Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 44 · 30 October 1903
5printed page
scan 5 of 20

No. 44. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.

(continued from page 4)

…betrayed Zionism and mean to give up our goal. "You would sacrifice Palestine," so it rings out in chorus, "the land in which alone the Jews can have a future?" Truly, were the spectacle not so ridiculous, one might be vexed. But we are well used to these methods of combat by now. When we still wanted small-scale colonisation, they were all vehement opponents of the plan. When we advanced to Zionism, they discovered their colonisation-loving hearts, because they thought they could in this way take the wind out of our sails. Now they believe — mistakenly — that we would sacrifice Erez Israel for the sake of East Africa, and at once the dirge resounds over the loss of Palestine, which, alas, they love so dearly. But this time the precious moisture has flowed from the tear-ducts too soon, and they will have to be patient a while longer. A renunciation of Palestine, in whatever form, is out of the question; that we wish to establish once and for all. So long as there is a Zionism, it has but one goal. And that lies beyond the Mediterranean. We do not renounce the hills on which Abraham pastured his flocks and in whose bosom our fathers were laid to rest. We shall not sacrifice the land in which our people was young to any prospect, however alluring.

That such follies could be believed in the other camp is understandable. But whence the agitation in our own tents? There were people in Basle who wept and sobbed like children when the Congress approved the East Africa expedition. And among them were many worthy and capable men. The agitation has since subsided, but the mourning continues. Why, then? Let us call to mind once more what has actually happened. Perhaps we shall then come to a better understanding.

We wished to have the Sinai Peninsula, and it was not given us, for whatever reasons. Instead, England offered us a territory in East Africa. We resolved what had to be resolved with even the slightest political tact: namely, courteously to examine a magnanimous offer. We did not bind ourselves for the future; we did not pledge ourselves to carry out the undertaking. We even laid down that no party funds should ever be put into the project. We reserved to our electors the decision which a future Congress is to make; and it is asserted that we have violated the programme, sacrificed Palestine, and are no true Zionists. And why all this? Because the persecutions of centuries have made us so mistrustful that confidence is lacking even in those who created the whole movement. The expedition was taken for a farce, and people thought: "Once Herzl has his expedition, he will afterwards do as he pleases." Why, who is this Dr. Herzl, then? Some untried combatant, a disciple of the movement newly arisen? The man who created our Congresses, the man who staked his life and his livelihood upon Zion, who defended and fought for the programme, is he suddenly to be a less good Zionist than the gentlemen of the "No"? And the whole Misrachi, which stood up for him in a body, is it to have sacrificed the land which must hold a special value for it? And finally all of us, who have earned many a scar in honest combat, are we all traitors? — — —

There are two possibilities. Either the expedition returns home without result. Then the whole question is settled. Or it reports that the land is suitable for colonisation. Then the Congress will have to pronounce upon it. We will not keep back our own opinion: if the land is really as good as it is described, the Congress will decide for colonisation, without giving up Palestine. It will have to do so, because the necessities of life of the masses defy all ideology. He who lives in constant peril of death, he who trembles for the life and happiness of those dearest to him — he takes what he can get, and goes at least as gladly to a land with Jewish laws, Jewish administration, Jewish life, as to Canada or Australia. For it is the emigrants to those countries who are in question, not the emigrants to Palestine; we shall never summon the masses to East Africa.

A slight confusion has befallen the gentlemen of the "No." They applaud enthusiastically at the words of Schemarjah Levin: "We do not need East Africa; we have Palestine." Unfortunately that is not quite correct. For we do not yet have Palestine; we have it only in thought, and so cannot yet people it. As soon as it is ours, no one will any longer speak up for East Africa. In the opinion of some of our brethren from the East, to be sure, we already have Palestine. But that rests upon their untrained manner of thinking. Since they have no present, they live exclusively in a world of ideas. And there they have thought themselves so deeply into the idea of Palestine that the real actuality escapes them. They have often said to us: "Palestine is our land," so that a nebulous centre somewhere stands ever before their eyes: "our land."

They already live in this land of their longing; they are no longer subject to the Tsar at all. And that is why they call themselves the "better Zionists." But this is an error which must be cleared up. Let them ask the masses, the people that groans and bleeds under the knout! It is not yet in Erez Israel! And we fear that many a dear and honest fellow Zionist will receive no mandate for the next Congress if they grasp realities so little.

Otherwise with the Western European doubters. Thus we heard one delegate say: "Zionism has nothing to do with East Africa: for it is an idea of Jewish thought, which can flourish only in Palestine. The people are a matter of indifference. Night shelters are of no interest." Very fine. But ought not human beings to be the bearers of ideas? An abstract Judaism bears a disquieting resemblance to the knife without a blade that had no handle. Once the Jews have been beaten to death, there is no more Jewish thought either. More serious are the objections of those who fear: "Once we are in East Africa, all the intellects we possess will take part in creating a polity there, and nothing will be left for Palestine. People will feel at ease and forget the national homeland — what then?" We might answer with the customary counter-question: "And if it takes another 50 or 100 years before we obtain Erez Israel, and our people perishes physically and morally in the meantime — what then?" But we will not, for we hope for an early success. Therefore, then: the apprehension springs from an error of calculation. One counts only those present, not those to come. But on the day that brings us Palestine we shall be a mighty army, not only in soldiers but in officers as well. We shall even have trained excellent peasant material in the school on the Kenya. And, most important of all, money too will not be lacking. From our own judgment of the situation we do not believe, moreover, that the leadership lays any stress on Zionism officially conducting the East Africa undertaking, even in the most favourable case. Perhaps a form can be found by which Zionism as such remains altogether out of the matter. All the more reason to wait calmly and composedly for what the expedition will say.

For the present we have sacrificed nothing, broken no programme, bound ourselves to nothing at all, but have won a diplomatic success of which we scarcely dreamed even three months ago. For it depends solely upon the will of the Jewish people whether it will begin a national existence even now, or wait until we are given the last thing that we demand.

Over this one should rejoice, instead of weeping. Let us once be clear about it. We have achieved a success which will perhaps carry us further in Constantinople than all the negotiations of recent years. The straightest road is not always the best to the goal, especially not given the condition of Oriental streets. In carpet-dealing in the bazaar it is very expedient to exchange a few words with the competitor in between. Let us not, then, have our joy spoiled in a success which, it is to be hoped, will not remain our last. And let us remember that Herzl himself, in his closing speech, reminded us of the words: "May my right hand wither if ever I forget thee, O Jerusalem."

*

A Russian Monthly on the East Africa Project.

In the recently issued September number of the respected and influential St. Petersburg monthly "Russkoje Bogatstwo" (Russian Wealth), the eminent Russian publicist I. Iuschakow publishes a lengthy article on the East Africa project which deserves to be made known. Iuschakow, who has already devoted several studies to Zionism, is above all an honest publicist and a true friend of the Jews, to whom the desolate plight of the Jews sincere