Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 43.
Many points have been set down on which I was to speak to-day. It is superfluous to report to you on the course of the Congress, which is already known to you. There are many questions of which I should like to speak; indeed, the paths of Jewry are strewn with questions that lie deep within us, and that carry within themselves the bacilli of fresh questions which will one day arise.
The development of the Zionist movement has been a remarkable one. At first Zionism had only a comparatively small, though at the same time a comparatively immense, aim — the recovery of Palestine for our people. But circumstances have brought it about that Zionism, which is a synonym for the organisation of Jewry, has been obliged to take notice of everything that concerned Jewry. Here is the point which our critics seem to have forgotten entirely. I believe, however, that one question lies nearest your hearts at present above all, and on that I shall speak in particular — the offer of a colony in East Africa on the part of the British Government.
As regards the place itself, I can say but very little about it, for the simple reason that I know no more of it than the proverbial man in the street. Nothing definite can be said about the prospects of the proposed settlement before the report of the Commission. Above all, we do not know exactly for which territory of East Africa the offer was made. All that we have read about this or that territory is of little use to us, for the colonisation in question is a peculiar one and not to be compared with other attempts at settlement. What may suit an ordinary colonist might perhaps not suit our people, and until we learn the exact conditions and the definite place it is vain to discuss it.
But the policy of this plan we may very well discuss. I will say no word of reproach against those who rose up against this plan. In a movement such as the Zionist there must be room for every honest opinion, even when it differs from our own. The Zionists who raised their voices against the project will doubtless have had the weightiest reasons for doing so, the best intentions and the most perfect honesty, even though I believe they were wrong. Together with Mr. Zangwill I witnessed the scene at the Congress which I shall never forget. I mean the scene that took place after the Congress had resolved to appoint a commission for East Africa. I was in the committee-room of the Russian Landsmannschaft, and I cannot put out of my mind the scene I saw there. Men and women whose feet must still have been slippery with the blood of their massacred brethren, people whose lives were encompassed by unspeakable torments, showed themselves firmly resolved to undertake nothing that might diminish by a single jot their long-cherished ideal — to see our people one day in our beloved land of Palestine.
I would never cry a word of blame to those who were plainly moved by feelings so noble and so estimable.
All this is splendid indeed, but is it a fight? Is it practical Zionism, and is it feasible policy? Were I asked what is the greatest fault of our people, I should say that it is this: that as individuals we are too materialistic, and as a people too idealistic. Were the reverse the case, we should, in my opinion, never have come into the terrible condition in which Jewry now finds itself. It was therefore nothing surprising to me that at the Congress there was in the end a party which felt the plan to be too practical and too little idealistic.
Let us consider some of the objections to the East African plan. There is, above all, the fear that the colonisation plan will diminish our Palestine ideal. Truly, I have never heard anything so absurd. For two thousand years our people has been more or less, or rather more than less, under the iron heel of brutal persecution. It has suffered as no other people... But we see that even to-day, in this twentieth century with all its materialism, our people is steeped as never before in the feeling of love for Palestine, a feeling of veneration for the ancient home of the Jewish race. Is it reasonable to suppose that, because a settlement in East Africa has been offered to a comparatively small fraction of our people, we should forget Jerusalem?
I do not believe it, and if I believed it I would not advocate the colony. I believe that one of the first and most flourishing institutions to arise in this New Judaea will be a strong Zionist society, and I do not doubt in the least that this Zionist society, or this league, will not only be the most energetic and helpful support of our movement, but that it will one day consist of the best type of Jews in physical, mental and moral respects, who will keep faith with this free and blessed land.
A second objection to East Africa is the following: Have you the strength to realise both projects — the Palestinian and the East African? Those who ask thus argue against themselves, because they rate too low the inherent, overflowing love for Palestine, and misjudge the fact that in our movement there will always be people who will stake their lives for Palestine. But the question turns not merely on Palestine. We Zionists forget that avowed Zionists to-day form as yet only a small fraction of Jewry. There may be some one million Zionists, but there are twelve million Jews! This East African project will, I am sure of it, now attract a number of Jews who have hitherto held aloof from Zionism, or indeed from any Jewish movement at all, save that here and there they subscribed for charitable purposes. If we can win these for our East Africa project, then we have built a bridge between ourselves and them that will bring them to us. Believe me, it will not be long before they are Nationalists and Palestinians through and through. Then it is said that our movement is a Zionist and not an East African one. I grant that entirely, but surely you would not wish to put a man into the clothes he wore as a child? In the Zionist movement, the events around us, of which we took no account, have compelled us to extend the field of our activity. We have been shown on the one hand that Palestine is not immediately accessible to us; on the other hand we see that the conditions under which we live demand that we undertake something to lighten the pressure from which Jewry now suffers — which could be accomplished by the establishment of a Jewish colony under the freest and best government that history has ever known.
What, after all, is our movement, if not a movement of Jewish nationalisation? I have always been of the opinion that our movement, instead of the Zionist movement, ought to be called the Jewish National Movement
