Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 17 · 24 April 1903
3printed page
scan 3 of 20
Facsimile · scan 3 of 20
Scan of p. 3
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 17 — "Die Welt" — Page 3.

(continued from page 2)

…then the chief question, that of the Jews' right of residence, must first be settled. As regards the substance of the new bill, it must be said that no considerations can justify the creation of a law which, by its severe restrictions of the rights of the Jews, will inflict great economic injury upon many millions of subjects of the Russian Empire, not only of the Jewish but also of the Christian faith. Moreover, the law will also draw unfavourable political consequences after it, by increasing the discontent of the broad strata of the population affected by it, the more so as the new bill does not even shrink from annulling rights to immovable property already acquired by the Jews by lawful means. In order to fulfil the Imperial commands, which stand as marginal notes on the reports of the Governors of Smolensk, Pskow and Nowgorod, the Jews should henceforth be categorically forbidden to acquire immovable property outside the towns in the interior Governments, without touching the rights of ownership already acquired by them; at the same time, however, a revision should be proposed of the restrictive regulations of 3 May 1882, by which the rights of the Jews in the Pale of Settlement were so curtailed that the pressure of the Jews towards the interior Governments must be regarded as a consequence of these restrictions."

The Minister of the Interior, Secretary of State von Plehve, set forth, among other things, the following: "The economic benefit which the Jews bring our fatherland is to be doubted. I am, however, convinced that the activity of the Jews carries into every sphere of our political and social life principles which are harmful. I am therefore not in favour of alleviating the position of the Jews; but in the choice of restrictions upon the rights of the Jews one must be very cautious, for in some cases these restrictions create fresh inconveniences in our political life. Thus the restrictive regulations of 3 May 1882, which were created for the Jewish Pale of Settlement, have led to this: that the Jewish population, herded together in the towns, has no means of livelihood; the Jews who have become beggars, living under insanitary conditions, form a danger to the public health and to public order, while the Jewish youth, growing up without supervision, forms a material ever ready to take up revolutionary ideas and to take part in the anti-governmental movements. New curtailments and restrictions might make this situation still worse, while the practical results to be hoped for will not come about so quickly, in view of the tactics of the Jews in being able to evade the laws."

The commission at length passed the resolution "unconditionally to prohibit to the Jews, outside the bounds of the Pale of Settlement, the acquisition of rights of ownership, and the possession and lease of immovable property situated outside the towns, and to suspend the execution of all public deeds of that kind."

In order, however, to take from the Jews the possibility of failing to observe this prohibition by evasion of the laws, it was resolved that Jews who acquire rights to the possession of immovable property by unlawful means or by means of fictitious documents shall be subjected to administrative banishment. The commission even declared that the Minister of the Interior might extend to such Jews the operation of the law of 7 December 1895, under which persons endangering the public peace are liable to deportation. All these resolutions, which were passed unanimously, now await the sanction of the Tsar. Gt.

A New Letter of Zangwill's on the ICA.

To Zangwill's letter in the "Times" on the millions of Baron Hirsch, already known to the readers of the "Welt," there came an answer from Mr. Lucien Wolf, a member of the "Ica," in which he remarks among other things that the Zionist endeavours did not deserve to be taken seriously by the men of the "Ica." In rejoinder to this there has now followed a second letter of Mr. Zangwill's in the "Times" of 17 April, which we reproduce verbatim:

With reference to Mr. Lucien Wolf's letter, which appeared in your paper ("Times") on the 11th, I should like to communicate to him the interesting news that the criticism I lately directed in your columns at the Hirsch Committee has had its effect, in that the points of the proposed Act of Parliament against which I most strongly set myself have been hastily withdrawn. The Bill itself, however, which has as its object the legalisation of its (the Hirsch Committee's) doubtful position, is likewise the consequence of my earlier criticism.

Thereby, however, the diversion of the millions from their proper colonising function has been averted, although, as I know, two philanthropists — not Zionists — still take up a hostile attitude towards the Bill. The negligent dragging-out of the Bill, together with the costly and troublesome manner in which the Association means to carry it through, attests anew the incapacity of the Committee to solve its Herculean problem. And indeed, an academic council hostile to Jewish feeling, which meets once a month and is informed only by paid officials, has no hope of accomplishing anything, especially when nearly 200 institutions are to be subsidised. In counselling them concentration in Palestine, or failing that in some other country, and the harnessing of their millions to the motive power of popular enthusiasm, I point out to them, in my best belief and for the best success of the cause which truly lies near their hearts, the only possibility of successful colonisation.

It bespeaks a curiously twisted and philistine standpoint when a Zionist is accused, for this advice to use the money in such a way, of hatred, envy and more such uncharitableness.

As though Zionism were not striving to accomplish the very task for whose accomplishment the Hirsch millions exist — albeit, alas, in vain! Mr. Lucien Wolf sets our sterility against the deeds of the Hirsch Committee. I maintain that these substantives ought to be transposed; but in any case he strangely forgets that the Committees began to work with nine millions, the Zionists without a Heller. Had the Hirsch Committees begun seven years ago to prepare a centralised Jewish home for the unhappy wanderers of our race, London would today have been spared an anti-alien agitation.

Mr. Lucien Wolf, seeking to defend the Committees against the charge that they neglect their duty through their ignorance of the Zionist movement, asks: "What is there, then, in the activity of the Zionists that should arouse their curiosity?" He might find the answer in an excellent article on Zionism in the "Encyclopaedia Britannica" from the pen of Mr. Lucien Wolf: "The Zionist movement is today the greatest popular movement that Jewish history has ever known."


Jewish Oriental Colonisation Company*)

(Scha'are Zion).

PROSPECTUS.

The steadily worsening political and economic conditions in precisely those countries in which the main mass of the Jews is settled compel a number rising from year to year to emigrate. By tens of thousands they scatter, without plan or goal, to every point of the compass, and not only are for the most part lost to Judaism, but also fall, in the new land, into the old distress, since they

*) In accordance with the wish of our esteemed friend Dr. Franz Oppenheimer, we publish an extract from the prospectus of a Jewish Oriental Colonisation Company which, although a private undertaking, is nevertheless of undeniable interest to us Zionists. The Editors.