Page 12 — "Die Welt" — Special Edition. No. 5
(continued from page 10)
…tance of our organisation being the most perfect possible, and to implore you to exert all your strength to bring it to the highest level. Above all other things we must never forget that we are all capable of serving the great work, and that even the best that we are able to do represents only the least that an honourable member of our great people ought to perform.
As for myself, I rejoice — and from the depths of my heart I feel happy to have once more the opportunity of declaring publicly — as I have often done before — that I profess myself a loyally minded, zealous Zionist and will devote my whole self to the great national movement — that I shall always do everything in my power to further with full strength the progress and the future of this movement so dear to us, and to bring it nearer to the goal it strives for.
(Long-continued applause and clapping of hands).
The President adds a supplementary note to the vote: Dr. Heinrich Loewe asks it to be announced that he votes No.
The result of the roll-call vote is as follows: 473 votes were cast. Yes 295. No 178. The motion of the A. C. is therefore carried. (Renewed, long-continued applause.) But I will add: although this vote is now over, I wish to remark, by way of explanation and to clear up misunderstandings or errors that may perhaps have been brought into the assembly, that the adoption of this motion means nothing more than that we shall study the proposal which has been made to us with due respect and due seriousness. The result of this study will be laid before the Congress which will be convened for this purpose, and the result of this study will not first be communicated at the Congress, but will be made known to the delegates in good time beforehand, so that they may prepare themselves for the discussion and learn the feelings of their electors. I do not, however, mean this in the sense that I believed a delegate would depart from the principle of representation, which is authoritative elsewhere too, that one does not come into the assembly with a definite imperative mandate; but since this is a matter of real practical need, the feeling in this direction too can be ascertained in good time. For this is a very grave and responsible question before which we stand, which we have not solved to-day, and for whose solution we have only to-day begun to prepare. Let that be well understood; and if it is well understood, then I cannot comprehend that a part of the delegates should have left this hall in such a manner. (Quite right! Bravo! Thunderous applause.)
I will now, in the absence of the gentlemen, whom I expect back shortly, (Cries: they will not come!) allow the discussion of this matter to continue.
Dr. Syrkin. I hold it my duty to make a statement of fact: It is no obstruction that those who voted No have set up here. It is merely one of the measures intended to forestall and avoid various frictions which might perhaps take on a somewhat unpleasant character. This I should also like to say to the President.
Dr. Nossig. I hereby enter a protest, in my own name and in the name of many of those who share my views, whose list will be submitted later, against a vote having been taken upon a motion which has not been debated, and I ask that this be entered in the minutes. (Oho! Oho!)
President: I shall of course comply with the wish of Dr. Nossig.
(Some further business announcements are made.)
I close the sitting. To-morrow we shall conclude the item "Zionism and Charitable Institutions" and then pass on to the remaining points of the order of the day.
The delegates sing the national song as they leave the Congress hall.
Close of the sitting 8 o'clock.
* * *
Wednesday — Morning Sitting.
N. Sokolow, after a stormy welcome, takes the floor for his report:
Zionism and Charity in the East.
Honoured Congress!
Not without misgivings do I accept the invitation to speak on charity and Zionism in the East, for neither can a direct connection between charity and Zionism simply be found, nor is it easy, within a short span of time and without any reference to the economic side, to give an insight into the mostly intricate problems which at present occupy the administration of the communities and of the charitable societies. If I nevertheless venture for a short time to direct your attention to Jewish charity in the East, I do so in the conviction that, on the one hand, such a subject is to-day assured of the interest of wide circles, but that, on the other hand, it stands all the more in need of Zionist treatment, since qualified and unqualified adherents of the Zionist programme of present-day work have in recent years turned to this field and, on the basis of a shallow, stereotyped view of communal as well as association affairs, have caused no little confusion. Of course it can here be only a question of a picture to be sketched in broad outlines, for which I ask your indulgent attention.
The olden times of the Jewish people in the East of Europe offered little occasion for the founding of rational charitable institutions. We lack, it is true, detailed primary sources on the original settlement of Jewish immigrants in the lands of Eastern Europe and on the charity that developed in parallel with it, but there can scarcely be any doubt that each group practised relief of the poor within its Kehilla; for the Jews of that time were thrown upon their own resources, and the Kehilla formed a surrogate for an administration which, though crippled, was nevertheless in many respects still wholly autonomous. According to the conditions of the country, the Jews in their new home either continued the cultivation of the strictly orthodox Zedakah, or turned to the founding of peculiar Chewroth-guilds, in which, to be sure, the peoples among whom they lived became their teachers. The latter was by far the most widespread form of a halfway reasonable self-help. The