Page 4 — "Die Welt" — No. 23
(continued from page 3)
…peasant women to heart's desire. Come, ye enemies of the Jews, behold and admire! Sunburnt, careworn, rolling before them casks full of drinking-water from "מקוה ישראל" over a distance of 2 German miles to Rishon. These people were anxious for the needful loaf of bread for the coming morning, without knowing what was to be undertaken for the coming agricultural year. Whether they would have to leave the place, the beloved place, or stay on and waste away. So stood matters for these people.
Outwardly, however, they were the genuine Friedemann peasants!
Inwardly they were in truth the real layers of the foundation-stone of the ישוב החדש. For once they had set foot upon the soil of the land of their fathers — whatever it might be like — the soil of their ardently longed-for fatherland it is and remains. They swore not to leave it until everything had been tried to win a yield from it.
They took counsel and found that vines would thrive there sooner than any other cultivation.
To be brief, we shall pass over the history of the long years of experiment. Let us rather leave it to the judgment of qualified historians. On the matter itself we wish to remark only this one thing: that iron patience and unshakeable love for the great undertaking were required to hold out on the spot in spite of the numerous sacrifices of human life carried off by malaria and its consequences, until the people attained the possibility of dwelling in suitable, roomy houses and so of being less visited by the malignant diseases.
For the many-hundredth time it must unfortunately be emphasised here too that in malarial regions, if one is to survive, only hygienically arranged houses may be inhabited, and only such make a lasting settlement possible. In the contrary case, however — if, for example, in order to make the establishment cheaper, small houses are deemed sufficient — villages of prosperous appearance and longer duration will hardly be obtained as the result.
Well, the people of Rishon have at last succeeded after all in creating in the Holy Land an extensive district for viticulture, which might serve as a model even in Europe.
That ought properly to lead a Zionist to the one correct and true judgment: "We have so far a wine-growing province with practical, tried vine-dressers. On suitable soil in Palestine our brethren will surely bring into being agricultural colonies just as fine."
Herr Dr. Friedemann complains further of men of independent means who employ Arabs. Ought one, then, to keep a journal of the work which each man performed daily, and of that which he had to leave to others, in order to show it to every passing traveller? Why, must we then, even in the land of our fathers, show ourselves to the German correspondents as the loathsome "Polaken," as they are wont to call the unhappy Polish Jews, in order to be peasants after their pattern?!
Let our German brethren first create model villages and model peasants here, and then point to their more expedient achievements, and only then condemn ours as insufficient!
In Rishon, Herr Dr. Friedemann continues in his argument, there has been the most experimenting. The people are accustomed to farming out of abundance. Spoilt by the imaginary grape prices, made exacting, without ever wishing to attain independence. That is simply not in accordance with the truth. In Rishon almost half the inhabitants are independent vine-growers, who have settled and maintained themselves on their own account. The dependent ones, too, almost all live on the yield of their vineyards. For 6–7 years, moreover, the budget for the communal household has been covered by the colonists — in the first years only in part, later, however, entirely.
What is still lacking for independence?
As regards the imaginary prices, such were paid only so long as it was still believed that the Bordeaux varieties, though producing little in quantity, would yield correspondingly first-class wines. But when it was seen that for especially favourable results one would still have to wait, the prices were reduced, so that here in Palestine higher prices are obtained for Bordeaux grapes among the German vine-growers than among us.
If, at the prevailing prices, one deducts the costs of labour and the communal and government charges, then under the conditions of living here barely the needful bread remains! That is surely still far removed from affluence!
Naturally the people of Rishon will always appear neat and cleanly when receiving guests. Inwardly fully conscious of having fulfilled their duty towards the Benefactor, towards the land, towards the people, and towards every clear-sighted friend of Zion!
The women's labour, too, which the esteemed Doctor brings into the field, appears to one acquainted with the climatic conditions here to be a little-considered observation.
The immigrant generation has acquired the following experience, and paid very dearly for it: of women still young, some have gone blind; others, who have given life to several children, have become wholly anæmic. To this are added the effects of the frequently occurring malignant fevers. Thus almost all of them go about weakened and enervated. The husband is highly content if the wife looks after the household and the upbringing of the children. For the most part, however, the necessary cures consume the whole of the prosperity!
It is to be hoped that coming generations will have sturdier peasant women; for the present, however, all talk about it is merely imagination or delusion.
Acclimatisation and hardening can, after all, proceed only slowly and rationally in the tropics. The many-coloured costumes of the peasant women of Ramleh, who appeared to the esteemed Doctor as Rebekah & Co., are far from furnishing proof of the fitness, for colonisation, of human material that has immigrated from the temperate zones! It simply becomes clear from this that it is far from sufficient to bring people in masses into tropical regions. The real work and the real difficulties begin only on the spot, where in every agricultural undertaking long years of experience must be gathered on its own account, experience that cannot be gained from books and books of travel.
Therefore, if Dr. Friedemann wished to draw lessons for Zionist work, he ought to have stayed longer in the village and considered everything from every side. He would then certainly have come to quite other conclusions, namely: first, that everywhere only that culture is to be introduced for which the soil is suited; secondly, that settlements are to be founded only where the place is free of fever, since otherwise the settlement must inevitably perish sooner or later; thirdly, and this is the most important: that everywhere a mixed husbandry, i.e. viticulture and grande culture, unfailingly proves the best, because if need be the one could replace the other. Fourthly, the dwellings must be arranged according to a physician's instructions, otherwise the most robust race of men degenerates.
