Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 52 · 27 December 1901
7printed page
scan 7 of 16
Facsimile · scan 7 of 16
Scan of p. 7
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 52. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 7.


(continued from page 6)

…will be acquired for this purpose; but then the old land has no excessive immigration of new settlers to expect either. One of the two it must be: how anyone can assume that the organisation indeed prospers, but remains confined to the site of the first experiment, that goes beyond my horizon.

The only question, then, is whether the first experiment has a well-founded prospect of succeeding. And this question I believe I may answer in the affirmative with all decision, and in this opinion I find myself in the best of company. All the agrarian politicians, agriculturists and co-operators to whom the scheme has hitherto been submitted have without a single exception expressed their conviction that the plan has the best prospects. The general secretary of the English Co-operative Union, I. C. Gray, has, without any knowledge of my writings, laid before his congress an almost identical plan with an almost identical demonstration. But I am no believer in authority, and so I will briefly adduce the substantive grounds which make it more than probable to me that the collectivist settlement society with individualist distribution of the yield really presents that superior economic form which I see in it. They are grounds of history and of economic theory.

The history of the agricultural productive co-operative, which I was the first to write³), shows in the clearest manner that without exception these undertakings displayed the more glorious prosperity the nearer their organisation came to the scheme I have set up. Even the experiments with capitalist half-share farming and with the bonus system show that the wastage of material is strongly diminished and the gross yields strongly increased when the labourer has an interest in the net yield of the estate. The only nearly pure experiment which has come to my knowledge, the co-operative husbandry on the estate of Rahaline in the county of Clare (Ireland) in the years 1830—32, had positively fabulous results in respect both of the economic net yield and of the moral bearing of the members. Unhappily this most promising germ of a new and better social order was shattered by a misfortune coming from without, which had not the least thing to do with the working itself: gaming losses brought the proprietor Vandeleur to bankruptcy, and the estate was put up to auction by the creditors. Had a co-operative law existed even then, this catastrophe would have been impossible.⁴)

To meet irrelevant objections, I must here emphasise with the utmost force that here, as everywhere, I have spoken only of the collectivist working co-operative with individualist distribution. The favourable verdict finds no application to collectivist co-operatives with communist distribution, and just as little to the so-called "Cooperative farming" and the so-called "agricultural productive co-operatives" of Great Britain.

For in all these forms of organisation precisely that is eliminated from which, in the settlement co-operative, I promise myself the superiority over the great private undertaking: the strong self-interest! The communist experiments of an Owen, a Cabet and so forth, with their labour according to capacity and their distribution according to "needs", eliminated self-interest altogether. The same holds of Cooperative Farming, of the great estates which certain English consumers' societies have tilled by wage-labourers: to call these undertakings "co-operatives" because the capitalist landlord is a co-operative society can only confuse; and just as little may that be called an agricultural productive co-operative which in England sails under that flag. They are joint-stock companies of small shareholders, which have agriculture carried on upon leased or purchased land by wage-labourers who at times, to be sure, are members also. They distribute the net profit (when, that is, any comes in) not upon the labour performed, but upon the capital subscribed. Since now the number of the non-working partners monstrously outweighs the number of the working ones — in one case several 100 shareholders to 7—8 labourers) the spur of self-interest is here blunted to the point of complete ineffectiveness.⁵)

To sum it up: whoever brings against me objections drawn from these experiences of economic organisations which are built upon exactly the opposite principle proves nothing else than that he has not grasped the problem at all.

I believe I have even shown that the agricultural working co-operatives with communist distribution, which are not rare, notably in America, prospered just so long as the manner of distribution was, on account of the general poverty, wholly a matter of indifference, and that it was only communism which brought them to stagnation and in many cases to shipwreck from the moment when a higher well-being came into conflict with the communist distribution.⁶)

A weightier objection is the following: the history of the productive co-operatives in general shows an unbroken chain of failures; development itself has passed sentence upon this form of production; it is not possible to build a new economic form upon it.

This objection is fully justified, but it relates only to the industrial productive co-operative. I have myself proved its regular failure, not only out of its history, with greater sharpness than any one of my predecessors, but I have also succeeded in furnishing the stringent proof that it can never succeed. In the great majority of cases it is wrecked, before ever it has come to flower, upon the three reefs that threaten its voyage: the struggle for credit, for the market, and for the form of labour. But if in rare cases it escapes these reefs, then it has meanwhile, without exception, transformed itself out of a co-operative into a parasitic capitalist form of exploitation; and it must always so transform itself, according to the "Law of Transformation" discovered by me. It bars itself against new comers, engages fresh labour only as wage-labourers who have no share in the profit, and loses the co-operatively democratic organisation. According as few "members" exploit many wage-labourers, or many small capitalists employ few wage-labourers, there sails here an employers' partnership or a joint-stock company under the flag of the erstwhile productive co-operative.

But this law does not hold for the agricultural productive co-operative. It is in every respect the antipode of the industrial one. This lies deeply grounded already in the fundamental antithesis, for the most part wholly misapprehended by present-day socialism, between primary production and the refining of materials. The formation of the prices of commodities is subject in the two to a wholly different law; in industry it takes place predominantly through supply, in primary production predominantly through demand. There, in the long run, it is the supply of the best equipped undertaking that determines the price of the commodity, in that it compels the whole of the competition either to withdraw, or to bring its own working at least to the same height of productivity, or to restrict its profit ad maximum. In agriculture, on the contrary, it is the demand on the part of the urban markets which determines the price of primary production; and that price of produce becomes the market price which repays cost of production and transport charges to the undertaking farthest from the market, or working upon the worst soil (the marginal farmer), whose produce is still requisite for the satisfying of the market. Consequently there exists among agriculturists no competition for price and for sale!!

(Conclusion follows.)


³) My "Siedlungsgenossenschaft", Book 2, Chapter 4, page 387 f.

⁴) Fuller particulars in the work just cited, p. 405 f., and more circumstantially in Pare, "On cooperative Agriculture", London 1870.

⁵) Compare thereon my paper in No. 36, 1901, of the genossenschaftl. Blätter, Berlin.

⁶) My "Siedlungsgenossenschaft", page 444 f.