Page 8 — "Die Welt" — No. 42
(continued from page 7)
…shall give thee. Thou shalt not spare them, neither shalt thou serve their gods." (Deut., ch. VII. 16.) "And thou shalt lend unto many nations, but thou shalt borrow of none." (Deut., ch. 28. 12.) Such and similar "promises" seemed for about a century past to be realised on the Exchanges of London, Paris, Berlin and Frankfort, and that precisely through the denationalisation of Jewry. The Diaspora and the gradual absorption of the Israelites by other peoples was apparently the last word of the world's history for this strange nation.
Then, towards the end of the last century, there set in with the Zionist movement a Jewish-national reaction against this process of absorption of the scattered Israelites by alien races. As the name implies, the plan was put forward of gathering the Jews, in the first place the Jewish proletariat, once more around Zion, in the ancient "Land of Promise," and of uniting them into a commonwealth. This concerned chiefly the mass of the Russian Jews, who were becoming more and more inconvenient in Russia and presently found themselves subjected to oppression and expulsion. It appears that the main stream of Jewish emigration after the destruction of Jerusalem by Titus (70 A.D.) and the final dispersion of the people by Julius Severus (135 A.D.) went towards the north-west and remained caught in Russia and Poland. There are to-day five millions of Jews in Russia, who cannot be absorbed by the Slavs, but have preserved their national type as well as their ancient popular customs more purely than anywhere else. Russia wished to be rid of these masses of Jews as far as possible, and accordingly thrust them over the frontiers in batches. But the other States of Europe and America were not exactly delighted by such arrivals either, and hastened to shut their doors against them as far as possible, or else to foist them in turn upon a third party. Thus these wretched emigrants became a veritable plague of the nations, moving hither and thither like a swarm of locusts, everywhere unwelcome, nowhere wanted.
It is obvious that the leading minds in Jewry should have pondered means of settling their pitiable kinsmen somewhere under tolerable conditions of life. Apart from purely humanitarian considerations, it is clear that the social standing of all Jews must be most sensibly injured by the pressure of such a proletariat from the East. Thus arose the plan of Baron Hirsch to open an asylum in the Argentine for his distressed kinsmen. This plan, however, has evidently not found much favour among the Jews themselves. At least it is not known to me that a free Jewish commonwealth has arisen in the Argentine.
The most obvious course for the realisation of the Zion idea would naturally be to acquire from Turkey, if not the cession of Palestine, at least a large concession of land there, and to found a Jewish commonwealth here in the real Land of Promise. Such a commonwealth would, it is true, stand for a measurable time under the suzerainty of the Porte. But the Israelites have indeed been accustomed to such a dependence during the last half-millennium of their history, and with the progressive decay of the Turkish Empire the prospect of full political independence would even rise in the background of this plan. Unfortunately the Sultan has declined to enter upon any concessions whatever in this direction. He is willing to permit the Jews a scattered settlement, but not a compact colony with self-government. With that, naturally, they are not served.
This year, now, the English Government has given the Zionist movement a tangible goal. The Marquis of Lansdowne offered the Zionist Congress at Basle a wide area in Uganda for settlement, with the right of full self-government under British control. With this the leaders of the movement have the most essential requisite for the carrying out of their great idea. Uganda has a temperate tropical climate, is fertile, and is connected by a railway with the coast of the Indian Ocean. It fulfils all the conditions for a colony of people who are ready to earn their bread by agriculture and handicrafts. If the Jews enter upon this plan, a piece of history would be enacted anew on the banks of the Nile, on which they once before had to perform centuries of labour; and perhaps this time, too, a Moses would again be found to lead them back later from the Nile into the Promised Land itself.
That the proposal met with a divided reception at Basle is well known. The Russian and Roumanian Jews opposed it. But the leaders of the movement, Dr. Herzl, Mr. Zangwill, and above all the brilliant Max Nordau, succeeded in bringing about its acceptance at the Congress. Concerning the position of international Jewry Dr. Nordau expressed himself in a manly and self-assured fashion, "We Jews," so he said in substance, "have for centuries made the degrading attempt to assimilate ourselves to alien nations and to give up our own customs and popular usages for their sake. The attempt has failed Let us at last let the mask fall and confess that we are not content with the position which we occupy in the world to-day." In fact the "chosen people" has for centuries played the part of pariahs in the world, and one can very well understand how repugnant this part is to the more self-respecting characters among them. The creation of a State would in any case remove one of the essential causes of this lowly esteemed position in the world; namely, it would put an end to the state of things in which a helpless Jewish proletariat, which is notoriously welcome in no country, is pushed off from one State to another like an unwelcome burden. It is well known that the demonstrations of sympathy in the United States with the Russian and Roumanian Jews spring chiefly from the fear that these might stream off to North America.
In this settlement of the Jewish question the Jewish haute finance has, in the first place, a strong interest, for social, political and humanitarian reasons. It can surely not be desirable to these essentially Europeanised Jews that their distressed co-religionists and kinsmen should, by their mere existence, again and again expose the Jewish name to the contempt of strangers. But the other States too have an interest in this settlement, States in which the "Jewish question" in part leads again and again to internal disturbances and crises. We ought for these reasons to be entitled to assume that the Zionists will lack neither the requisite capital nor international goodwill in the carrying out of their programme.
A far more serious misgiving is the question whether these masses of Jews are still capable at all of coming together again into an agricultural commonwealth. We know that two or three thousand years ago they were essentially cattle-breeders and husbandmen, as the Arabs still are to-day. We know also that under David and the Maccabees they developed decidedly warlike qualities. But what transformations and catastrophes has this people not passed through in two thousand years! In Russia, indeed, as I learn, the Jews still pursue chiefly handicrafts to-day, and also, here and there, agriculture. In the other civilised States of Europe this is not the case; trade and money-dealing are the principal callings to which they apply themselves. Such dealings, however, they could not carry on among themselves alone; nor could any national economy be built upon them. Rather, a national economy requires production that creates values.
However, when men as clever as Max Nordau and Dr. Herzl believe that their kinsmen are capable of returning to such fundamental labours, an outsider may well keep his doubts to himself. Then we may expect that upon the high plateaus to the north of Lake Victoria there will presently develop a commonwealth according to the hallowed norms and laws of the Old Testament, with priests and temples of Jehovah. To be sure, it may possibly turn out to be a parody of historical Judaism, somewhat such as present-day Greece represents in relation to classical Hellenism. The language question alone is an extraordinarily difficult one. Is Hebrew to be restored; or is English to become the language of the country? But the Russian Jews, who are after all to form the main stock of the population, understand no English.
One thing is clear: the educated and wealthy Jews of Europe will not personally take part in the experiment of this national foundation of a State. But for this too we have historical precedents. Already in the time of Christ the Diaspora, in particular the Alexandrian Jewry, was richer and more esteemed than that of Jerusalem. So in our century, too, a half-independent
