Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 28.
Jewish Communal Cares.
On 3 June of this year Herr Ludw. Behr spoke on the subject "From Our Communal Life," on behalf of the Federation of Synagogue Societies, in Dräsel's Festival Rooms in Berlin. Under its energetic chairman, Herr Lewinski, the Federation has in a short time become a factor in Berlin communal life with which one must reckon if one is not to miscalculate. Herr Behr's address has raised its standing still further. A year ago the Federation, in a lengthy memorial to the Board of the Jewish Community, set forth the standpoint of the Federation and the obligation of the Jewish Community towards the private synagogue societies. This document at the time aroused some stir and warm recognition within the circles concerned; a lawyer sitting in the Representative Assembly was mistakenly taken to be its author; now that we have heard Herr Behr's address, we know where the writer is to be sought.
The speaker describes the development of the Jewish Community and characterises the movement that calls itself Reform Judaism as one that leads out of Judaism. He shows how, under the influence of these endeavours and under the cloak of "Liberalism," the institutions of the Community have been allowed to wither, and how it provides adequately neither for divine service nor for religious instruction; even compulsory religious instruction is owed neither to the communal administration nor to any of the more prominent societies, but solely to the efforts of a single individual standing outside the administration. The last tax-list of the Community shows 18,285 souls, and there are not seats for even half the taxpayers, leaving aside women and children and leaving aside the other members of the Community. The speaker pointed out how the difficulty of being able to take part in divine service had produced an indifferentism which has passed from the parents to the children; the founding of private synagogue societies, or rather the strengthening of those existing, had become a saving deed; he rejects the insinuation that occupying oneself with these private societies is a kind of sport for many; he shows what great pains the leaders of these societies undergo in order to fulfil those tasks which the great Community has neglected to fulfil. All these congregations, with the exception of the Reform congregation, desired nothing further than to continue the usages of traditional Judaism. In the same way he describes how the great Community had not fulfilled its duty with regard to the religious schools, and if the existing religious schools of the private synagogue societies were not quite up to the mark, the lack of support on the part of the Community was to blame; yet the societies, according to their slender means, had done more than their duty. By § 2 of the statutes the Community is obliged to provide for religious instruction, an obligation which is merely a consequence of § 62 of the law of 25 July 1847. The Community had fulfilled this duty very badly. Against this he pointed to what was accomplished by the private synagogue societies. A return from 16 societies showed that they maintained 5700 synagogue seats and that about 1200 children receive religious instruction; to this must be added the synagogue at the Potsdam Bridge with 500 seats and 5 permanent officials, and further the synagogue "Addas Jisroel" with 500 seats and 400 schoolchildren, 175 of whom have parents belonging to the great Community. The great Community thus lets the societies and corporations furnish it with 7000 synagogue seats — nearly as many as it has itself in its synagogues — and with instruction for 1500 schoolchildren. The budget of these societies amounts to 119,200 Mk.; to this must be added that of the synagogue at the Potsdam Bridge and the budget of the Adass Jisroel congregation, amounting to 55,000 Marks — in all more than 200,000 Marks. Those 16 societies together receive a subvention of about 27,000 Mk. from the great Community, the Reform congregation one of more than 20,000 Marks. The speaker then deals with the complaint of the school inspectors that the children learn too much Hebrew and too little Jewish ethics; he is of the opinion that the children should learn Hebrew as well and as soon as possible, and he points to the school-books in the schools and libraries of the Jewish Community; here there is much that is not precisely Jewish ethics; as an example he cites library book No. 29 of the Jewish girls' school, "Book for Girls" by Agnes Franz; it contains a poem "The Christmas Rose," a prose piece "Peace be with you," in which the mood of Good Friday is depicted, further a seventeen-page poem "The Christmas Tree," or "Go ye and do likewise." Herr Behr then mentioned a motion (which was believed already buried, but which seems to have been brought to light again) whereby it is intended to fix the subventions to the private synagogue societies in a definite proportion to the tax paid by their members to the main Community, which would amount to an act of violence against the smaller societies. It was surely clear that the poorer congregations must receive a larger subvention than the rich; an assessment of the subvention according to the tax was untenable. The intention of having these private schools and places of worship taken over by the great Community was practicable only if a guarantee were given that the traditional spirit would in no way be violated. He then also shows how, with regard to the care of the Milah and to works of loving-kindness among all classes from man to man, the societies have fully accomplished their task, and he appeals to the communal administration's sense of justice that, in recognition of the necessity of the societies' services, it should no longer resist giving them material support as well. "Not the notion of a petty love of separation, but the honest endeavour to be the guardians and nurturers of a traditional Judaism free from all assimilating schematism, is embodied in the private societies." Having already pointed out at one point in his address that the younger generation, thanks to the winning power of Zionism, is far less indifferent and indolent than the older, and no longer wishes to deny its Judaism, he closed with the exhortation to go vigorously to work, in order to combat the spirit that leads out of Judaism, so that it may be possible, above all in the children, to awaken anew a love for the traditions of our religion and of our people.
These remarks, borne by a glowing love for the Jewish cause, were rewarded with abundant applause from the numerously attended meeting.
In the discussion Herr Klausner demanded that the great Community should be divided into districts and that the private societies with their rites should be the bearers of these districts, so that those persons who know the situation in the private societies would be called to become the leaders of the districts. Klausner then sought to interpret the speaker's dissatisfaction with the communal institutions as a dissatisfaction with the Communal Representative Assembly, above all with the leaders of the Central Society, who had not redeemed the word they had given the electors.
Herr Heimannsohn made use of an old election leaflet to polemicise somewhat against the Liberal Society, while Herr Weinberg took the Central Society under his protection.
Herr Dr. Klee argued that the Central Society had indeed in its day done good for the Community, but had for a considerable time past been entirely stagnant, because it seemed in many cases to lack suitable personalities. Everything that felt fresh and lively and Jewish must unite in Berlin in a cartel, in order at the next election to send into the council-chamber of the Community men who would know how to join faithful attachment to historic Judaism and its institutions with an understanding of the great present tasks of the Jewish people.
After the unanimous adoption of a series of resolutions the meeting closed. J: z Berlin.
Letters from England.
II.
The resolution of Mr. Leopold Schloss concerning the Kischenew massacres at the last meeting of the Anglo-Jewish Association, held on 22 June of this year — namely, that "a special committee be appointed for the organisation of a public protest meeting, which meeting should if possible be attended by sympathising Christians" — was rejected by a large majority of votes. We Zionists were prepared for such an outcome beforehand and were by no means surprised. What is interesting about it, however, is the following: In my preceding letter I asserted that the leaders of the "Anglo-Jewish Association" were after all beginning to doubt English sympathy for the Jews. The little word "if possible" in the resolution quoted above speaks for the truth of this assertion of mine. "The meeting should if possible be attended by sympathising Christians!" There lies the rub! The English Jews in the twentieth century, for all their much-vaunted emancipation, have doubts as to the possibility of winning the sympathies of the Christians for the Jews, even for such as have been cruelly maltreated, plundered and murdered. The discussion which followed upon the resolution brought out many interesting points — interesting not because they persuade the Zionists
