Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 50.
(continued from page 5)
...a religious community (!). With the fall of its Temple and the suppression of the rising of Bar-Kochba it ceased to be a nation . . . That "all anthropologists" regard the Jews as a distinct race is news to me. Only a Utopian enthusiast, or one wholly unacquainted with the history of Judaism, can speak of a Jewish race."
Now, such bottomless ignorance, or such conscious untruth, merely in order to serve the idea of "Germanism of the Mosaic persuasion," does not really deserve any answer from a serious quarter.
Driesmans, however, did not let this vex him nevertheless. He wrote on the matter as follows:
". . . A Jewish race in the Old Testament sense, to be sure, no longer exists, just as pure races no longer exist anywhere on earth at all. But that the Jews as a 'nationality' exhibit typical racial marks which make them unmistakable — as the other 'nationalities,' too, have their typical marks and characters, by which they differ considerably from one another — can hardly be denied away. The writer has only confirmed how right I was — namely, that there are Jews who can no longer bear even to be reminded of their 'marks' in a thoroughly matter-of-fact, calm, scientific manner.
To go into the lame comparison with the 'Catholic nationality' we leave to all reasonably thinking readers themselves. It is superfluous to speak of it. That fundamental racial differences are alive in the 'nationalities' down to the present day is at present denied by no one who has any eye at all for real conditions. The 'religion' of a people is, at its deepest ground, likewise nothing else than the outflow of its racial spirit, of its particular vital instincts. Hence it is that, as Egidy very rightly perceived, there have hitherto been only 'confessions,' no 'religion,' and indeed as many as there are peoples and national communities."
The excitement in the Jewish assimilationist press, however, rages on. The "Allg. Ztg. des Judentums" in Berlin declared its wish "to make front against a race theory which is being studiously spread in a manner contradicting all the scientific researches of modern anthropology and with the conscious intention of disparaging Judaism."
To this Driesmans replied once more in a letter addressed to the editors of the "Allgem. Ztg. d. Jdtms." and printed by them, which, after some introductory words, runs as follows:
". . If you had cared to inform yourselves beforehand in some measure about my way of thinking, you could easily have found in my writings that I have treated the race question in a thoroughly objective manner. But you do not know my relevant works, so I must assume, and nevertheless you bring so grave an accusation, which can accordingly rest solely upon the passage from my rejoinder to Dr. Rieger quoted by you in No. 46. That passage, however, said nothing further than that the Jews of to-day exhibit 'typical racial marks,' just as the other nationalities have their typical marks and characters. To find in this utterance a disparagement of Judaism pursued with conscious intention is — do not take it amiss of me — such a monstrosity that I really have no words for it. Do you really mean to assert that your present-day kinsmen exhibit no typical formation of face and skull? That would fly directly in the face of the simplest observation — even without any anthropological knowledge whatever. And if you really believe you must see an 'insult' in ascribing such characteristic marks to your kinsmen, then you thereby only prove that, to you as well as to Dr. Rieger, who first took offence at it, the 'scientific researches of modern anthropology' which you bring into the field against me, who have stood in them for years, are wholly foreign. For if you were but a little familiar with them, you would not resist the 'typical marks' of your race and seek to deny them, but would rather emphasise and bring them forward all the more. In a word, you would be proud of possessing typical marks at all, and would find the pride of your race in such. For it is precisely in its racial individuality, of which the marks bear outward witness, that a people, a tribe, raises itself out of the mass, out of the general pulp of nations. The typical marks are what the anthropologist calls the aristocratic trait of a people. They show that such a people still has individuality and creative worth within it and is not yet wholly dead and levelled. Ask what anthropologist you will, he will give you the same answer; and ask your sound reason whether it tells you anything different. Your rejection of the typical marks therefore signifies nothing else than: we Jews wish no longer to be an individuality, we wish to have no racial character; in short, we wish to belong to the general pulp of nations, or rather, to disappear in it. While you think I am insulting your people, you thus do it the worst insult and disparagement that there is for a people. At least I should, for example, hold it to be such for the German people if its typical racial characters were denied it; precisely that wherein this people shows itself superior and richer than, say, the Romance nations is its individualising power, which manifests itself not only in its marked racial features but in the further stamping of tribal types and characters, as against the more levelled Latins, who have lost such. A people which in this sense will no longer show any individuality gives itself up; and if the Jews wish to disown their 'marks,' then they quite simply wish to be nothing any longer — then they wish no longer to be. To us Germans that could only be welcome, and whoever looks somewhat more sharply here can hardly fail to see that on this occasion I — unintentionally, out of pure, objective scientific interest — am defending the true advantage of Judaism, while my unknown opponent, its kinsman, shows himself its enemy. At all events, if he were to draw the consequences of his rejection and denial of the 'typical racial marks' in this fashion, he would needs grow thoughtful over his own words.
In the expectation that these supplementary remarks of mine will contribute not only to setting my standpoint right but to the clarification of the questions concerned in general, I remain
Most respectfully yours, Heinrich Driesmans.
Letter from Paris.
Two incidents which have occurred in our city are clear proofs that the situation of the Jews in France, and especially in Paris, has become just as unpleasant and uncomfortable as it has long been on the whole Continent. After the pardon of Captain Dreyfus, the Frenchmen of the Mosaic persuasion proclaimed a Truce of God, that is, they cried aloud to all the winds that they would forget the Dreyfus case as an exceptional one, and hoped that everything would remain as of old . . . But all their labour of love is in vain. The "Affair" was only a symptom, and the hatred of the Jews — at most latent, but ever present — has broken loose again and grows mightier and bolder from day to day. And even the Frenchmen of the Mosaic persuasion, who otherwise wish to speak of their Judaism as little as possible and to avoid everything that merely resembles a union and a separation of the Jews — they have ent-
