Page 4. — "Die Welt" — No. 16.
(continued from page 3)
...to him the low level of the intellectual life even of that part of the nation which the lawgiver intends to be its élite. He will doubtless have seen there again many an old hero whom he had formerly portrayed per satiram, but certainly also many a new one whom "Clio" has not yet recorded.
He may well also have thought of his poor friend Zola, who foretold all this, who had prophesied that peace neither could nor would return to France until the shroud had been cut through beneath which a band of criminals and dupes sought to stifle truth and justice — two expressions for one idea.
One man, a courageous man, an honest man, Jean Jaurès, has undertaken, in spite of the dissuasion and resistance of timid friends, to reopen the "Affair." He did so with much temperament, with brilliant, sweeping eloquence, with compelling logic of proof — but with far less skill, and therefore with only half a success, as even blinded optimists must admit.
In the first place it was a mistake that the revelations were announced so long in advance. We grant, in all objectivity, that it is not with them as with announced revolutions, which are wont to fail to appear when they are foretold. They contained much that was really new, which had indeed been suspected but not known with certainty, and in some respects — for instance as regards General Pellieux — they were astounding. But the first news — that Jaurès, the famous orator, a leader of the Socialist party, well known from the earlier Dreyfus Affair as a warm defender and advocate of the condemned Jew, had at last found the long-sought "fait nouveau," the new fact which must of necessity lead to revision, and cherished the firmest confidence that by virtue of it he could strike the decisive blow against the party of the forger-generals — this first news, cleverly launched, aroused the most general suspense. And then weeks upon weeks went by, but Jaurès kept silent; the well-disposed began to believe that Jaurès had been mistaken or had himself been deceived. But Jaurès kept silent; he kept silent now against the advice of his friends, who feared that in the meantime the opposing parties would bring the wavering groups of the government parties to defection, and who wished to carry the doubters along by a swift and decisive thrust. That was the first mistake.
When Jaurès at last took the floor on the occasion of the debate on the election of Syveton — some insignificant Nationalist, who, by the way, had to pay the reckoning on this occasion, his mandate not being verified — "then it would not let him go." He spoke too long, and that was the second mistake.
The third mistake is a rhetorical one, but is no doubt connected with the one just named. Had Jaurès been briefer and finished his speech at one stretch, the effect of Dr. Dumas's report would have been quite another thing. The arguments more closely packed, rattling down thick as hail upon the dumbfounded reactionaries, no twenty-four hours' respite for reflection for the weaklings and the ambitious in the ranks of the Republicans who stood ready to fall away; after the Brisson-Cavaignac scene, Dr. Dumas's narrative and the War Minister's declaration — the Jaurès order of the day, which was the Government's own order of the day in truth, would have been adopted by a colossal majority. That was the third mistake.
Fourthly, the clumsiness of the Socialists, who by an interjection needlessly insulted the whole army, gave the Right the opportunity of playing its protector, and did many a man of divided mind on the left side of the House the kindness of being able to show himself a patriot.
These are some of the mistakes which on mature reflection could surely have been avoided, which must surprise one in so practised and experienced a parliamentarian as Jaurès, and which brought about the lamentable result that we now propose to discuss.
Jaurès had introduced an order of the day according to which the Government was to be charged by the Chamber with instituting an inquiry into the Rennes verdict and with drawing all possible consequences from it. This order of the day was to serve the Government, as it were, as a backbone in its undertaking to bring the Affair to a close in the only right and possible way.
We remark here in parenthesis: we take the standpoint that the Dreyfus Affair in itself belongs wholly to the domain of justice. Through the parties of darkness and reaction it has been carried into the political field, and has there become the shibboleth by which friends know one another. Only under compulsion, in order to reach the opponent at all, do we Jews follow when a matter of justice is turned into a matter of confidence in a wavering Government,
With this reservation of principle, we acknowledge it to be right that the truly liberal parties wished to support the Government in its efforts by means of the order of the day mentioned. It did not succeed, and that gives food for thought.
It proves, for one thing, that many deputies judged the temper of their constituents to be that they wanted peace from the vexatious Affair at any price. There is no doubt that there exists in the country a widespread, dogged, passive resistance to the reopening of the Dreyfus Affair, to the overcoming of which a better staging of the matter could probably have contributed much.
Let the following serve to illustrate what has been said: Marcel Collière, in a recently published essay, discussed the attitude of the French Catholics, and wrote in it:
"I have a friend who is a Catholic, and neither a friend of the army nor an anti-Semite; he does not dream of a great 'France for the French,' of a France subjected to the discipline of Rome and from which all Jews, Protestants, Freemasons, freethinkers, etc., have been carefully weeded out. My friend holds that many Catholics think as he does, and is exceedingly astonished that I meet his words with disbelief. I put to him how the Catholics had conducted themselves in the Dreyfus Affair, whereupon he replied that he himself, after all, had been a declared partisan of revision from the first day. He will not admit that his case has few like it. One day I find him absorbed in reading a book which contained ideas similar to his own: the work of Leon Chaine, 'The French Catholics and their Present Tribulations.' 'As you see, there are at least two of us,' he called to me, laughing.
Quite right! Two, and perhaps a few more besides, but in any case only a vanishing minority. Chaine himself confesses that for many a Catholic can only be an anti-Dreyfusard, but believes that if the whole question, as at first appeared to be the case, had not left the lawful ground of jurisdiction, then in the Affair it