No. 47. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.
The striving to preserve national character, distinctive custom, language and culture, and the hostile feeling towards what is foreign, are admonitory signs of an inward psychological revolution in the fundamental temper of the life of nations. They indicate that the coming century will be an epoch of racial wars; that the peoples of sure instinct are striving to reorganise the blood-chaos of the Christian and liberal period through a physiological unmixing and self-purification of the races, or at the least to resist the further injuries done by the jumbling together, levelling and bastardisation of the human race, and to save of pure blood and national character whatever may still be saved.
We hold the nationalist movements, for all their excrescences and exaggerations, to be healthy; and however much we acknowledge in Professor A. Kirchhoff the eminent geographer, and declare at the outset that his lecture on the question "What is National?"²) contains many apt individual observations, we can in no way assent to the fundamental idea of his argument.
Kirchhoff starts from the correct definition that the nation is a multitude bound together by kinship of blood, which, in consequence of its common descent, shows itself alike in appearance, language and custom. Distinct from this is the concept of the people (Volk). "The inhabitants of every island, every city and every state we may, in a comprehensive sense, call a people, even if they are not at all, or scarcely, distinguishable from their neighbours."³) Hence by a people are to be understood the inhabitants of a territory outlined by state frontiers. The causes that create states out of enduring associations are of a geographical kind: natural frontiers formed by mountains, sea-coasts and rivers. Where a country lacks natural frontiers within which a compact nation can develop, there they must be created, be it by force. All modern peoples have arisen from a fusion of ethnically different elements. Through a process of intellectual assimilation they form a nation of culture. The result is: "The mark of belonging to a nation is citizenship. Just as ancient Rome made membership of the Roman nation dependent upon the possession of the rights of citizenship, so the latter is still to-day the decisive factor for a man's nation. The Poles within our Empire are in fact Germans and must be officially regarded as such. They must therefore, if they resist this fact, be politically educated as Germans and linguistically assimilated. "In the same way the Jews are Germans and not members of a foreign nation."
It is not easy to follow Kirchhoff in all his leaps of thought, since the concepts of nation and nationality, of people and state, shift under his hand and acquire another meaning. Whereas he originally starts from the correct concept of the nation as race, the nation later becomes for him a multitude of men of quite arbitrary origin, held together by common deeds or by accidental natural or artificial frontiers. By this reckoning we should have to recognise even Hottentots and coolies, were we to import them into Germany, teach them to speak German and teach them other customs, as citizens of German nationality with equal rights. In such examples the whole absurdity is revealed of a geographico-political theory for whose sake Kirchhoff does violence to historical facts and to the feeling of whole classes of the people.
Race signifies common descent by blood. People is a concept of culture, denoting the politico-historical development of one race or of several races intermingled with one another. The state is the legal organisation of a people held together by natural or artificial frontiers of territory.
In some cases race, people and state form a single organic growth, in others not. The German (that is, Germanic) race, for example, is not identical with the German people, nor this with the German Empire. Germanic race is found in other peoples, in northern France, Russia, etc., where it has "assimilated" itself but has not given up its physical and mental racial character. A German people exists in Austria as well, without being pure Germanic race. Even the German people contains at most one half of pure Germanic race.
Whereas in older times, when the peoples themselves were still pure races, nation meant common descent, this has shifted in the consciousness of modern peoples. For them nation has become identical with community of language and culture, that is, with the concept of the people, despite the mixtures of blood that have taken place in the course of centuries. In such a people, however, the peculiar character of one race has always been the predominant and leading power, even though it outwardly transferred its culture, and with it apparently its nationality, to the elements of foreign race and to the half-breeds.
Nation, in the sense of the modern peoples, is an independent, politically organised community of culture, whereas nationality denotes the national character even of an individual. We speak of Jewish and of Polish nationality. But Jews and Poles do not form a — nation. Yet their political endeavour is directed towards gathering and organising themselves once more into a nation.
Kirchhoff rejects the nationalist strivings of the present. Fichte, to be sure, and the politicians of the Frankfort National Assembly he does not venture to censure. They were "ideal." But the nationalists of to-day are to be nothing but "political bullies and place-hunters," nothing but demagogues who misuse the word nation as a political stimulant. Kirchhoff forgets that those German Nationalists were in their own day persecuted even as — political criminals.
Instead of feeling the pulse-beat of the age and interpreting it rightly, Kirchhoff sets up a geographico-political theory and from it passes judgment on the actions of men. "Of personal liking and disliking, of philo- and antisemitism there can be no question for us; we have only to demonstrate the correctness of our theorem for this case also." As if the peoples governed themselves by theories! Natural antipathies and sympathies, growing out of racial feeling, rule the peoples. Without mass movement and without the use of the instincts of the masses — in the good and in the bad sense — there is no political history, however great the genius of the statesman. But the mass instincts of to-day are, or are beginning to be, nationalist. They are not artificially provoked agitations.
At the root of political history lies a physiological process of alternating mixture and unmixing of the races. Conquest, the caprice of rulers, accidental dynastic rights of inheritance, have thrown the races together pell-mell, and capitalism and humanitarianism now wish to complete this work. Then the natural reaction awakens; the protective instincts of racial feeling and of nationalism come into play. America and Australia enact restrictions on immigration against inferior races and against Jewry. Subjugated nationalities, scattered among foreign states, bestir themselves towards political self-activity. The history of the nations is entering upon the stage of unmixing, of seclusion, of "the gathering of the peoples," in order to preserve the human race from complete levelling and bastardisation. And since, from the standpoint of historical biology, one must see in this tendency of development a thoroughly healthy reaction, we joyfully welcome the strivings of the Pan-Germans and of Polonism, and of Zionism too, as well as all similar nationalist movements in other states. Let us hope that in the future political dissolution and reformation of states, as in the coming race-
²) Professor A. Kirchhoff: "Was ist national," Halle a. S. 1902. Published by Gebauer-Schwetschke. ³) Far more appropriate in this case would be the use of the word population.
