Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 47 · 20 November 1903
11printed page
scan 11 of 19

No. 46 — "Die Welt" — Page 11

(continued from page 10)

…supporting them financially. After what has been said above, I consider it superfluous to go into this further. But perhaps he arrived at his poetic and well-formed images through the assumption that one could create centres of industry and manufacture there, other Birminghams, Manchesters and Bradfords, and develop the country otherwise than by agriculture. Then I shall tell you that in the neighbouring country, in German East Africa, various experiments were made for fifteen years by German capitalists, that enormous sums of money and scientific care were expended, with the sole result that the country swallowed several million marks yearly to cover the deficit, and that there remain to the mother country by way of recompense only the promised possibilities. The Rift Valley cannot become a night-shelter for 1½ million people, for there are no sleeping-chambers there. For if they do condescend to a modest idea of a small settlement for emigrants, why hang upon it the grandiose shield of an autonomous State?

One must face the fact: in the letter of the Foreign Office there is not a word of an autonomous State, of an autonomous colony; it speaks there of the exercise of religious customs, a free hand in municipal administration, and local autonomy under the supervision of the British Government. And even if it were a complete autonomy, an independent State with a foreign policy of its own, then picture to yourselves this State of 100.000 people on the Equator, 300 miles distant from the coast, cut off from the whole world, and, should a railway bridge collapse, wholly without an outlet. Picture to yourselves a State which for its imports and exports depends entirely on a railway that does not belong to it, which depends on the authorities of the port of Mombasa, and must pay duties as it pleases them. I must confess that I, nationalist as I am, would ask:

"Have you found no better spot on which to plant the Zionist flag? There I should truly have to think of Palestine on the Mediterranean Sea. To be sure, it has always been emphasised that we shall have a Jewish governor. But that is no attraction at all for the Jew. One might just as well say now: because there is a Jewish Lord Mayor in London, I shall go to London.

It is further given as a reason for East Africa that it will become a small drilling-school, in the physical sense, for the Zionists. But there are surely associations in Europe for this purpose, as was shown, for example, by the display of the Jewish Gymnasts' Union at Basle; there are, after all, 100.000 Jewish soldiers every year in the various armies of Europe, where they are likewise drilled. No, if emigrants are sent to East Africa, they will have to remain there.

At Basle the watchword was given out, and in London it was taken up, that East Africa is only a halting-station on the road to Palestine, only a detour. No, Zionism will gain nothing in East Africa, at least nothing for itself; at most it can accomplish something there for the welfare and in the interest of Jewry as a whole, and only in this single direction would I admit the expansion of Zionist activity. Circumstances have brought it about that our Organisation stands at the centre of the Jewish world and draws its eyes upon itself. I should have no objection if in certain respects we co-operated with the other bodies in rendering help to our brethren. If the British Government has found suitable land for a certain number of Jewish settlers, we can be the intermediaries, indeed the controllers. But we must surely understand that this is not our primary duty, and that Zionism cannot go on circuit like an English judge, lending its flag to-day to East Africa and to-morrow to Timbuctoo.

Gentlemen! I consider the idea that East Africa will wash Zionism away too ridiculous. I say, further, that the Rift (Ravine) Valley will never become a dividing ravine in Zionism. If such a rift should arise, it will be the fault of those who with a light heart turn their backs upon all that they have spoken and done for years. Mr. Greenberg declared at a public meeting that he had always been of the opinion that Palestine was not to be obtained with money. The only means, he said, was enthusiasm. Why then, holding this conviction, has Mr. Greenberg remained a Director of the Bank, instead of resigning that post and becoming director of an institute for enthusiasm? He was the intermediary in the negotiations with the English Government and did his work well; must he then also become a destroyer? Must he use the time of the investigation of the question to annihilate all our hopes and bring them to shame? I see no ground for despair in Zionism." The speaker closed with the words that he would never despair of Zionism, even if more attempts than have been made hitherto were to fail, and appealed to all Jews who still stand aloof from Zionism to join the movement. In the ensuing debate there took part: Ob. Goldsmid, Sir Montefiore, Mr. Zangwill and Mr. Bentwich, of whom some, such as Sir Montefiore and Zangwill, broke a lance for East Africa, while Bentwich argued against it. The meeting closed with the customary vote of thanks to the speaker.

From Russia.

Kishineff. As we have already reported, the trial begins on Thursday the 19th inst., before the court with jurors-delegate of the Odessa Judicial Chamber at Kishineff, of the participants in the harrowing murders and plundering of Jewish goods and chattels which were committed unhindered and undisturbed at Kishineff in April of this year, during the Russian Easter holidays. The indictment in this monster trial, which was drawn up by the public prosecutors Goremykin and Tschibelli on the basis of irrefutable data gathered by four examining magistrates, unrolls horrifying pictures of the events of the terrifying Russian Easter holidays of the current year, and at the same time officially and irrefutably corrects the statements, published from competent quarters immediately after the Kishineff murders of Jews, regarding the alleged guilt of our fellow Jews in the origin of the excesses. The version officially circulated at that time, that a Jewish merry-go-round proprietor had ill-treated a Christian woman and thus given the signal for the excesses, is rejected by the indictment, which establishes that the excesses are to be traced exclusively to the incitements of the notorious "Bessarabetz" and to the agitation of representatives of the Kishineff intelligentsia, who, however, "could not be ascertained by the investigating authorities". At the same time the indictment brings grave charges against the Governor von Raaben and against the Kishineff police, who partly tolerated, partly even furthered the excesses. The commandant of the garrison, General Beckmann, received only on the third day of the excesses the written order of the Governor von Raaben to restore order by military force. And in a moment order was restored, but innocent Jewish blood had already flowed in streams, the prosperity of thousands of Jewish families had already been destroyed, thousands of poor Jews had already been made beggars. According to the data of the indictment, which the "Novoye Vremya" also cites, during the excesses 1350 houses, a third of Kishineff, were demolished and the goods and chattels in them destroyed and plundered, 38 Jews killed, 433 Jews wounded. In all 350 persons are accused, 100 of murder, 250 of robbery and plunder; 300 persons were sentenced by the justices of the peace to minor terms of imprisonment for violence, 500 acquitted. Among the Jews in Kishineff a certain disquiet prevails in view of the trial.

St. Petersburg. The Universities of Charkow, Dorpat (Jurjew), Kieff, Novorossisk and Tomsk this year requested the Minister of Public Enlightenment (Minister of Education) to permit the admission of Jews in a number greater than the fixed percentage norm. This intervention, which was called forth by the dreadful position of the Jewish school-leavers who are every year thrown overboard, met with success: Minister Sänger sanctioned the additional admission of Jews as students of the universities concerned. The "Novoye Vremya" has published a spiteful and sharp article against this small relief, in which this paper, which stands close to Russian official circles, declares among other things that the Jews in Russia are not sons of the fatherland and have therefore no right to be admitted to the schools maintained by the State.