Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 40 · 2 October 1902
8printed page
scan 8 of 16
Facsimile · scan 8 of 16
Scan of p. 8
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 8 — "Die Welt" — No. 40

(continued from page 7)

…felt himself an equal among Jews. They are present wherever it is a question of manifesting solidarity, of furthering public spirit, of displaying a truly Jewish-humane disposition, and of affording, through what one might call a democratic brotherliness, a foretaste of the Jewry of the future. When a Jew entered this assembly, he saw before him a piece of the Jewish homeland, and indeed a friendlier and more obliging one than he finds in his Golus institutions. This is not the least merit of the Congresses and the national conferences, and we doubt whether one so grand as that lately held at Minsk has ever taken place before.

What was the Russian Zionist National Conference to us? Was it a series of resolutions? No. It was an ordeal by fire of Zionism in Russia. It showed how mightily the national idea has entered into the sentiment of our people and become the guiding idea of its life. And though it may well accord with the notions of separateness which are still dominant in assimilationist circles at present, that there should be the most zealous sniffing about for indications out of which a charge of treason might be constructed against Jews who went to Minsk to confer upon the situation of their people — Habeant sibi! So long as the Zionist programme exists — and it will exist for a good long while yet — all this labour of love will be lost; for who, with clear senses not blinded by hatred, could rise to the sublime notion that it is treason when Jews fraternise and imitate the shining example of the strivings for national regeneration which the best, noblest and most modern of the nations set before them?

The reorganisation of Russian Zionism was not resolved upon in final form. In substance the origin of this proposal of reform makes no difference. A motion which effects so sweeping a change in the organisation could not be disposed of affirmatively before it had the decided support of all parties. Mr. Ussischkin may have tactical reasons for choosing the one or the other mode of taking the question in hand; the reform will nevertheless in any case, despite great modifications, remain his work. Nor is Mr. Ussischkin in earnest so Jove-like a ukase-Zionist as his opponents find fault with him for being.

I should not wish to be misunderstood. I shudder no less than anyone else at the sum of misery and want which has accumulated over the heads of our dear pioneers in Palestine. And I explain to myself the resolution concerning the National Fund as the result of a psychological moment. It is an uplifting and at the same time a humanly beautiful sight when the representatives of the first colonists, surrounded by hundreds of Zionists, are fêted as our heroes and favourites. I understand that a deep emotion arises whenever these excellent men appear upon a Zionist platform. We shall not and must not ever forget that we have serious duties towards these people, that we secure our own future when we are unceasingly intent upon bettering the lot of these few, and upon supporting most warmly every reform which serves this end; but we must consider carefully whether we are not forcing back Zionism, conceived on a grand scale, to the method of the half-philanthropic and petty Ischuw. It was gratifying and instructive that the energetic and highly respected Odessa Palestine Society made known its concord and its approval; but we must strive not backward but forward. As a strict and consistent adherent of Zionism in its present modern form, I am perhaps too suspicious, but I have the feeling that a retrograde tendency exists whose very core it is to make the small experiments, by turning back the course of development, once more the central point of Zionism. Perhaps this is a delusion of prejudice. It will surely not occur to any political Zionist now to imitate, move for move, step by step, the measures of the earlier colonists.

The resolution concerning the National Fund commends itself after very thorough and expert deliberations, with regard to the chief aims and tasks of political Zionism. We welcome this resolution as a noble intention.

And now to the question of culture. This matter lies near the heart of many, whether it gladdens them or oppresses them. Some speakers at the preliminary conferences did indeed exclaim angrily that it was time to make an end of the culture debate; but how greatly the matter nevertheless interests most Zionists is evident from the fact that the first opportunity that offers calls forth the liveliest debates upon it. This could be observed quite plainly in Minsk. Those, then, who would like to silence the question of worship to death by no means express thereby the prevailing fundamental mood, and they talk so at all only because the theoretical disputes occasionally cause them some difficulties in practical agitation. In so doing they overlook the fact that Zionism, which justly boasts of raising the Jewish spirit, cannot do otherwise than provide for the further development of the Jewish spirit. Many believe that the aversion of broad hyper-Orthodox strata of the people is a consequence of the cultural tendency and its manifestation. It is so convenient, so practical, to know a solution at once for the most difficult social problems. Whence arises the repugnance of the "Chassidim" and the obscurantists towards Zionism? From erroneous views of religion, from ignorance, from sloth, from cowardice, from the Golus stunting of the spirit of enterprise and of manly pride. Who understands this? But answer all these questions with the single word: Culture! — at once everything is understood, at once the scapegoat is discovered, upon whose head all the sins are laid, and now all those applaud who have not fathomed the causes. But it is of no avail — the majority at all Congresses and national conferences always votes for culture.

Many had emphasised that the National Conference at Minsk would be a quiet, a purely business party-meeting. Well, that has not come to pass. The National Conference was positively flooded with questions of principle. The question of organisation alone afforded a host of discussions of principle. The debate on organisation is like the budget debate in parliaments: one speaks there of everything one has at heart. On the one side ring out the reports: so-and-so many societies, so-and-so many circles, clubs, etc. Then comes the criticism, often apt, but at times carping as well: people are very boastful with the numbers of the societies, but when one looks at them one soon notices their frailty! On this occasion the criticism cannot keep strictly within the bounds of the question, and is often called to order. The discussion grows wearisome and splinters into details of a local character; yet it would be levity to pass over their significance and far-reaching consequences. One must tell oneself that the problems which move this vast multitude are of a harrowing earnestness and of