Page 8. — "Die Welt" — No. 20.
(continued from page 7)
...had become", but all the same, for him the emancipation of the Jews is synonymous with a recognition of capitalism.
So much for Sombart's "historical conception of the Jewish question". His views coincide approximately with those of the political economist who for the first time recognised plainly and clearly the economic content of the Jewish question, without, it is true, having set it forth exhaustively. I mean the already-named Wilhelm Roscher. Like him, Sombart too fails at the decisive point, from which it is but one step to the full comprehension of the problem. Whence this failure comes, the following discussion shall show us.
Roscher writes:
"If we bear in mind the restless activity of the Jews in regard to the commerce of that time, and further the circumstance that the development of an independent burgher class in Europe falls in the 13th and 14th centuries, we shall understand why the persecutions of the Jews in the later Middle Ages are to be regarded as a product of commercial competition, as credit crises of the most barbarous kind, as a mediaeval form of what is nowadays called social revolution."
Accordingly Roscher concludes that "the persecutions of the Jews in the Middle Ages began when the growing burgher class became ripe to take upon itself the commercial services which the Jews rendered to the national economy, and therefore to begrudge them to the Jews".
So clear an exposition can spring only from a deeply historical way of viewing things. It is no accident that precisely the greatest political economist of the old historical school also recognises most clearly the economic content of the Jewish question. For this problem is to be solved only as a historical one and in a historical sense.
In spite of the high degree of insight which one finds in Roscher, he was nevertheless unable to grasp the question at its root, since he does not know how to solve, indeed does not so much as touch upon, the question of the Whence in regard to the "restless activity", which is identical with Sombart's "incarnation of the capitalistic-mercantile spirit".
Sombart's position on this point will also explain Roscher's view.
Sombart does indeed touch upon the question of the Whence, and in his recently published work "Die deutsche Volkswirtschaft im XIX. Jahrhundert" he instructs us that it is the "will, not to be diverted from its goal by anything," living in the Jewish race, that makes the Jews so highly fitted for the capitalistic economic system. Sombart is here entirely consistent in the sense of his theory, which admits as "the ultimate causes to which we would trace social events" only "the motivation of living men". The moment one contents oneself with this — and Roscher too will have paid homage to this thoroughly spiritualistic view, which in itself is no new theory — one can, to be sure, hold the tenacious will of the Jews responsible for all the misfortunes of our people.
If, however, one regards this will as conditioned and limited by economic premises, if one stands, that is, on the ground of a materialistic conception of history, then one looks for the material factors which have produced this will.
Thus Sombart, through his departure from the Marxist conception of history, arrives at no full comprehension of the Jewish question; for precisely at the decisive moment, where it is a matter of putting the question "Whence", he substitutes the "motivation of living men", the tenacious will, for the historical fact of the taking over of the capitalism of antiquity by the Jews, through which the mercantile spirit, the commercial spirit, or whatever one may choose to call it, was only secondarily bred.
In a recently published essay I have attempted to carry Sombart's work further at the decisive point in the sense of the materialistic conception of history.*)
In conclusion it should further be mentioned that Sombart too has not been spared the reproach of being an antisemite. Nothing is more foolish than that. Sombart is a purely objective investigator, and contents himself with establishing what is. What he himself thinks of this reproach he communicated to me lately in a letter.
"There are still people, you see," he writes, "who take everyone for an antisemite who records the existence of a Jewish people with particular racial characteristics."
On the future of the Jews Sombart has not yet expressed himself. For the present he holds that if one "takes one's stand on the modern development of economic life" — and he does take his stand there — one must recognise the existence of Jewish economic agents as one of the greatest advantages.
Towards the Zionist movement Sombart apparently still stands as an observer. He does, however, regard the idea of founding it mainly on an economic basis as an extremely happy one.
Tribune.
A Suggestion for the National Fund.
Dear Sir,
I follow the growth of the National Fund with the greatest interest. I await the weekly return each time with impatience. And for a long time now it has struck me how few Zionists and Zionist families have pledged themselves to a weekly contribution. I find it simply incomprehensible that the Zionists who stand within the Organisation do not regard it as their duty to pay every week a fixed contribution to the National Fund, were it only a few Heller. I address the appeal to all my fellow Zionists to take part in the weekly contributions to the National Fund, and to induce all their acquaintances, friends and relatives to do likewise. It is in the National Fund above all that it will be shown how far the real enthusiasm and self-sacrifice of the Zionists extend. There let them prove that they are in earnest in their concern for the future of our people.
With the highest respect, yours faithfully, Jochanan Meyer.
*
Dear Sir,
Allow me, I pray, to find room in your esteemed paper for an important suggestion. It is an often-discussed and gratifying fact that the victoriously growing success of Zionism is in great part to be ascribed to the enthusiastic collaboration of our youth. But apart from the fact that, alas, only a part of that youth is animated with love and enthusiasm for Zionism, this youth is already too far advanced in years to be able to win the high goal by its struggle. Now Frau Hermine Hartman, in her excellent essay which appeared in your valued paper on the 10th of April of this year, points to the path upon which we ought energetically to enter; she says: "If ye would secure the Zionist ideas for the future, then bring up the children to Zionism." How can this now be done with success? We parents
*) Die moderne Judenfrage. Von den Grundlagen der jüdischen Wirtschaftsgeschichte und des Zionismus. Wilhelm Koebner, Breslau 1903.
