Page 10 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 40
(continued from page 9)
…racter is incomparably less dangerous to the national life of its host people than one that seemingly assimilates to it, and which swiftly and surely decomposes the foreign culture, morality and character. But one may find it comprehensible when an agent of the inwardly hollow and everywhere threatened power of autocracy trembles before an open league of its adversaries. Even if Russia's support should prove vain with the Grand Seigneur, who is already succumbing to his present difficulties, the pressure of so tremendous an enemy upon the Jews will, in every attempt at a practical Zionism, bring the new state the greater part of its citizens.
But now, when the hope of regaining the historic homeland has almost vanished, new and surprising tidings came to the Congress at Basle. The British Government has declared itself ready to promote a Jewish mass immigration into its East African colony — the consent of its colonial authorities presupposed. These, indeed, appear to be none too pleased with the projected invasion; but London high finance may well bring a sufficiently strong influence to bear on behalf of its kinsmen to break any resistance stirring from that quarter. It is not, then, from that quarter that danger threatens the new realm; should it prove incapable of life, it carries the germ of death within itself. And it almost seems as though the derided Utopia were really about to take shape. The only question is whether we have to do with the fleeting formation of a moment, or with a creation that becomes history.
Things have not yet gone so far. The report of the commission which received its mandate from the people in search of a home is still outstanding, and only a later Congress has to make the decision. But already one may believe that it will consent to the removal from Zion to Uganda. For, as this year's resolution already proves, it has put water in its wine. It is still ruled by the adroit diplomacy of its creator Herzl, who out of longing and defiance created this mighty movement. The leaders will give the order, and their call will go forth to the Jews in every part of the earth. Will they find the Biblical sites again on Lake Victoria Njanssa? Will the curse of the Diaspora be lifted from the people scattered over all lands?
As always, the solution to the riddle of the future is found in the past. To the question: Will Judah form a state? — the answer lies in a second question: Why has Judah formed no state for thousands of years? Other peoples, too, have lost their independence; they then sank beneath the sea of history and vanished in it without a trace. Not one has lost state, land and language, scattered itself over the whole earth, and yet remained a people. That can have only two causes: an extraordinarily high national vitality and an extraordinarily slight talent for forming states. It is not only the last centuries, in which we see the Jews as instigators or abettors in every destruction of traditional forms, that prove this; the whole history of the Jewish state shows us a people ever critical, dissolving, wholly incapable of positive devotion as subjects. The Jew feels — it is one of the most praiseworthy merits of the Zionists to have brought this truth to honour against all liberal hypocrisies — more nationally than any other people; but his state is the community of all Jews and is entirely independent of any territory or any form recognised in international law. The Jew is no citizen. He lacks the modest capacity for self-sacrifice of organised mediocrity. Here this was once characterised in the following words:
"The Jew has no talent for the state. The most brilliant qualities therefore do not suffice; on the contrary, they only lessen his fitness; what is required is rather: subordination, want of independent personality, absence of the critical sense, self-sacrifice. All this is lacking in this race. A state is formed of individuals of uniform kind; their difference in number, culture and capacity is decisive for its importance. But whether Abyssinian or Frenchman — the citizen is a definite quantity of a definite kind. The Jew is independent, incalculable, always different. In short, the state needs types; but the Jew is almost always an individual, indeterminable and ungovernable, and therefore unfit to be a citizen. For that very reason he is capable of exact criticism, and sees weaknesses and faults everywhere. He is born a reformer, if not indeed a revolutionary. That alone explains his lasting unpopularity among all peoples fitted for forming states, and explains further why he never amalgamated with them. For the admission that the Jews are a people does not yet explain how this scattered stock has dwelt two thousand years and more among foreign peoples without perishing in them. Only if one bears in mind that this race is unfit for the service of the state does the historical phenomenon become comprehensible, that while great nations vanished from history with and without traces, these few human beings have preserved themselves and their kind unchanged. One might almost believe that all peoples sacrifice their best strength to the idea of the state and at last, robbed of what is most their own, perish together with the form of state they created, while those who never let themselves be forced into servitude have thereby also found the secret remedy of eternal life. It runs: Personality . . . . The subject dwelling beside them, who lives in fear and awe of all powers and lets them fix his position and his worth, looks with envy or with bitterness upon the enormous, tenacious independence of the Jews. To him it must appear as presumption when a constraint to which he willingly submits is not borne by others. What he feels to be a self-evident subordination to an authority — no matter by whom appointed — is critically examined by the Jew. The eternal questions of the Jew, which are often turned into poor jokes, in truth explain the Jewish Question. This audacious curiosity, with its terrible "Why?", is a danger to the rulers and a humiliation to the ruled. The Jew is the element of destruction, and therewith also the germ of development. The great upheavals, it is true, have never proceeded from him — for new ideas of his own are very seldom granted him — but he has stood godfather to almost all of them. Capitalism, parliamentarism, socialism, journalism — upon these and upon all other phenomena that determine development he has stamped his impress. One might believe in a purpose in nature when one considers the activity of the Jews. This small stock, whose destinies are so extraordinary, has also an extraordinary position in history. Its task is to prevent mankind from sticking fast to what is handed down, and outworn institutions from enduring for ever. He is an element of fermentation — his enemies say: of putrefaction. Be it so! We are not entitled to judge the mysterious intentions of development. But this mission has roused the hatred of those who cling to what is, and explains quite sufficiently — in my opinion it alone suffices — antisemitism. Therefore the founding of a Jewish realm seems to me a proposal certainly well meant, but without much prospect. The Zionists, wiser than the "liberal" Jews, perceive that the anti-Jewish feelings which occur everywhere and always cannot be a mere accident; but why, then, do they not also understand that it cannot be a mere accident that this stock has always remained scattered over the earth and since the most ancient times has never
