Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 47 · 20 November 1903
10printed page
scan 10 of 19

Page 10 — "Die Welt" — No. 46

(continued from page 9)

…of systemlessness can lead to nothing else than the periodic and chronic renewal of the old sufferings, to the spread of the troubles into countries and communities which have hitherto not known them? And who came to our help?

The poor classes have carried their shillings to the Bank, their pennies to the Shekel — their halfpennies to the National Fund, while their rich laugh at us, their preachers and bishops mock us, and their synagogues, which collect hundreds of shillings from each of their members, never hit upon the thought of sacrificing a mite for the struggle to recover the place without which all their prayers would be empty and hypocritical chatter and a base lie. They are now disquieted and ill-humoured at the approach of that venom-spitting and dangerous beast which is called Jew-hatred. They have seen with the deepest dismay the storm of terror break out in Jewry, and they cry out for an organised emigration. Hundreds and thousands of Jews would like the Zionist Organisation to take this initiative upon itself, but a greater number go still further. They would be glad to seize the East African offer at any price, even at the price of giving up our present goal — Palestine — and they say that in that case they would go with us, work with us, and support us with money. Amid this clamorous crowd I see many faces of our former opponents, but also those of many Zionists. The latter are at times even more clamorous than the former.

They demand a complete change of policy, a swift and abrupt turning into the path that leads to the new promised land.

In view of this agitation I should like to offer you some facts and explanations about the offer itself. The Sixth Congress had absolutely no notion of the country; the offer was spoken of as being in some English geographical locality. For even the British administrators and officials who write the annual reports appear to fear that they will be misunderstood, and repeat incessantly that it is not a question of Uganda or Central Africa or any other possessions. I have carefully avoided such misunderstandings and shall report to you merely what can be learned from the authentic and official sources, which are open to all. These are: the two reports of H.M. Commissioner of the East Africa Protectorate for the years 1902 and 1903, the report of the Mombasa—Victoria (Uganda) Railway Committee on the progress of its work for 1901 and 1902, all three published as Parliamentary Papers, and the pamphlet of the Emigration-Information-Office entitled "General Information at to the East Africa Protectorate 1902."

Without in the least wishing to discredit the generous offer, one could clearly state its reason. England, he said, had spent five or six millions on the construction of the Uganda railway line and saw no possibility of drawing any profit whatever from it. It therefore needed a stream of settlers. The lecturer then sketched the general situation of the East African Protectorate, with its 350.000 square miles, with a native population of about 4,000,000 souls and 450 Europeans and Eurasians. He then described, according to the official reports, the climatic conditions of the country and its flora. After he had spoken of the sanitary conditions of the country, which will doubtless be known to our readers from our authoritative reports on the subject, he touched upon the question: how many people, then, can be settled in the projected colony? At the Congress it was said that the territory lies between Nairobi and Mau, that is to say in the Rift (Ravine) Valley. Then I heard that the territory was larger, and I am willing to grant that too. The whole Rift Valley is fifty miles long 40 miles broad, that is to say 2000 square miles. According to the statements of the High Commissioner, however, only the southern part of the valley is suitable for cultivation; let us therefore take only half of the territory and add to it another 2000 square miles, somewhere near Kust, let us say 50 miles long and 40 miles broad. Then we have together a territory of 4000 square miles. Now the question is: how many settlers can it support?

Let us be guided by the opinion of the present administration. To settlers who are not capitalists and who buy land by instalments, 160 acres are offered at once and 4800 acres as land held on pre-emption. Consequently each settler receives in all 640 acres, that is to say one square mile. If one wished to plant the colony in this manner, there would be room for 2000 farmsteads, and if one puts five Jews on a plot where one English colonist dwells, the number will reach the height of 10,000. If we now allot five persons to each farmstead, the total will amount to 50.000, and with the addition of the tradesmen, artisans and townsfolk, the officials, and the civil and military authorities, the number 70,000 is, in my estimation, not too small. I am convinced that this estimate is not to the taste of those who speak of the colony as a new fatherland. I shall not let myself be satisfied by the vague assertions that we shall receive several provinces. Above all, I believe that the local authorities will grant land only where the native population is sparse, and that is, as I made my calculation, in the Rift Valley and the Athi Plains.

Further, I believe that a land area of 4000 square miles in a semi-tropical, virgin country is more than enough for a beginning. The greater the number of settlers' farmsteads, the greater the capital required." The speaker then quotes the data from the report of the High Commissioner, already communicated to our readers, that every settler must possess at least 300 pounds sterling, that the climatic conditions, as in all equatorial countries, are indeed good, but very changeable and therefore productive of disease, that the highlands too, "German" East Africa, likewise suffer from all these drawbacks; further, he points out that agriculture in a tropical country is much more difficult and costly than in a temperate one! For there are difficulties to be overcome which do not exist here, as for example in irrigation, bridge-building, etc. The British Government, he said, is unwilling to bear any costs in the settlement of the country. The matter is consequently left to the Jews alone. Can we then assume that there are 10.000 Jews who possess a capital of 3000 or 2000 roubles and will go to East Africa? The whole settlement, reckoned for 10,000 farmsteads at the minimum cost of 200 pounds for each one, with the addition of the outlay for irrigation, bridge-building, railway-laying, administration, etc., will cost 4 million pounds. Whence is the money to be taken? The time needed for the founding of the colony, he said, is at least 25 years. As regards the regulation of immigration, there are two ways. Either it will be left to individual entrepreneurs, and then it will take 50 or 100 years, or the poor will be let over there by the thousand, and then a year, if not less, will suffice for the news of their misery to shatter the whole plan. The country, he said, is by no means secure, on the side of the native population either.

If this were counted according to the taxes it pays, it amounts to 4 millions. Among them are dangerous and warlike negro tribes, such as the Wanderolos in the dense forests of the Mau mountains, the Nandi in the west, the Kavirondo, the Masai in the south. From this it follows: even if the expedition brings back a favourable report, even if all other conditions are fulfilled, a settlement of 70.000 or at most 100.000 Jews could at best take place. How then can one prattle from Zionist platforms that we can bring a million or even a million and a half there? That, in default of Palestine, we are to accept the Rift Valley as the future home of the Jews, that it resembles the valleys of Surrey, that it will represent an excellent training-school for an autonomous State, a half-way station on the road to Palestine, and so forth? All these assertions are publicly put forward from Zionist platforms before provincials, although the primary questions of the fertility and the situation of the territory are still sub judice, although the Congress has as yet committed itself to nothing whatever, pending the facts. For the Congress has not read the English Blue Books. The Congress knew nothing at all of the country in question. Therefore, and only therefore, I hold it my duty to tell the truth to Zionists and non-Zionists, whom I should like to win for our cause, and not to let them be misled. As if Zionism could cease to be Zionism and become East Africanism! I will therefore analyse these vague assertions and show them their emptiness. First, as regards the million or the million and a half whom Mr. Greenberg will settle without