Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 7 · 14 February 1902
4printed page
scan 4 of 16

Page 4. — "Die Welt" — No. 7.

"The Times" of 4th February of this year writes: "The Jewish Colonization Association (= "Ica"), whose statutes show that it was formed for the purpose of promoting Jewish colonisation, colonises too little and tries to make good its bankruptcy in this field by desultory charity... The labour to make Palestine rise again is there, and the capital is there likewise. But the labour must be diverted from its present lustreless and insignificant migration, and the capital likewise from its present lustreless and insignificant employment. The use of the Hirsch millions for Palestine would be absolutely legal. For Baron Hirsch himself, who unhappily died too early, would, had he lived longer, as an able man of business soon have abandoned the unproductive experiment in the Argentine, in order to exploit the unexpected national enthusiasm for the work of colonisation, of which he, with many other philanthropists, was a pioneer."

"Daily Expers" of 3rd February writes, among other things: "... The "Ica" could achieve no success because its plans were wrong and because they were opposed to the Jewish spirit. ... Its project was unpractical, and the Jews cannot and must not wait for it any longer."

"The Standard" of 3rd February reports: "At present there are two great projects for the regeneration of the Jews of Europe: the one called into being by Baron Hirsch, the so-called "Ica", which settles Jews in the Argentine, and the other project, which aims at the colonisation of Palestine. The latter is the one more favoured by the people..."

And the "Evening Standard" writes: "... Zangwill's proposal to use the millions of Baron Hirsch for the colonisation of Palestine should at last clear the financial difficulties out of the way. The future alone can decide upon the political and commercial success of this experiment, but the good wishes of all right-thinking Christians will accompany the Jews in their aspirations after a national unity."

"The Echo" of 3rd February writes: "Zangwill's speech to the Jewish meeting held on Saturday in honour of the delegates to the last Basle Congress was a remarkable utterance, inspired by a strong business spirit and a lofty national idea. The Jew as a homeless wanderer is doomed to destruction... We associate ourselves wholly and fully with Mr. Zangwill's statements and deplore the inactivity of the Hirsch trustees. If this enormous fund were to be applied for the Jewish nation, Zionism would be a fait accompli, and a new day would dawn for Israel."

Detailed reports of Zangwill's speech were further given by the following great daily papers: "Daily Telegraph", "Daily News", "Morning Post", "Observer", Morning Leader", "Daily Graphic", "Daily Chronicle", "Sunday Sun", and many others.


A Board that Desires no New Elections.

By Dr. Elias (Mülhausen).

On 27th January of this year I wrote the following letter to the President of the "Alliance israélite universelle" in Paris:

Dear Sir,

Articles 8 and 9 of the statutes of the "Alliance" provide that the Central Committee is elected by general ballot of the members of the society and by simple majority of votes; that the members of the Central Committee are elected for a period of nine years, but that every three years one third of them must retire; and finally that the members of the Central Committee are eligible for re-election without restriction.

The last elections took place on 8th October 1893.

According to the statutes, the following elections should have taken place in the years 1896 and 1899.

For reasons that remained unknown to the electors, the Committee resolved to postpone the elections of the year 1896, and fixed them for the end of the year 1898. At the end of 1898, however, they again did not take place.

At that time, according to the Bulletin of the "Alliance", all the members of the Central Committee as well as the most important district committees were of the opinion that elections in which all the members of the society could take part would produce certain inconveniences, and that the Committee would do better itself to choose by co-optation the persons who had been proposed to replace the deceased or retired members. The advice was followed.

Thus the elections took place neither in the year 1896 nor in the year 1898; but the year 1899, too, passed without new elections.

It is not worth while at the moment to inquire whether "the reasons of various kinds" that were brought forward for repeatedly postponing the elections were really of so grave a nature that, of two evils, elections or conduct contrary to the statutes, the elections were the greater.

I cannot, however, suppress the remark that elections held in the most various parts of the world commonly give rise to inconveniences in one country or another, and that on the ground of these inconveniences one might abolish universal suffrage altogether.

But one would then also destroy precisely that which gives our society its democratic character, and which is the best guarantee that our members know why they support our work, and that the hand which helps is guided by a brain that thinks.

However that may be, the position of the Central Committee is at present as follows:

It consists of 60 members. Yet only 27 are to be regarded as elected in accordance with the statutes, and of these 27 only 20 have the right and the duty to direct our society, because of the 60 members of the Committee 20 must submit to re-election every three years, and these re-elections have not taken place for over 6 years.

The mandate of the remaining 40 is, according to the statutes and the laws, null.

And on 8th October of this year, unless new elections take place beforehand, the mandate of these 20 also expires.

The board of the "Alliance" will then consist of persons who can no longer be regarded as the trusted representatives of the members of the society, who no longer know whether their ideas agree with those of the majority, and who are therefore no longer in a position to direct the society according to the ideas of this majority.

This state of affairs is untenable.