Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 6 · 29 August 1903
5printed page
scan 5 of 16
Facsimile · scan 5 of 16
Scan of p. 5
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 6, Special Edition. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.

(continued from page 4)

…Bank create, in the sense that the Bank, as a trust, should purchase the lands, administer the money, and act as legal representative. At the session in Vienna the Russian representatives present declared themselves against an amalgamation, as did, in the subsequent vote, all the Russian members of the Greater A. C., with the sole exception of Ussischkin. Thereupon I said to myself: If the representatives of the greatest mass of the Zionists are opposed to it, it would be useless to bring forward a proposal here which is not in the spirit of the mass. Nor did Mr. Bentwich submit any worked-out draft.

We were then occupied with the question: Where is the seat of the National Fund to be? In England or in some other country? We believed that England should be given the preference, since English protection counts for a great deal in the East. The colonists of Palestine, too, expressed a wish to that effect in a letter to me. That led in turn to the question of what form the Fund should be given there. We took the decision in principle to choose the legal form which gives us the most freedom, that is, to administer it ourselves without interference from the authorities. I thereupon went to London and conferred with English lawyers and consuls. The opinion of the lawyers was that one must choose the form of a Share — of a joint-stock company. Outwardly it is a joint-stock company, but a share can be acquired only by a member of the board of directors of the Jewish Bank or by a member of the A. C. And we have resolved that these shareholders must submit to the decisions of the Congress. For the administration we must have two bodies: the Smaller Actions Committee as supervisory board, and, as the second body, a Directorate.

The A. C. is to buy the land, the Directorate to administer it. In order to buy land, the body must, for the sake of rapid understanding, be in one place. For the administration, local circumstances do not come into consideration, but rather the ability of the persons concerned; they must be men trained in political economy and in technical matters. We want a Directorate of experts.

In the meantime two further sessions took place in Basle, and here the Russian members represented the view that nothing at all should be decided now, since they believed that in a few months' time there would perhaps be greater clarity. I remark that at that time there was as yet no talk of East Africa.

We therefore move that you meet the wish of the Russian members to-day; on the other hand we recommend that you agree in principle upon two things: 1. The purpose of the National Fund; 2. When the National Fund is to begin buying land.

A printed motion of the National Fund Commission has been distributed among you here. With regard to II., I emphasise that by "neighbouring countries" we understand not countries such as East Africa, but the adjacent countries, such as El-Arish. We further say: "to purchase or to sell." "Sell" stands there for a practical legal reason. It does not mean that we wish to trade in land, but that we should have the right to sell land, for instance in order to obtain other land for the rounding-off of a territory. Then we have demanded the "exclusion of sub-leasing." We do not want individual contractors who do no work and pocket the profit. He who works the land shall reap the gain.

We further say: "all possible or conceivable undertakings." It is not enough to buy land; one must also do something with the produce. Let us suppose that we grow wine, beets, sugar and the like. Then we surely do not wish to make use of a third party who sells it and pays us the lowest price. But this is to be not a duty, but a right.

Concerning the commencement of activity, we have in the first place adopted under III the resolution of the Fifth Congress that land shall be bought when the National Fund amounts to 5 million Fr. Now, however, the Minsk Conference has resolved that land shall be bought at once. We have said: We must submit to the will of the greatest mass of the Jewish people; and we have added that this may take place if a three-quarters majority of the General Assembly of the Greater A. C. agrees to it. Be it remarked in passing, it is by no means advisable, for practical reasons, to resolve to-day to buy at once: the gentlemen would immediately dictate higher prices to us. That would be the question of principle.

As regards the substance, we recommend that you refer the matter to a commission and elect a commission of eleven members, which would have to lay its resolutions before an eventual small Congress in a few months' time, when the misgivings of the Russians no longer exist.

I also take the liberty of making formal motions on the manner in which we are to debate. I would recommend, firstly, that we first debate and vote upon the question of entering into the matter, that is, whether the submitted draft is to be discussed in full or referred to the commission. If you agree with us that we should not deal with the draft, then the matter is settled. If not, we must take up the individual paragraphs. Then we recommend to you, secondly, that you deliberate upon the purpose, and thirdly upon the activity of the National Fund, whether land is to be bought at once or later. (Applause.)

Chairman Dr. Bodenheimer. A motion of Dr. Farbstein on a point of order lies before us here. I shall not now put this motion to the vote, but shall call a recess of an hour and a half. After this recess the presentation of reports will be continued. The first item on the agenda of the afternoon session, which begins at three o'clock, will be the vote on the Levin motion.

(Some further business announcements are made, and the session is then closed at a quarter past one.)


Thursday Afternoon Session.

Opened at 3.40.

Krenowitz of Buenos-Ayres describes the condition of the Jews in Argentina. The exact figure of the Jewish population cannot be ascertained, but is estimated at 35—40,000 souls, namely some 8000 colonists, 10—12,000 Jews in Buenos-Ayres, and the remainder scattered in other towns. 80 per cent. are Russo-Polish immigrants. The immigration dates back to the founding of the Hirsch colonies in the year 1898. The French and English are for the most part well-to-do, though it is true that they came here already possessed of means. The greater part