No. 28 — "Die Welt" — Page 5
(continued from page 4)
…assertion stands upon the ground of scientific experience, and accordingly I have only scientific criticism to fear. But what in all the world has consideration of what the antisemites might say about it to do with this biological problem?! "He who knows the truth and speaks it not is verily a wretched wight" — this forceful saying ought surely to be ever present to your German heart. "Self-defence in the light of publicity" is, after all, the watchword of your society. Well, I think that self-protection demands above all self-discipline, and self-discipline has as its first condition unbending honesty towards oneself, ruthless truthfulness about one's own weaknesses. Pursing the lips is of no avail; one must whistle! I have not overlooked that at the close of your letter you yourselves recommend that in Jewish affairs one should not "trouble" oneself about the antisemites; but this comes after you have, in four different places, impressed upon me the effect of my publication upon the antisemites!
Your letter shows precisely the same double face as the whole activity of your society; you ought to make its symbol the double head of Janus, which on the one side signified war and on the other peace. Now you encourage loud protest and embittered outcry, now you practise soothing and cloaking. Wherever a weakness or a vice is laid to our charge from the Christian side, you are at your post to gloss it over and dispute it away; the truly distinguished and, on the whole, not unjust criticism of a Schmoller you brand with vehemence as scientific antisemitism, yet in the same breath you extol the value of honest criticism for our community (your society's journal, 1901, p. 198). Repeatedly and urgently your side has warned against a Jewish Centre policy, and yet at the last Landtag election in Posen you had a special emissary canvass for a candidate who, though highly unsympathetic to the Jews of Posen as a politician, had the advantage of being a Jew. On every fitting occasion you parade your national Germanism, and with your name you wish to embrace all citizens of the Jewish faith; but your honoured chairman surrendered both, briefly and succinctly, at a students' meeting with the words: "With us every German Jew finds his place, be he orthodox, be he liberal in religious matters, be his religion dear to his heart or does he coldly disregard everything that religion as such offers (p. 383) .... no matter whether they profess themselves Germans of the Jewish faith or Germans of Jewish nationality (p. 428)."
This obscurity in your fundamental views and the contradictoriness of your practical activity, upon which Dr. Bodenheimer passed judgment with the harsh word "hotchpotch society," prevents most of those who share my convictions from taking part in your endeavours. This is not to say that the notions of Zionist and Central-Union man are absolutely exclusive of one another; although I myself declined to join your society on grounds of principle, I nevertheless respect the power of the individual personality to reconcile within itself, and to combine harmoniously, certain opposites that appear to me irreconcilable. I have, moreover, always maintained that your society should not be attacked from our ranks without necessity; for I am convinced — and here, O horror, comes yet another fearful concession to the antisemites! — that for the hitherto wholly indifferent elements of German Jewry your society is the best preparatory school for Jewish nationalism; that, in a word, the Central Union is a cadet academy from which the ablest ensigns of Zionism will one day go forth.
Precisely because I am thus free of all animosity towards you, I should like in conclusion to take the liberty of returning your friendly counsels to me with like services for you. It is truly a pity how your great moral and material resources are squandered on trifles. Do you seriously believe it to be your task to remonstrate against the closing to Jewish visitors of a garden belonging to the church parish (p. 641)? Or do you consider it truly meritorious to procure the punishment of a tramway conductor who had called out the station Jüdenstrasse as Judenstrasse (p. 695)? Is it not a labour of Sisyphus to track down and earnestly refute every piece of stupidity of some antisemitic ink-coolie? There is nothing to which the fable of the Hydra applies so well as to the monster "settled opinion"; scarcely has one struck off one of its heads with an argument and set about making the second follow, than the first has already grown again (Suttner). I challenge you to show me ten righteous men who have been cured of antisemitism by the work of your society or by the reading of your journal!
As against all these pettinesses there are truly great, significant and worthy tasks for your society; living in the German East, I aim here above all at a positively burning question: the position of German citizens of the Jewish faith in the Eastern Marches. You are very well aware that the Jews there, who at elections and otherwise in public life are, as a matter of course, claimed for Germanism and the oppression of the Poles, are not only, as in the rest of Germany, politically and socially proscribed, but are moreover being slowly expropriated by that very German policy of settlement and co-operatives. A glance at the political literature of the day teaches this; it has been made especially plain to you in various cries of distress from the circles of your Posen members. Nevertheless you have hitherto, with astonishing skill, avoided taking a position on this highly important question, and have indeed opposed active or passive resistance to any public discussion of the matter. That I call: self-denial in the shadow of secret sittings; self-defence in the light of publicity would have required that you should, first, have organised the economic self-help of the Jews before they are ground to pieces between Germans and Poles, and, secondly, have demanded, as the indispensable precondition of any co-operation in the policy of Germanisation, the honest and practical realisation of our equality of rights throughout Germany. Instead of this you draw up paper protests against the distinction drawn by the Minister of War between Germans, Poles and Jews — a differentiation of the three nationalities which in the German East is perfectly current even in the mouths of right-thinking Central-Union men — and you advance your rights, not by turning to account a balance of power very favourable to you, but by publishing ten articles of faith on Right, Charity and Fatherland.
Hic Rhodus, hic salta: here you can furnish the proof of your capacity; here, by a courageous action, you can win the respect of all German Jews — and Christians! Take care lest one day Zionism appear on the scene here too and take the wind out of your sails!