No. 43 — "Die Welt" — Page 9
"The meeting, representing the colonists already settled, protests sharply against the project of settling foreign Jews in their midst, and is resolved to ward them off by every means within its power." The resolution was adopted unanimously. It was also decided to communicate the resolution to the High Commissioner and to have it forwarded to the Government. It was likewise communicated by telegraph to Mr. Chamberlain, the author of the project. A standing committee was formed, with Lord Delamere, who was the first to protest, at its head, in order to conduct a counter-agitation.
Yet sympathetic manifestations are not wanting either. Thus, for example, the "East Africa and Uganda Mail" at Mombasa published on the 5th of September an article on the subject, entitled: "The Inheritance of the Jews. It advocates the project most warmly. After recounting the sufferings of the Jewish people it says: "Now we must share East Africa with this peculiar people, with the people that gave us the Bible and the whole sublime history which uplifts our thoughts and teaches us to hope, even beyond death. We should bid the Jews a hearty welcome, for we may be sure that the Jews will bring into our land the blessing of the Ark of the Covenant, that our fair land will be blessed, and that the new colony, fostered by the wealthy Jewish patriots, will become an important factor in the British East Africa Protectorate."
The Bishop of Mombasa spoke on the project on the 6th of September.
He did indeed express his sympathy with the Jews, and called upon his hearers to regard unselfishly the projects which aim at conferring a benefit upon "Christ's own people"; but he held at the same time that it would be desirable to offer the Zionists another territory along the Uganda Railway instead of the one proposed, since this offer injured British interests.
With regard to the resignation of Mr. Chamberlain and the change in English colonial policy bound up with it, the "Jewish Chronicle" of the 9th inst. remarks that this circumstance will hardly affect the East African proposal, since the new Colonial Secretary — Sir Alfred Lyttleton — is well disposed towards the Jews.
*
N. Sokolow writes in his "Hazefirah," No. 223: If the East African proposal deserves attention, it is not the business of the Zionists but of the "Ica" to occupy itself with it. The "Jewish Colonisation Association," which makes attempts at colonisation all over the globe, latterly in Brazil and in Egypt as well, may not leave this proposal unheeded. If it was a dictate of propriety for the Congress not to reject this offer of the English Government out of hand, but to deliberate upon it thoroughly and seriously, then it is all the more the duty of the "Ica," which is, after all, bound to a particular courtesy towards England, not to pass the matter over in silence.
It is possible that the "Ica" will feel itself in some measure bound to do so towards the Jewish people as well. Times change, and the "Ica" changes with them. The Zionists are, after all, no longer so proscribed and shunned. Even those in the "Ica" who speak every evil of Herzl now admit that "he has created a Jewish organisation and aroused an enthusiastic interest in Jewish colonisation." The great gentlemen graciously condescend to negotiate with him and magnanimously enter into correspondence with him.
It was easy to foresee that the one bright spot in the East African question, which had inclined a part of the Zionists towards it, would appear to the "Ica" as its dark side. What made an impression at Basle in the first moment was the announcement of the promised autonomy which the East African proposal contained. I will call the child by its right name: it was the political significance of this proposal that brought it somewhat nearer to Zionism. A great world-power proposes to the Jews that they found a real state.
Our opinions were divided: there were "Ayes" and "Noes." I myself considered the matter well and abstained from voting. The proposal concerning East Africa seemed to me out of place at a Zionist Congress. If it was a question of tact towards England, then the decision ought to have been quite other than one to send out an expedition. I had proposed a resolution to this effect to the Presidium, which unfortunately received no attention.
What sense, then, had the "Aye" or the "No"? Whether East Africa might perchance be "Erez Israel" — such a question does not even deserve the answer: No. There remained, then, a purely technical question: whether one could colonise there or not? But therein lay a mere irony. Who among us knew, whether of the "Ayes" or of the "Noes"? It was a jest, and a — poor one.
Or was it perhaps merely a question of an expedition? That would mean: either "we wish to examine it first," or "we wish to know nothing whatever of it." Let those send out an expedition who have the means at their disposal!
The only "bright spot" for us contained in the letter to Mr. Greenberg was the autonomy (on which I shall yet express myself) and the political tone in which England's proposal to Zionism was couched.
And for that reason the "Ica" had to leave itself a way open. In its communication, the contents of which cannot yet be made known in detail, it declares expressly that the matter must not be a political one, but must be a purely colonising undertaking.
The English Government has no scruple in giving the matter a political colouring, and the "Ica" fears, as usual, that it might appear as though the Jews were founding a state for themselves. No — the "Ica" hastens to emphasise from the very outset — heaven forbid, it is not a state we wish to found, but merely to colonise where we can colonise. We are patriots!
That, too, is policy, but an age-old one, the policy! of timid people, which always asks: "What will the nations say to it?" And how naïve this policy is. Those who wish to say something pay no heed to any declaration, and those who do not wish to speak simply say nothing.
The "Ica" is now prepared to bear half the cost of the expedition, on condition that it consist of three delegates on its side and as many on the part of the Zionists — and even this it does with a certain reservation — but we will not now enter into details.
One thing must be admitted: the "Ica" thereby remains truer to its principles than we Zionists to ours. It is a colonisation society not bound to any one land; it holds to the system of dispersion, and thinks it well that yet one more should be added to the many lands in which it has colonies. An expedition? In God's name! How much has it already spent on expeditions! But the matter is not so smooth; it has something of political autonomy about it; that cannot be claimed for the Jews, and therefore the "Ica," in consistency with its views, protests against it. It remains wholly true to itself.
This protest contains but one more trait of naïveté. Granted that the expedition comes about with the participation of both sides, that the proposal is ac-
