Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 8 · 21 February 1902
2printed page
scan 2 of 16

Page 2 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 8

(continued from page 1)

…a confession and not as a jurisprudence, and it has preserved this many-sided character down to the present day. Therefore, it was answered, it is from this standpoint also entirely fitted to be the object of a science, which has to treat it as a living organism. Were Judaism to consist solely of an accumulation of articles of faith and formulae of law, it would indeed be no object for a science, and the systematic or critical treatment of these would still be far from conferring upon it the character of a science. The most abundant knowledge is not yet science. Science is the investigation of the essence of a thing in its origin, its becoming, its development, its existence and its working, in the living connexion of cause and effect, in the comprehension of its principle and of that principle's radiations and embodiment, of its purpose, its means and its realisation. It goes without saying that to science there belong the most careful knowledge of the subject, that is, the most complete material possible, critical sifting and systematic elaboration. But only upon this foundation does the true edifice of science arise, which contains the knowledge of the essence as it exists in the whole and in all its parts, in all its historical manifestations and creations, and as it has realised itself and is realising itself. Thus there can indeed be a Science of Judaism, and it will present itself partly in the scientific history of Judaism, partly in the scientific treatment of its content of thought, as this shows itself both in its innermost life and in its forms and real products.

This Science of Judaism is not new, as some maintain; it has already had several epochs. Not that we count here the religio-philosophical works of Philo the Alexandrian and of Saadia, for a merely religio-philosophical treatment is not yet science. Maimonides, however, is certainly one of the founders of the latter. The mighty figure of that man, in whose personality the strongest and most remarkable qualities of the Jewish genius appear as though compressed into one, was epoch-making in this field. He was too much of an Aristotelian not to have grasped and treated Judaism also as a science, after the example of his master, who founded science altogether. Maimonides not only set forth the content of thought of Judaism religio-philosophically, but he also treated systematically the articles of faith and the Law in its Mosaic and its traditional form, and endeavoured to discuss their purpose and their content of thought and, finally, to establish their formation historically. Yet all this, it is true, remained with him an attempt, and everyone knows that the historical conception of his time was bound to be deficient.

Men who more or less made use of a scientific method there were, no doubt, many more. We might, indeed, make it very easy for ourselves in this respect; we need only point to the great number of learned thinkers and their sterling treatises. The abundance of intellect and labour which the representatives of Jewish learning developed in the course of those centuries can only be touched upon in passing, but not remotely exhausted.

Azariah di Rossi's "Meor Enaim" is an intellectual creation of the first rank. The wonderful originality, too, which dwelt in the mental vision of R. Elijah of Vilna, and which revealed itself in everything he wrote, bore in some measure the stamp of an almost scientific mode of research; but these phenomena remained isolated. It is therefore not to be wondered at that the Science of Judaism is regarded as, in particular, a product of the 19th century. It began with the consciousness that Judaism, in order to attain a higher significance within our time, and with it a lasting existence, required treatment as a science, and with the attempts to treat individual subjects from its domain in this spirit and after this manner, such as Zunz's "Zeitschrift für die Wissenschaft des Judenthums" (1822—23) contained in its three numbers. From then onwards it was especially the history of Judaism as such, and as the history of the Jews, which, as a highly important part of the Science of Judaism, received comprehensive treatment. There appeared the historical work of Jost, "Geschichte der Israeliten seit der Zeit der Makkabäer" (1820—1828), then his "Allgemeine Geschichte des jüdischen Volkes" (1831—1832), the "Neue Geschichte der Israeliten von 1815—1845" (1847), and his "Geschichte des Judenthums" (1857—1859). Beside him there appeared, breaking new ground and laying the foundation of scientific treatment, the work of Zunz, "Die gottesdienstlichen Vorträge der Juden, historisch entwickelt" (Berlin, 1832), which was followed up to 1865 by the same author's works in literary history on synagogal poetry. Standing upon their shoulders, their disciples did not fail in able activity, in extension, correction and deeper comprehension. The works of Herzfeld, "Geschichte des Volkes Israel von der Zerstörung des ersten Tempels bis zur Einsetzung des Makkabäers Schimeon zum Hohenpriester und Fürsten" (Brunswick, 1847 to 1857), Grätz (1853—1869), Fürst, "Geschichte des Karäerthums" (1862—1865), Geiger, Steinschneider, Frankel, Munk, Duke and others, to which a multitude of special histories are added, bear loud testimony to the mighty historical consciousness which pervaded and filled the Jews of more recent times, and which pressed ever more towards true scientific satisfaction, such as is won not merely in the critical illumination of the facts, but also in the deep and clear understanding of all historical phenomena. In this manner the history of Judaism in itself, of its literature, of its worship, and of the Jews themselves in every direction and in all their parts, was opened up, investigated and set forth with more or less thoroughness, criticism and understanding. Among the works which weave the unfading wreath of glory of the German Jews, Grätz's "Geschichte des jüdischen Volkes" was received with an unusual excitement, briskly fanned by literary controversy. The conception of history founded upon the principle of Jewish nationhood, begun with certain views of Fränkel's, makes in Grätz's History a significant advance, although in many respects Grätz still remains true to the old school. Just because with Grätz everything entered the circle of subjective feeling and radiated out from it, a life came into the work which perhaps at times pulsed too violently for the historical style, but which by that very means brought the work nearer to the understanding of our time. As for the other, fairly numerous historical works, they find it hard to push their way out of the shadow in which Grätz places them. Yet Cassel, Kayserling, Karpels and Brann have produced important work, partly in popular history, partly in the history of general Jewish literature. Unforgettable remains David Kaufmann, a rich dispenser of knowledge, an enormously industrious investigator, who with noble zeal and moral earnestness worked through almost every domain of Jewish learning. Weiss, Harkavy, Joseph Halevy, Friedmann, Jacobs, Schechter, Gaster, Bacher, Güdemann, Schwarz and others have, with larger and smaller works, the literature