No. 7 Separate Edition. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.
(continued from page 2)
…other half must remain profitably invested. Thereafter at most one half of the respective annual receipts may be applied to the purchase of land, while the other half and the whole of the interest must remain untouchable until, in the opinion of the General Meeting, a Jewish colonisation on a large scale in Palestine or Syria is possible» has lapsed, but not the third paragraph, which in the Commission's wording reads as follows: «The Board of Directors is, however, empowered to buy land in Palestine and Syria even before the Fund reaches the amount of 200,000 pounds sterling, if the meeting has passed such a resolution by a ³/₄ majority. «
Dr. Tschlenow demands only a simple majority for the approval of land purchases. Tschlenoff's motion is adopted.
There remains for us the vote on the last supplementary provisions in Article III, second paragraph, which express the idea that only one half is to be applied to land purchases, while the other is to be profitably invested. Dr. Tschlenow proposes that ³/₄ be applied to the purchase of land and ¹/₄ be profitably invested.
The Commission's motion is rejected. Tschlenow's motion is adopted. Art. IV: For the rest, the statutes are referred to a commission of 9 persons to be elected by the Congress; adopted.
Pres. Dr. Bodenheimer. The vote is concluded; the next item on the agenda follows. I have one more announcement to make. The congregation of (the name was unintelligible) informs us that it devotes 200 marks to the inscription of the victims of Kischineff. We now begin the discussion on "Zionism and Charitable Institutions, by Zangwill." The various speakers on the list are not present, and therefore a vote is taken; the debate on Zangwill's address is closed. We pass to the discussion of Dr. Franz Oppenheimer's report. The first to ask for the floor is
Herr Davis Trietsch. With regard to Dr. Franz Oppenheimer's report I have a few objections to make. It goes without saying that I am in complete agreement on by far the most essential questions with the reporter, with whom I had occasion to work a great deal in the founding of the Jewish Orient Colonisation Company. Nevertheless it will be necessary to make some objections for our particular case. He said: "The foundation of colonising activity must be agrarian." Now I should like to ask: must that hold good in every case? Is it an absolute requirement? We Jews are in a very different position from other peoples who have formed states. Only consider it. In all other formations of states it is a question of raw, primitive human material, which one, what one could so call, scarcely human, human beings at the lowest stage of culture. We Jews have no such primitive, robust human material. Our colonisation reckons with the Jewish emigrant material, and these are for the most part emaciated town-dwellers, artisans, pedlars, people of poor physical constitution. As poor as our human material in the physical respect is the land with which we must begin; for surely no one in this hall seriously believes that we have a choice of lands somewhere in Africa — that is not the case. We may resolve on commissions as we please; the beginning will not be in East Africa. To begin with we have only Palestine, and of Palestine a very poor part, El-Arish. We have, then, a land that is essentially a kind of desert, not much better, and we have people who are not fitted from the outset for agricultural colonisation. Dr. Oppenheimer said: "He who would found towns must create peasants." For human material in general that holds true; for ours it does not. Since we have to deal with artisans and pedlars and tradesmen, it would be unnatural for us to wish to begin our colonies agriculturally; since we have no choice of fertile lands, but have nothing at our disposal except El-Arish, we cannot begin agriculturally. (Commotion.) The speaker asks: "Is it fitting that the hall should be so empty, that so few delegates are present?"
Pres. Dr. Bodenheimer. Those who are assembled will at any rate take an interest in it; go on, it will go into the minutes in any case.
Trietsch. A vote cannot be taken on the minutes.
Pres. Dr. Bodenheimer. Then I shall have the motion put to the vote to-morrow.
Trietsch. The Congress resolved a little while ago to hold a night session. The theses to-morrow?
Pres. Dr. Bodenheimer. The theses to-morrow, yes. Pray continue now.
Trietsch. With our available material in men and land, the rule that one must begin with agricultural colonies ought here to admit of an exception, and it will prove necessary to take industrial colonies into consideration as well. It is an important subject of which I am speaking here. I hold that as soon as we recognise that for our case industrial colonisation may possibly come into question, East Africa vanishes, and the rejected El-Arish comes to the fore again. I mean it thus. Dr. Herzl said that according to the findings of the expedition there is not enough water in El-Arish for a colonisation on a large scale. Now I grant that a great deal of water is needed for a large-scale colonisation. But what matters to us is to help as many Jews as possible, with as little money as possible and in as short a time as possible. For that, agricultural colonisation, with its great costs, is not suited. If we consider to-day that the towns on the Suez Canal, Port Said, Ismaila, Suez, have lately enjoyed an extraordinary rise through manufacturing industry, we must ask ourselves whether El-Arish too may not become a flourishing industrial place; and there are numerous industries for which one needs no water, for example the cigarette industry, in which Jews are engaged in many places. But I could enumerate to you hundreds more industries for which water in any appreciable quantity is not required. Drinking water I will undertake to supply from the water available in El-Arish.
Pres. Dr. Bodenheimer: You wish to speak on the settlement of a particular territory, whereas Dr. Oppenheimer speaks on settlement in general.
Trietsch: I will meet Dr. Bodenheimer so far as to speak not only for El Arish but also against East Africa; then I have two territories.
Pres. Dr. Bodenheimer: I think that in this way the discussion already concluded hervor-
