaration. Profs. Pinner and Meyerhoffer suggested to the editor whether, instead of the alphabetical form, an arrangement by disciplines ought not rather to be chosen. Prof. Zabludowski, in very interesting remarks, observed among other things that it was high time to begin the work, since the knowledge of Hebrew was beginning to disappear,
