Page 2 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 2
(continued from page 1)
…of the Jewish people they see only an error of history, which must be set right by assimilation and mixed marriages; others because, content with the crude obstinacy bequeathed to them as an inheritance from "the good old times," they will not renounce it. To teach reason to such people it has for the present no means. There are, however, very many who have not yet made the attempt to reflect upon this question, and others who, in reflecting upon it, were unable to free themselves from the routine notions of the historical meaning of Zionism which had been instilled into them — either by our mystics, who wrapped our idea in a supernatural form, or by the rationalists, who see in what is to come the Utopian golden age in which the wolf shall actually live in brotherhood with the lamb. Such persons may yet be convinced of the error of their views by a good book which sets forth to them the true meaning of Zionism.
Zionism has, it is true, already produced a whole literature, but it is chiefly journalistic or descriptive. The present work of Dr. J. B. Sapir, however, illuminates the question from every side, and is the book best suited to the aforesaid end. This work will also be of great service to those Zionists who are not wholly initiated into all the particulars of the historical evolution of Zionism, of its actual development in recent times, and of its various currents.
Everyone is of course free not to share one or another of the author's views upon these currents; it may perhaps turn out that one or another fact from the history of the Palestine movement, or from the history of the founding of one colony or another, is not rendered with entire exactness; but for the elucidation of the matter as a whole such trifles do not come into consideration at all. The present book of Doctor J. B. Sapir is the first comprehensive treatment of the Zionist movement; it will most assuredly be of mighty service to the cause so sacred to us, and all those whose hearts beat for the great idea of Zionism will be grateful to him for his truly and in every way useful and earnest work.
M. L. Lilienblum.
The Polish Press and Zionism.
None is quicker to suspect than the suspected. Whoever wishes to see this maxim, which is beyond doubt psychologically sound, confirmed by a practical example, need only follow diligently the Polish press and its attitude towards Zionism. The fact that the utterances of the Polish press touching Polish nationality — especially where it gives itself out as ultra-loyal — are not met with a corresponding measure of confidence, has bred in that same press a strong inclination to distrust, as unchangeably as unjustifiably, the clearest and best-intentioned expositions and the most open and loyal declarations of elements of other nationality — quite especially of the Jewish and the Ruthenian.
"What goes on behind the curtain, what surges and foams there, what makes itself known there by a wild roaring, what constitutes the kernel of Jewry — that is what we wish to see, that is what we wish to come to know, that is what we wish to appraise. But that the leaders of Zionism do not show us. For us they have declamations; for themselves and their hidden aims they have the might of their element. For us they have Palestine; for themselves — Warsaw, Vilna and Cracow, three 'capitals,' as a candid Zionist called them without any circumlocution."
Such is the final wisdom at which the Warsaw correspondent of the Lemberg "Słowo Polskie" arrives in an article headed "Guests of the Zionists." As though there were no Zionists anywhere outside Poland, as though there were no frivolous slanderers of Zionism anywhere outside the former Republic — so the writer of the article will see in Zionism a movement confined to Polish territory, whose ultimate aim is to put the reins into the hands of Jewry and to make Abraham and Moses the successors of the Piasts. What a ridiculously narrow horizon! We are almost inclined to think that we have here to do with a novice in zionisticis, with a man who has doubtless heard and read many monstrous and horrifying things about Jews, and even about Zionists, but who was attending a Zionist meeting for the first time. The milieu he found there seems to stand in such contrast to his previous notions of it that he cannot recover from his astonishment. He writes:
"Floods of light, masses of people. The hall of the 'Neue Harmonie' is filled to the very last seat with Jewish intelligentsia. It swarms, it glitters, it rustles. Satins and silks gleam, necklaces and collars play in the colours of the rainbow, coiffures (coifurrey) of red-gold, chestnut-dark and raven-black tower aloft. This is no longer the Jewish street. This is the flower of society. This is no longer the counting-house and the market-stall, but the liberal professions, represented by advocates, physicians, engineers, architects, university students, women and girls who strive towards the light.
All of them were drawn hither by the Zionist idea, whose herald in the Kingdom of Poland is the Zionist League, which is unfolding an ever wider, ever bolder agitation outwardly."
The unusual — the unusual for the Polish journalist — which he was here given to see held him so spellbound that over the "How" he forgot the "What." He knows how to report faithfully whether a speaker spoke good or less good Polish. But the words merely whirred past his ears; he caught one here and another there, and patched a report together out of them. According to this the course of the meeting was as follows:
In his opening address the chairman, the advocate Jasinowski, declared the object of the meeting to be the winning of new adherents and the dispelling of the legend of a reactionary and harmful Zionism.
Thereupon the Warsaw physician Dr. Müntz spoke. He regretted that since the Minsk Congress the Zionists had been placed in the dock by the Polish press, that this press sought no authentic news at the source, but only too often plucked its news out of the air. Assimilation — the speaker observed — was reprehensible also from the standpoint of Polish society, since it would entail a change in the typically national character of the Poles. For this reason alone Aryan society ought to support Zionism.
The high point of the evening was indisputably Sokolow's two-hour speech. Taking history as his guide, he went through all the phases of the national idea among the
