Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 36 · 5 September 1902
5printed page
scan 5 of 16

No. 36. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.

(continued from page 4)

…of the well-fed. The well-fed Jew likes to grumble a little about antisemitic authorities and people. He likes to see himself oppressed. He likes to gossip about affairs in the community. He likes to hear the Jews only praised. This press supplies him with the material for it. And one thing more. Rousing Zionism, too, does not suit the well-fed paymasters of this press. Often the paper is short a hundred lines. "Kill off Zionism a little," the publisher orders, and the next moment we lie on the ground.

This time it was especially dangerous. And solemn! A first-class funeral in a leading article. And what brought about this excitement? Out of Dr. Herzl's latest negotiations in Constantinople the most noble gentlemen turned out upon their lathe a complete failure of the Zionist movement. That is how one answers an open and honest communication, given voluntarily in the consciousness of honest intention and honest work. In a paper of the German Empire, for example, one reads: "Have we not always said that these supplicatory journeys of Dr. Herzl's to Constantinople are useless? He might have spared himself and the Jewish people this humiliation." But the published statement says plainly that Dr. Herzl by no means went on pilgrimage, but was summoned by telegraph by the mighty ruler of Turkey and was his guest the whole time. Down there our leader was showered with honours and attentions. One does not, after all, summon anyone to negotiations with the intention of saying a curt "No!" Nor did this happen at all. "The concessions which His Majesty declared himself ready to make to a Jewish settlement could not be declared sufficient according to our Zionist programme. The connection is by no means broken off." So it stands, word for word, in the published statement. Whoever, as an honest man, believes an honest man — and nobody, indeed, ventures to doubt the truth of the communication — can see from these words only that the "No!" was but half a No, and in any case not a final one, and that Dr. Herzl was justified in his remark that the negotiations would yet bring a positive result. Our worthy paper, however, prints after the communication the high-flown sentence: With this Zionism is at an end. Thus spake Zarathustra. Only that we Zionists, with our unfashionably straightforward way of thinking, find rather a success than a failure in the Constantinople communication. To be sure, if things went according to the wishes of certain scene-shifters of politics, the hope of the Jewish people would already be an insubstantial phantom by to-morrow.

Humour, by the way, has not been lacking in this latest campaign of the anti-Zionist papers. There is an English paper which all its life long has thrown sticks between the feet of Zionism. This time, too, it issues Zionism its printed death certificate. In the same article the paper feels itself called upon and entitled to demand an explanation of what actually took place in Constantinople. For not Zionism alone, but the whole Jewish people, has an interest in learning it. We Zionists beg the paper for a very little patience! We shall certainly not fail to elect its editor-in-chief to our Inner Actions Committee, so that he may be informed on every point of the Constantinople negotiations. But we are dead, surely; no cock crows after us any more! Why, then, does the English paper knock at the gates of our grave? Does it wish to awaken us again by its co-operation, or to slay us outright by its opposition?

The oftener a man is reported dead, says the people, the longer he lives. We invite the anti-Zionist writers to read the latest reports on our movement. They are nothing but corrections to their — let us call them works. Zionism has grown great and is growing, because it is the cry for life of a reborn Judah, the cry for a homeland, because it is the necessity of Judah's misery. An impulsive popular movement always finds the spirits it needs, always the means to reach its goal, however many will-o'-the-wisps may dance along the way. Zionism will die when the Jewish people dies, however many betrayers of their people may labour to that end.

The English reading public stands in far closer contact with its newspaper than is the case with us. There exists an exchange and correspondence between the two. On every occasion the reader takes up his pen, and the newspaper grants room to his utterances, complaints and suggestions. Of interest now are two letters which the "Jewish Chronicle" received from the circle of its subscribers on account of its attitude towards Zionism, particularly in its discussion of the Constantinople negotiations, and which it publishes in its last number with a sour-sweet countenance. The first letter reads:

Sir! There seems to be more than an undercurrent of ill-suppressed joy finding expression in the so-called Jewish weeklies beyond the great water on the occasion of the news of the Sultan's empty sympathy with the great cause which the Zionists represent. Fifty years ago the news of the postponement of Israel's sweetest hope would have plunged all Israel into the deepest mourning. To-day the modernised Jew has not only outlived the glory of his forefathers; he would do well to pause on his downward course to ask himself whether the worship of clumsy teraphim is anything other than idolatry, and the slave of circumstance anything other than a slave. Never since the return of the Jews, under the leadership of the immortal Scribe, to rebuild the Temple has there been a movement in which the persecuted race placed more confidence than in that which makes millions of mourning hearts tremble with hopeful prayer and sympathy. Alas! if it be but a flickering dawn on the rim of the grey horizon, yet for at least three-quarters of martyred Israel it is a gleam of light in the endless night full of heart-oppressing nightmare. It is easy for a clear understanding to grasp why the lost sons of Israel, falsely called Reform Jews, mock at the idea of another redemption, although greater things in our epic history have not succeeded. Ignorance, material prosperity and selfish motives render these people incapable of discussing such impressions as form the foolish, unyielding nature of the historic son of Judah. But what are we to think of our holy Orthodox, who three times daily raise their prayer for the restoration of Zion, and take to hasty flight when the realisation of their prayers is held up to them as a possible event? If this is honest, manly firmness, what then is droll inconstancy? Political considerations may make the holding aloof of certain persons from the great movement appear justified, but rejoicing over its momentary failure — a failure which no one at all acquainted with treacherous ways and caprices will regard as exactly a cause for despair — is surely as un-Jewish as it is unmanly and contemptible. The Zionist "Utopia" is the most significant expression of the inalienable claims of the Jews since the times of Titus Vespasianus, indeed the only great and remarkable event in the history of the modern Jews. Let the remainder of our strange, colourless Judaism, with its various sub-species, which leave one in doubt whether to laugh or to weep over them, remain unmoved. This will be inscribed in history with steel and iron, and there will be little room left over for the glory of our noisy little great men.

Yours obediently, Henry Iliowizi.*)

  1. Collingwood Avenue, Muswell Hill N.

The second letter is couched still more sharply:

Sir! Dr. Herzl's unsuccessful mission to Constantinople has furnished you with material for comment, and whoever takes the trouble to read between the lines must recognise the ill-concealed jubilation over this failure.

For regular readers of the "Jewish Chronicle," who know its attitude on the question all along, this attitude was not surprising. A surprise, on the contrary, would have been in place had your comments been of another kind. But what was perhaps a small surprise on this occasion is that the "Jew. Chr." — otherwise so shrewd in all worldly matters — is so wholly unable to appreciate Dr. Herzl's gigantic work, and regards his failure to obtain the desired Charter from the Sultan on his third visit as proof that the project will never succeed. As though the Sultan had merely been waiting for Dr. Herzl in order to accept his plan!

To the straightforward mind the wonder — as it would seem to me — lies not in the Sultan's not yet having conceded everything that Dr. Herzl asked, but in his having taken the request into consideration, in his having made some offers. And that is a good omen for the ultimate success of Zionism and deserves the heartiest congratulations. For it is in truth far more than the most sanguine among us (the editor of the "Jewish Chronicle" perhaps excepted) ever expected at the opening of the negotiations....

Dr. Herzl will press on and will succeed in the end. The Sultan — to judge from his gracious and benevolent attitude towards this great question, and from the fact that he has, after all, already made some concessions — will in the end grant everything.

Combination and alliance — these are the watchwords of the day; and Turkey can conclude no better or more reliable alliance than with the Jews. It is perhaps the case of the


*) Henry Iliowizi is a refined poet and portrayer of Russian-Jewish life.