No. 8 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3
(continued from page 2)
…enriched. In France the "Société des Etudes Juives" is at work, in England the "Jewish Quarterly Review".
No less, however, there gradually awoke the endeavour to bring the doctrinal content and the content of thought of Judaism, too, to scientific knowledge and treatment. This, it is true, arose rather from practical motives. These practical motives were the sermon and religious instruction. Both, having grown out of a real need, must seek out the ideal content of Judaism, even where they discuss the Law and the ceremony. But the former does this in free movement and in popular fashion, the latter systematically, but superficially. Only in the forties of the 19th century was the attempt undertaken to raise the doctrinal content of Judaism to a higher consciousness in a philosophical manner as well. The one attempt was made from the eclectic standpoint and moved only about the highest principles (Formstecher); the second, entering more deeply into the details and the character of the doctrine, constructed the teaching of Judaism upon the basis of Hegelian principles (Samuel Hirsch); the third sought to make the doctrine of revelation an "exact science" (Steinheim), that is, to prove it like a physical experiment or a mathematical axiom. More important in this respect was the thoroughly national-Jewish philosopher Nachman Krochmal. The surprising quality of his outlook, his acuteness and his gift for combination raised him high above his fellow-scholars, and under his master hand the harmonising of Judaism with pure philosophy also took on a noble form. To this was joined a more many-sided treatment by a more inductive method, that is, upon the basis of history and of the concepts of natural science. (Philippsohn's "Israelitische Religionslehre," 3 volumes, 1861, 1862 and 1865.) We may call the latter original also for the sake of the following element. With the deeper comprehension of Judaism, indeed already with its emergence into the life of modern culture — one may even say, already with the demand for equal rights for the Jews — a twofold matter was bound to come into question. First, namely, the calling and the position of Judaism in general. It was not long before the proclamation rang out from the Jewish pulpit that Judaism was not merely, in particularist fashion, a religion of the Jews, but had a calling in the history of the world. This was arrived at as though of itself. The sermon, by its nature, was always bound to lean chiefly upon the Prophets. Called upon to treat above all the general propositions of the doctrine of God and the laws of morality, and to impress these upon the people on the basis of historical Judaism, it placed itself upon the standpoint of the Prophets and culminated in the conception that one day the whole of mankind would profess this doctrine of God and realise these laws of morality. But after the Jewish sermon had proclaimed this often and loudly enough, it had at last to be comprehended and demonstrated historically as well, and in particular in how far the teaching of Judaism has passed over into humanity at large, partly through the religions derived from it, and continually passes over through the spread of our Bible, partly has worked, through the progressive development of the human race, in the life of the latter, and works ever more. To this, however, a second thing was added. If the sermons and the religious books had for their subject the doctrine of God and the laws of morality, there was yet a third thing present, of no less importance. Political and social life in Europe had arrived at a period of energetic development, and was bringing every branch of the domain of the State, of society and of law into question anew, giving occasion to protracted discussion and to the most thorough investigation.
Here the question of the relation of religion to those objects forced itself forward of its own accord; but it lay nearest for Judaism, which from its origin had regarded and treated these great elements of human life as integral parts of religion, as necessary consequences of its moral teaching. Mosaic and Talmudic law was treated only in part from an independent scientific standpoint (Fränkel, Saalschütz, Samuel Mayer 1862, 1866), and in part with particular reference to those general questions (Salvador). Together with these special works, however, the undertaking was now also made to draw out from the special laws and institutions of Judaism, and in particular of Mosaism, the general principles, and to demonstrate that these are precisely the ones towards which the development of the human race is striving and for whose realisation it is struggling — a striving and struggling which at that time came forth with lasting force. These principles, consisting, as consequences of the doctrine of the unity of God, of the unity of the world and of the unity of the human race, in the union of all the nations of men into one human family, in the equal rights and personal freedom of all individuals, in a certain equalising of the conditions of property within the freedom of personal ownership, and in the harmony of these rights of the individual with the merging of the latter into the social totality of the State, were to be demonstrated as the principles of Mosaism, as it partly proclaimed them and partly embodied them subjectively in its institutions, and as they are finally to be realised in universal peace, in the universal dominion of love and of right. It is evident that this great question of principles could in turn only be a part of the former question concerning the historical calling of Judaism. For both points Philippsohn's lectures on the development of religious ideas in Judaism, Christianity and Islam (1847) and "on the religion of society" (1848) broke new ground. Unfortunately this riding of principles went too far. Men laboured to construct an antithesis between a particularist national Judaism and the idea of the brotherhood of man. Such an antithesis, however, does not exist, for the basis of a sound and reasonable peace among the nations is precisely a vigorous national culture. The one does not exclude the other; the one is the precondition of the other. An advocacy of principles which would leave its own nationhood without protection, which in particular would not concern itself with the preservation of its own individuality — that would be a fantastic, impossible, chimerical mission, in timeless eternity, in spaceless, free omnipresence.
It was a fashionable dogma of that time. Good will, but with it a want of self-consciousness and of proud strength, unhappily drove the men of that time into a land of mists and compelled them to climb up into a higher stratum of the air. Instead of dispelling faint-heartedness soberly and strongly, earnestly and with dignity, and strengthening the national feeling — instead of personality and free individuality, unreserved national candour and the naïveté of a people — they kept the national feeling shyly hidden in the depths of their bosom and developed a phraseology which even then was easy to riddle with holes. They lacked not talent, nor yet good will, but courage. Again and again they fell into preaching, again and again they displayed the worn-out gesture of self-denial. Pitifully petty diplomatic arts to purchase the favour of the "nations"; a yearning for the heights towards an apostolic world-mission, which was expected with touching naïveté in the near future; a tedious and partly also foolish reluctance of the commonplaces about the brotherhood of man, without the understanding that it is precisely through separation