— 18 —
(continued from page 17)
...the opposition group there is disagreement on this question. Now in country A the opposition fights for the taking-up of economic activity, while in country B the opposition, from the same principles as in A, resists its taking-up.
If the oppositions in A and B are united within one organisation, they will come to an understanding, perhaps explain their differing positions, rightly enough, by differing conditions, and thereupon agree, should the majority not give way, to bring about a party crisis by open resistance. To avoid this, nothing will remain for the majorities in both countries but to give way. For a young party, above all, will hardly proceed rigorously with expulsion.
It will certainly be objected that so exceptional a case is scarcely likely to occur; to this, however, it must be replied that even the mere appearance of the possibility must be forestalled. For let us not deceive ourselves: it is better that something old — bad, if you will — should remain in existence (we are sufficiently adherents of the materialist conception of history to know that it cannot, after all, endure in the long run) than that the discipline and organisation of a fighting party should be put at stake, be it even for the sake of something good. "Organisation is everything" holds good with us as well.
Opposition within a party is necessary. But it may assert itself only within the party. The moment it seeks to gain validity beyond it, organisation turns into separation and disorganisation.
The development which the two chief groupings of our party, the Misrachi and the Democratic-Zionist Fraction, have passed through in the past year should prove the truth of the foregoing lines.
The "Misrachi," which by reason of its uniform view of the world and its uniform principle is by far the stronger grouping than the Fraction — which, with the catchword "democratic," could but poorly conceal the weakness of its programme — both have the chief part of their adherents among our Russian party comrades. Naturally the attempt to gain a firm footing in Western Europe was bound to fail, not because the principle of the Fraction was a bad one, but because the conditions out of which it was born were Eastern European, and opposition in Western Europe demands quite other forms and activity, above all only such forms as can do no harm to the discipline of the party. At this point it must be stated — to forestall any misunderstanding — that such undertakings as the Jüdischer Verlag, the Bureau of the Jewish University, and the Statistical Bureau are the work of individual fellow Zionists and have nothing to do with the Fraction in Western Europe.
To be sure, the efforts at grouping have brought forth one good thing. They have shown us that reform must proceed from below, from the national committees — not from the Congress in purposeless demonstrations. If evils exist, let one work within the national organisation and group oneself there into powerful opposition groups. If the evils in the various national organisations are the same, then at the Congress too the opposition will be a united one quite of its own accord.
That, then, is a healthy, desirable opposition, of which one may expect that it will submit to the majority. Everything else is separation.
From Gymnastics to the Schehechionu.
Dear Madam!
Years have rolled from the wheel of eternity since I last wrote to you. At that time our movement was in its frail youth: the Toynbee Hall in the making, the Jewish Gymnastic Club an experiment, and the National Fund a beautiful idea.
Since then our hopes and thoughts have taken on flesh and blood — sturdy flesh and young blood. There is a stirring and stretching among the Jewish people, full of quiet joy of life and assured beauty. —— — You will forgive me, dear Madam, if I now change my tone — I must become a little solemn. In the Ronacher ballroom, with its bright, supple, baroque splendour, there I had to be merry in proper style; there we all clapped our hands, laughed and cheered — while secretly we swallowed tears of joy.
That happened when sixteen Jewish girls moved in a charming round dance — — Laugh if you will — — the girls wore a becoming gymnastic costume in the national colours. From the platform fluttered the banners of Judah. To the strains of a gavotte they turned, formed original figures, parted and met again, danced and stepped — beautifully and surely. When they marched off with firm step at a brisk pace to ringing music, our applause drowned the music.
But I promised to become solemn with you — — Do you know what occurs to me? We are really living in a strange time. We are enjoying singular first performances for which the rehearsals have been held for centuries.
Perhaps, however, it is only a dress rehearsal before an invited audience. But no, we are not spectators; we are old actors, and we are playing in a great drama which began in blood and fire, found its continuation in hunger and want, and is now striving towards a reconciling close.
All that we are experiencing for the first time: the great Maccabean celebrations, the first Congress, attended by delegates of Jews of all lands, a bank founded by Jews which serves only the humane purposes of its own people, and for the first time — I venture the comparison — for the first time a Jewish gymnastic display in Vienna.
Our friend Nordau coined for us the good phrase "Muscular Judaism" — without exhausting its meaning.
In gymnastics uprightness of mind, honest judgment, develops out of the feeling of bodily strength. In gymnastics there are no secrets, no wire-pulling, no favouritism and no petty little tricks of any kind. At the apparatus a man stands on his own, and what he can do, that he is worth. There the word is: Hic Rhodus, hic salta. Here is Rhodes, here leap. But significantly enough they are not yet popular anywhere — the gymnasts. At this display the official heads of Jewry were absent. They have missed something.
The first exercise was a round with staves; the smart march-in had put the hall in good spirits.
When the ranks had divided and the gymnasts stood waiting with their staves at attention, many a lady smiled. It was really droll. What did these people mean to do with their sticks? And this assortment! Men and youths. People who
