14
Homecoming.
A wondrous white ship shall one day sail — For purer than lilies gleam its sails. At its approach each reef sinks down, And round the mast float birds of peace, Dreaming children of a festal land, That beat their wings but softly, Because pale maidens, gentle in the moonlight, Rowing along upon the white waves' dance, Bear Ahasuerus to flowery shores.
Breslau. Arthur Silbergleit.
The Millions of Baron Hirsch.*)
By Israel Zangwill.
There are people who, instead of listening to the music, frequently try to drown it with a drumming. Mr. Lucien Wolf's neat counter-attack upon Zionism must not be allowed to obscure the clear conclusion which followed from my letter, namely, that the Hirsch Committees require parliamentary sanction in order to withdraw from their tasks and their mandate. Whether Zionism had appeared or not, the position of the Hirsch Committees would remain the same, and my criticism of them would likewise be in the right. A flank attack upon the Zionist camp does not yet cover their own inner weakness. Mr. Wolf is, after all, not really an anti-Zionist, so he says. He would not discourage us in our estimable idealism, but adds encouragingly that Zionism is condemned to failure in advance, and proceeds to deal it one of the most malicious blows it has ever received. No English Christian, in view of the struggles of an unhappy people to obtain a publicly and legally secured home in Palestine (the formula of Zionism) for its persecuted and misjudged sons, has ever dared to fling in their faces the reproach that this would mean an alliance with the persecutor of the Christians.
How one can disregard the host in whose house one wishes to dwell — this riddle Mr. Wolf has not explained to us. We are very well aware of the manifold difficulties which Zionism presents, but a national aspiration cannot recoil before such ephemeral motives as the alleged intolerance of a single ruler. After all, the memory of the religious toleration which has indeed survived in Turkey is quite as bright as that of Christian Russia, which shuts up half of all the Jews within the Pale of Settlement and so creates half the Jewish Question.
Mr. Wolf's attack upon Zionism is moderate in comparison with his attack upon the Zionists. He has observed with regret the continual endeavours of the Zionist leaders to obtain control over the
*) In reply to Zangwill's letter on the millions of the Hirsch Fund, published in the "Times" and translated in "Die Welt," Lucien Wolf wrote an article in the "Jewish Chronicle" against Zionism and Zangwill, in which he calls the endeavour of the Zionists to win the moneys bequeathed by Hirsch for the national cause a "dirty manoeuvre," and regrets that Zangwill should have lent himself to it. The above article is Zangwill's reply, published in the "Times" of 4th April, which he has kindly placed at our disposal. — Editorial Note.
funds of the "Ica," or, failing that, to discredit the administration. It seems that he has not observed very attentively. At the last Congress in Basle I made the proposal of a censure of the Hirsch Committees; but Dr. Herzl, the President of the Congress, did not sanction the proposal. In England Dr. Gaster has repeatedly repudiated my tactics. Thus the responsibility for the "dirty manoeuvre" to which, to Mr. Wolf's regret, I "have lent myself," falls upon me alone. But even this manoeuvre Mr. Wolf's powers of observation have distorted or otherwise falsified. I have never attempted to obtain control over the funds, or, failing that, to discredit the administration. I have indeed discredited the administration, and then, as a matter of course, advised it how failure might be turned into success.
The failure is admitted, too, in the reports of the Committees themselves. I have always taken my armour from their own arsenal. Only their unconcentrated activity, their 193 undertakings, could furnish an explanation of their failure. But when I had read their memorandum, which is to be seen at Somerset House, when I convinced myself that half their activity was neither authorised nor sanctioned by the statute, I was simply stunned. The great idea that lay in the mind of Baron Hirsch they have cast from them, and now they have the effrontery to confess that they do not employ their income within the bounds he set them. This astonishing confession has been made in the Act of Parliament now lying before the Upper House (House of Lords); it is, moreover, the real pretext of their demand for an alteration. What, then, becomes of my "dirty manoeuvre"? Mr. Wolf speaks as though the Hirsch Committees had faithfully and successfully carried out the ideas of the dead man, and then the godless Zionists had come to rob them. But it is, after all, the poor millionaires themselves who, like the poor Zionists, are crying out for help. They need a plan of campaign just as urgently as we need the strength for the struggle. Is it, then, in view of the crisis produced in East London by the influx, which they could easily direct to a central home, a wrong to believe that if they move from their stagnant money to the power-battery of Zionism, they will also bring it to life? The wrong lies rather in this, that the thought did not spring from their own midst, from their own conscious impulse to do their duty towards a great benefactor and a suffering people. No one has spoken of a sudden "transfer of the Hirsch millions to the governing body of Zionism."
Before they cry out their Non possumus, they ought surely to set their problem upon a broader basis. One of their chief aims is to help the Russian Jews. But is it not characteristic that not a single Russian Jew sits upon their Council? They had a vacant seat last year. But these arm-chair colonisers co-opted as a member a professor of law in Belgium, a country with the smallest number of Jews (4000). Mr. Wolf says: "It would be well for the Zionists to tell the Hirsch Committees what they would do with the Hirsch funds." So it would. But Mr. Wolf is not a Hirsch Committee, although his expression of opinion has a curiously official ring,