Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 5 · 30 January 1903
13printed page
scan 13 of 20
Facsimile · scan 13 of 20
Scan of p. 13
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 5. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 13.

(continued from page 12)

…costly branches of industry: tanneries, candle factories, oil mills, flour mills, and so forth. The Jewish factories are founded upon a weak basis. Most Jewish industrial establishments bear the character of handicraft." So says Bloch in the book just cited.

If, then, Jewish trade and industrial enterprise move within a very narrow and confined compass, if Jewish production has not passed beyond the bounds of petty industry and has thus remained economically backward, so on the other hand the share of Jews in factory production, as wage-labourers, as producers of value, is so slight that one may almost ignore it. Thus, for example, the percentage of the Jewish working class to the whole Jewish population is 1·83 in the North-Western Province, 0·9 in the South-Western, and 0·73 in the Southern, which amounts on the average to 1% of the total number of Jews, and agrees with the figures of Dr. Gurewitsch ("Haschiloah": "The Economic Question," etc. [Hebrew]). I need not first uncover the causes of this so slight share of the Jews in manufacture. Whoever knows even a little of the life of the Russian Jews, with all its restrictions, prohibitions, etc., will perceive them for himself.

While, therefore, the Jewish capitalists take no part in capitalist production, the Jewish proletarians take no part in industrial labour, and even the few who do take part in it are for the most part unskilled, casual workers (unskilled labourers).

Let us, merely to complete our account, cast a glance at two other countries in which Jews are beginning to gather: England and America. The condition of the Jews in London, in the East End, in the Jewish quarter of Whitechapel, has become known through the book of Doctor Leonty Solowe jtschik, "Un proletariat meconnu." According to his description*) the condition of the Jews is characterised by: 1. the irregularity of work (six months pass without work; 2. the exceedingly high number of working hours (18—20); 3. starvation wages (starvation wages); and 4. the sweating system. All the blessings, in short, of the capitalist economy. The same, if in a somewhat milder form, is the case in America also. (Cf. Riis: "How the other half lives.") So stands the economic condition of the Jews in the countries that are in every respect the most advanced on earth!

But are the Jews, in spite of their dreadful condition, really proletarianised workers? Can one reckon them to that class? Experience teaches us that both in England and in America the Jewish workers are precisely the true "unskilled labourers," casual workers who are compelled to take up labours for which they are neither fitted nor called.

Hutchins Hapgood says in his fine book "The spirit of the Ghetto" (p. 239): "A 'Mister' in Russia becomes a 'Schister' (shoemaker) in America, and a 'Schister' in Russia becomes a 'Mister' in America." This jest is highly characteristic of the Jewish worker in the Anglo-Saxon countries.

Men who have grown up and been educated within the petty-bourgeois circle of ideas cannot, even in spite of unfavourable material circumstances, accustom themselves to their condition; they know no class-consciousness, since they will not permanently avow themselves members of the working class; at the least opportunity they strive to climb up to the higher social rung, that of the petty bourgeois. Indeed, even as a worker the Jew is for the most part no factory hand, but a modified artisan.

I stand at the close of my cursory survey of the economic structure of the Jewish people. I make no claim to have drawn a complete picture, faithful down to the details; for that there are still wanting an exact Jewish statistics and a Jewish economic history. But our chief aim was not the description of the Jewish condition, but the answer to the question: Are there, or are there not, classes and class struggles within Jewry? And the answer, as appears from the foregoing, is in the negative.

In every period of the history of the Jewish people, antiquity, the Middle Ages and modern times, we have observed the same phenomenon and employed it as the key to the explanation of the social life of the Jews: that the economic development of the Jewish people was not a normal one, not a completed one; the form was broken through again and again, and the plasma material formed a shapeless lump.

Since the premises for the formation of the capitalist economy — namely, a soil of one's own, its expropriation by the few, the formation of the burgher estate, of the "tiers état," and so forth — were wanting among us, so too the necessary results could not follow, that is to say, the rise of a capitalist bourgeoisie and of a propertyless, servile proletariat.

When I assert that there is no Jewish proletariat, I do not mean to say that there are no Jewish proletarians! But I am not speaking of the millions of the disinherited, the wretched, the hungering; these are indeed proletarians, and more than that, in the vulgar sense of the word, but not in the economic sense: "By 'proletarian' is to be understood, economically, nothing other than the wage-labourer who produces and increases capital and is thrown out upon the pavement as soon as he becomes superfluous to the process of increase of 'Monsieur Capital.'" So Marx ("Capital," I. 630, note). In this Marxian, scientific sense of the word one cannot call the Jews a proletariat; they are quite simply "êtres declassés," "declassed beings."

It is no narrow doctrinairism that bids us make this distinction, it is no theoretical hair-splitting — since, whether we stamp the Jews as of this or that type of proletarian, one thing stands fast: that they suffer hunger. The exact distinction, the analysis of the economic structure of the Jewish social organism, has significance for us in so far as it shows us the fundamental difference between the Social-Democratic doctrine and our own, the Zionist.

However one may stand toward Social Democracy, whether as an enthusiastic adherent or as a stern opponent, one must none the less soberly admit that the Social-Democratic doctrine is not suited to Jewish conditions. The Social-Democratic party, if it will but for a moment lay aside the airs of a fighting party and regard the Jewish question soberly, sine ira et studio, will have to acknowledge that neither its internationalism — in which, by the way, nobody any longer believes — nor the socialisation of the means of production can lead to its solution here.

Social Democracy and Zionism are not hostile parties, but neither are they kindred ones; they are fundamentally different from one another, and their paths do not cross. Social Democracy has one form of society for its foundation, its premise and its justification for existence; Zionism has another. And it is surely a logical truth that when the causes of two things are different, the consequences must always be different.

So much for the attitude of Zionism toward Social Democracy, its negative side. But this already includes the positive side implicite. If Zionism has sprung from other conditions and been called forth by other economic circumstances, it must also represent a positive social doctrine, which, though it has not yet developed quite clearly, has already come into being in its outlines.

And this consideration — that of the positive content of Zionism as a social phenomenon — will form the subject of our next articles.

A. Coralnik.

P. T. Owing to want of space, the continuation of Dr. S. Mirkin's article, "The Nature of Jewish Nationality," will appear only in the next number.


Notice!

We request those of our esteemed readers and subscribers who are still in arrears with the payment of their subscription fee to remit the same as promptly as possible, so that no interruption may occur in the delivery of the paper.


Donations.

For the Jewish National Fund:

K
Society "Schochrei Zion," L239.34
"Agudas Zion," Brai251.30
Lia and Wolf Posnjak, N. . . . . . N. . . . . . d240.—
"Chowewe Zion Association," Cork240.—

*) Cf. Henri Dahan: Le proletariat juif auondial, in Revue Blanche, 15 October 1901.