Page 14 — "Die Welt" — No. 18
Feuilleton.
Prof. Dr. Moritz Lazarus.
A Portrait of a Thinker. By A. Coralnik. (Conclusion.)
If one seeks the centre, the focus of his view of the world, one finds at the heart of his thought an idealism without equal — but an ethical idealism. Ideas guide the history of mankind, as they do the life of individuals. ("Ideen in der Gesch.," Zeitschr. etc. III.) They are reflective (ideas of apprehension) and prefigurative (ideas of formation); they are ideas of being, of ought, and of can. They explain, guide and create the life of men. Their effect is: the perfecting of personality; the creation of ideal works; the creation of social institutions. The perfecting of personality leads directly to the closer union of individuals, to the life of a people (Ideale Fragen, p. 107). These ideas are of the ethical order. But are they also grounded in nature? Or, in other words, are the moral and the natural world identical? Lazarus does not accept Kant's grounding of morality as a postulate of practical reason, yet neither does he hold it to be identical with the laws of nature. "We do not seek the ideas in nature, but we find nature, the full and true thought of it, only in the ideas." And then he says further — and herewith we arrive at the root, at the deepest depth of his philosophy — that the purposiveness of nature (teleology) is undeniable, and that the Author of nature is at the same time the Author of the moral law. It is this thought, the quintessence of all Jewish thinking, that leads him to the creation of his last work, the crown of his labours, "Die Ethik des Judentums" (The Ethics of Judaism).
The fundamental principle of Judaism, the moral order of the world, is the pillar of his whole ethical system. The origin of morality, he says in another place (L. d. S. III), must not be sought, with the Eudaemonists, in the feeling of pleasure or pain, but in the "feelings" of morality. Although an indirect influence of Herbart's ethics appears here (Herbart, with Jacobi, puts feelings in the place of concepts), the further development of the thought shows the true source of his outlook — the Jewish religion.
If it can be said of any philosopher that he was "God-filled," it was Lazarus. He was so in a higher sense than Spinoza, because he was a lesser thinker, a less mighty mind, but greater in faith, greater in heart. And "the heart of the national spirit is religion," Lazarus held (Ideale Fragen 28). We need not occupy ourselves longer with the ethical system of Lazarus; it is the modern, philosophical expression of the ancient Jewish religion, whose summit lies in the maxim: Holy shall ye be" ... for "ye are my children." Sanctification, the divineness of life — that, according to Jewish morality and to that of Lazarus, is the fundamental determination of ethics, of life. But ethics is not something mystical, transcendental; it is a wisdom of life, and in this he agrees with Spinoza, from whom he otherwise differs radically: wisdom is the contemplation of life (Sapientia non mortis, sed vitae meditatio est.) Hence also comes the optimism that is the fundamental trait of the Jewish national character, and not the pessimism, as Muret thinks. (L'Esprit juif, p. 45.)
It would be interesting, though it goes beyond the limits of the present essay, to examine how and in what respect the Jewish philosopher of the nineteenth century, Lazarus, differs from him of the eighteenth — Mendelssohn — of the seventeenth — Spinoza — and of the thirteenth — Maimonides. It might yield an interesting analysis of the Jewish national psyche. But let one thing above all be established: none of the more recent Jewish philosophers, Mendelssohn not excepted, was so specifically Jewish as Lazarus. And thereby he himself confirms his saying: "The philosopher, in his musing and thinking, thinks nothing other than what is the substance of the national spirit." (Ideale Fragen 21.)
Having now sketched the figure of Lazarus the thinker, we will pass on to his second, more general character, which we have already touched upon: Lazarus as Jew.
De mortuis nil nisi bene. And of Lazarus one must speak only well; yet we experience a painful feeling when we see him, the far-sighted and finely perceptive student of national psychology, he who saw the highest aim in the development of individuality, forgetting his principles precisely in regard to the Jewish people, to which he belonged body and soul, "true and free." Whoever reads his addresses "What is National?" and "To the German Jews" (Treu und Frei, 1887) is overcome by a melancholy feeling in view of the unedifying twists, the sophistical turns of thought, which the otherwise so strictly logical thinker was obliged to employ in order to convince himself and others that the Jews are not a people but a confession. Exactly the same thing was said at the end of the eighteenth century by Mendelssohn, in whom it was not to be wondered at — he was a son of the "age of Enlightenment," of rationalist thought — but Lazarus, who admitted racial character, if only indirectly, who, going further still, took the will of the individual to belong to some nation or other as the determining factor in the question of nationality — did it not dawn on him, then, that a national will, a national spirit, to speak in his terminology, is ineradicable, that it depends upon inner, unconscious motive forces? Did he not know it, then — he who reproached Herbart with having left the unconscious element in psychical life out of account?
Did it not dawn on him, then, that the Jewish people cannot draw a line under its whole history and deny itself? Had he, instead of combating antisemitism, instead of being quite discouraged and broken by it, as befell many another "German," for example Berthold Auerbach, rather summoned the Jewish people to consciousness, to action, to the realisation of its ideal — how much more fruitfully might his activity have prospered! But he did not do so, for he was a child of his time; he was too much the idealist, he reckoned too little with life, to perceive the true state of affairs. We will not impute to him any assimilatory tendency, for he was no assimilationist, but one of that race of giants of the heart who arise and have arisen in Judaism, who would embrace the world, "embrace millions." He was an idealist pur et simple, and therefore he did not understand life!
*
But Lazarus attained his highest perfection in the most universal human quality — as a man, as a moral individual. Seldom indeed have philosophers taken their teachings so seriously as he; seldom have life and thought, doing and striving, been in such harmony as with him. One of his best monographs treats, characteristically enough, of the heart. "Toutes les grandes pensées viennent du coeur." In him this great saying proved true. In the records we have of his life (cf. Brainin: Haschiloach vol. V, and Achiassaf 1896) we find a characteristic episode: A rabbi from a town near Kowno came to Berlin to undergo an operation on his eyes. He had a letter of recommendation to Lazarus, and on the strength of it demanded that he give him some hundreds of marks for the operation. Lazarus advised him to apply to richer men, but the rabbi answered proudly: "I am no beggar and take no alms; if it suits you that I should be blind, it is fair enough to me too, and I shall travel home." That had its effect on Lazarus, and he procured the money for him. What a lofty morality, almost touching upon the Nietzschean, is contained in this simple, even somewhat comical story! A dreamer, a sage was Lazarus all his life long, in every circumstance of life, proud and humble, true and free!
With the words he spoke of Mendelssohn I would close my sketch: "The thoughts he put forward are neither subversive nor foundational. He is not one of those systematic philosophers who open the way to new directions of thought. But he belongs nevertheless to those whose life's aim is set upon raising men one step higher." And even if the intellectual creations of Lazarus have been outstripped by the advance of scientific knowledge, even if his national ideas have been refuted by history — as a moral human personality striving towards the light of the ideal, Lazarus stands — Aere perennior.
