Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 34 · 21 August 1903
14printed page
scan 14 of 36

Page 14. — "Die Welt" — No. 34.

(continued from page 13)

…and no longer to need any subsidies. Rechowoth has already been put on a sound footing and makes a pleasant impression in its lay-out. The peasants of Wad-el Chanin, too, no longer receive any "support." In Pethach Tikwah the greater part of the peasants are independent, while in Sichron, too, the outward appearance is more prepossessing than the inner conditions.

In all these villages, then, a gratifying advance is to be noted since the Ica, or rather the "Comité Palestinéen," took over the administration.

Herr von Rothschild had sunk an enormous capital — thirty million francs is spoken of — into the colonies when he grew weary. In many villages the cost of settling one peasant family still stood at 20,000 francs. Many millions had been squandered to no purpose and only a part invested. Ever fresh subsidies were demanded, and the question of the sale of the wine became burning. Many thousands of hectolitres lay stored in Rischon and Sichron; every vintage brought increasing quantities of wine for which there were no buyers. So the Baron resolved to suspend further colonisation for the time being. He gave a fund of several millions, which was administered by members of the Ica, and himself remained chairman of this committee, which was gradually to put the existing colonies on a sound footing jointly with the Ica, but was to undertake no new foundations.

The Ica, or rather the "Comité Palestinéen," now proceeded with the utmost economy. Land was bought for those peasants who possessed too little ground. Numerous elements incapable of standing on their own feet were removed, which was for the most part to be commended. Unnecessary, on the other hand, was the fact that a part of the day-labourers too, and precisely the best of them, were compelled to emigrate by being deprived of every hope of settlement — and yet precisely these modest and capable people would have offered an excellent stock for another, thoroughly sound and viable colonisation at relatively small cost, for here one had men who knew and loved the soil, understood husbandry, and wished to be nothing else than real peasants! And precisely they had to go! The horsemen of Rechowoth, who once escorted Dr. Herzl in triumph and seemed like the symbol of a free Jewry awakened to new bodily strength, ride to-day across the plains of Australia. Any new settlements whatever were excluded on principle.

Subsidies to the peasants were refused; they were referred to their own strength, and personal labour in the fields was demanded. The tutelary activity of the administrations was restricted, initiative was demanded of the peasants, and in the schools a broad place was given to the teaching of Hebrew. All these are decided merits of the new administration, which are also widely acknowledged by the colonists themselves.

So far as we had opportunity to become acquainted with the officials of the villages, we received throughout the impression of well-meaning, capable and conscientious men.

At last the question of the sale of the wine was regulated. Last year, as we are informed, for the first time since the colonies came into existence, the entire stock of the Hamburg depot was sold — 17,000 hectolitres — and this question accordingly appears, happily, to be solved.

We have thus willingly acknowledged what deserves praise. But in all the proceedings of the Ica there was something jerky. When, for example, it was declared that no obligation was recognised to settle the sons of the colonists as peasants, there was certainly a justified kernel in this. The administration could not burden itself with incalculable obligations for the future. But it was an exaggeration of the principle to refuse any promises for the future even to the most capable of the colonists' sons.

It was certainly well to restrict French in the schools in favour of Hebrew teaching — the peasant who speaks French makes pretensions from the outset, because he thinks that a breath of gentility rests upon him. But why was it not done away with altogether, and the Arabic language of the country taken into the schools instead? It is surely an unheard-of state of affairs that in a whole series of villages no peasant is able to decipher the communications of the neighbouring Arab village headmen! Then, finally, there was a constant hindrance to progress and a rampart against the good will of the officials in the administration at Beyrut, to which the local administrations are subordinate. What did we not hear, in the weeks of our stay in the villages, about this "lord of the colonies"! At every step, from village to village, from men of every calling, the same verdict met us: "Complete want of understanding of the tasks of colonisation, coupled with a great sense of power which thwarts the good intentions of others." Would not the Ica for once examine the correctness of these statements? What we here put forward cannot surely be unknown to it! Why, the sparrows whistle it from the housetops in Palestine! Why does it suffer the general administration to reside outside the country, in Beyrut? What eyes the world would make if we established agricultural colonies in Holland and their director laid claim to the right to live in Paris! Agriculture is as little learnt on the quay of Beyrut as on the Paris boulevards. At the head of a great undertaking belong men who understand something of the matter, and the Ica itself should have an interest in seeing that criticisms such as we hear on all sides in Palestine concerning the gentleman in question are at last silenced.

When conditions had thus been improved, indeed, but further settlement had been brought to a standstill, the administrator of the Tiberias colonies, Herr Kalvaryski, came forward with a new plan and won by hard fighting permission to put it into practice. The plan consisted essentially in the following: one confines oneself to the growing of grain, for which large and fertile tracts of land are available in Galilee, and which moreover has a far more educative effect upon the peasant than the tending of vines. For in vine-growing the peasant in the East is really active only four months in the year, whereas tillage claims all his powers and admits of no long pauses in work. Next, one takes the peasants who are to be settled and lets them bring the land under cultivation themselves. During this year the men live in a common house of great simplicity, without their families, who remain for the present in the finished colonies. When the people have thus been accustomed to simplicity and activity, each is given 300 dunams of land, a little house of two rooms with kitchen and stable, and some thousands of francs for the purchase of agricultural implements, cattle, etc. As soon as the first harvest has been brought in, the people are left to themselves. They conduct their administration quite independently and are controlled by no one, but they also know that they have nothing to expect from anyone under any circumstances. The administration plays only the part of protector in relation to the authorities, somewhat as the German consul does for the Templars of Sarona and Haifa. Besides this, provision is made provisionally for doctor, dispensary and school, that is, until the colony has the means to make itself independent in this respect as well.