Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 40 · 2 October 1902
9printed page
scan 9 of 16

No. 40 — "Die Welt" — Page 9

(continued from page 8)

…of a noble honesty. At times everything goes topsy-turvy; some speakers take rather too much upon their tongues; but on the whole all this bears witness to a striving after order and after a firmer knitting of the bond. Then come the projects. The "clou" was without doubt Ussischkin's plan, ready and complete. The project has surfaced several times already, but has always foundered on its impracticability. Ussischkin defends his project in a truly mighty "Hun speech." Strict discipline in the Zionist hierarchy; the slightest rebellion against authority is to be chastised without mercy; a sentence of death upon the societies, and in their place a grading of the groups of shekel-payers. The clear and energetic mind of the able mover sees in the present situation a state of inextricable confusion, and in a well-organised and strict leadership, by contrast, a paradise. Now one may very well give Ussischkin's self-sacrificing gift for agitation an honourable testimonial without swearing by the expediency of too strict a discipline. The most enticing thing in his project is the idea of a Zionist guard, that is, a group of super-Zionists who are to devote themselves body and soul to Zionist propaganda. The project met with much attention, assent, and applause. Yet the project could lead to no tangible result. The commission appointed for the purpose merely laid down certain theses. It was well that the definitive organisation was not resolved upon, but referred to further thorough and careful deliberation. Nonetheless we look back with satisfaction upon the successful and thoughtful course of the debate. Large points of view were unveiled, and many details which one cannot deny interest were brought to general knowledge, as for example the active and the fictitious societies, the relation of the shekel-payers to the organised Zionists, and the like.

The present question of colonisation played a prominent part in the proceedings of the national conference. The sad plight of the colonists and the labourers is sufficiently known. Up to now the attempts to move the "Ica" to a great work of rescue have failed, and since the distress in Palestine is indescribably great, nothing remains for the poorest among the colonists but to turn to Zionist Congresses and national conferences. In the hard days they have had to struggle through, it was a blissful feeling for them to receive continual proofs of love and brotherhood from Zionist circles. It is therefore natural that they appeared in Minsk as in Basle. Our hearts bled when these, our best, spoke of the misery; we were deeply moved when they brought us "greetings" from the land of our fathers, from the poor land of our fathers, and alarmed when they told us of the purchase of lands by various nationals of other states. But whether it was right, under the impression of these undoubtedly true and sad facts, to pass the resolution that the National Fund should at once take in hand the purchase of land, is not altogether clear to me. It would be a fateful error to empty the National Fund at once and to buy land in all haste; indeed, this support would be a venture whose responsibility a political Zionist organisation will not so lightly assume.

The question was dealt with by two reporters: Achad-Haam and my humble self. I will not repeat what has been said. Achad Haam treated national education thoroughly and clearly. He recommended two leading principles for adoption. In place of Dr. Kohan-Bernstein I took over the report on practical culture. Since Achad-Haam represents the standpoint of his "spiritual centre," I was obliged to characterise my own tendency as the completeness of a programme of political-cultural Zionism. I look in Zionism for a vigorous party, fresh with youth, with an effective and attractive programme, and with clarity about its whole direction and its position on the decisive questions of the day. Then came, as usual, the most honoured rabbis, and general speakers chosen from a mass of registered speakers, and finally our replies as well. At last the resolution was adopted, almost unanimously, to appoint two commissions for progressive-national and traditional-national culture.

Someone might receive the impression that a compromise motion had scraped through by the skin of its teeth, containing, in words as fine as they are empty, something about two tendencies in culture. At bottom, however, it is not so bad. My proposals for practicable improvements — a rather long list of wishes, containing only the minimum of what is urgently necessary — were referred to the commissions. Zionism further sees in the question of culture one of its most important and most pressing tasks, the taking up of which by the societies is urgently required. For the appropriate furtherance of the work needed in this field a division is necessary, which enlarges the existing organisation to the extent that two commissions are elected. Only, the individual tendencies must be left as much latitude as possible. The soundness of this argument cannot be disputed. I would rather have striven for an unconditional adoption of my practical proposals; the standpoint of the peace-loving majority made itself felt to the effect that one should not resolve upon what is desirable, but should point out a passable road by which one might get further. The presidium understood masterfully the art of listening for the pulse-beat of the majority. It now depends upon the commissions to abandon the fruitless struggle over words and to set to work.

In the economic field the result is very slight. Dr. Gurewitsch's lecture was thorough and splendid. He defined the economic concepts, showed the development of workers' co-operatives, and set their dangers against their advantages. As is proved by the statistical inquiries undertaken, the proletarianisation of the Jews is making alarming progress. Dr. Gurewitsch rightly represented economic organisation as a political factor of the first rank. The material was then condensed into a series of proposals, which were referred to a commission.

These are the practical results. The most important thing is the public emergence and the consolidation of Zionism in Russia, and, since the strengthening of the parts means the prosperity of the whole, one may say of Zionism as a whole. The national conference at Minsk was a great deed, which will make possible a greater drawing upon the resources and energies of the Jewish nation for the realisation of the Zionist ideal. N. Sokolow.


World National Fund Festival.

A Proposal.

(Translated from the Hebrew manuscript.)

The annual conference is close at hand. Should the people not stir at all while its representatives come together to take counsel about its future? No! It will surely be granted that it would be fitting, at the time of the "little Congress" or some days before, to summon the people and the atten-