Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 51 · 20 December 1901
6printed page
scan 6 of 16

Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 51.

(continued from page 5)

…such a Zionist can very easily be led into regarding one of the means — economic improvement, for example — as an end in itself, and into contenting himself with a half-cure. Above all, however, this standpoint is far too narrow and far too — utilitarian. It corresponds to that of those certainly very worthy English moralists to whom the greatest possible "happiness" of the greatest number appears as the highest ideal. How sad the beautiful word "happiness" sounds out of a toothless mouth! And what a chimney-corner perspective it is, to let the vast and wonderful world be steered so that as many beings as possible may feel comfortable! If ever great values of life proceeded out of happiness, it was a happiness into which the deepest tragedy and the most unspeakable suffering were mingled. And can such happiness — the happiness of personalities — be striven after?

I will say as plainly as possible what I mean. If I had to choose for my people between a comfortable, unfruitful happiness, such as in old times fell to the lot of many of its neighbours, and a beautiful death in the last straining of life, I should have to choose the latter. For it would create, though it were but for a single moment, something divine; the former only something all-too-human.

To create! The Zionist who feels the whole holiness of this word and lives up to it seems to me to stand upon the highest step. To create new values, new works, out of the depth of his immemorial peculiarity, out of the peculiar, incomparable force of his blood, which for so fearfully long was struck into the fetters of unproductivity — that is an ideal for the Jewish people. To create the monuments of its being! To let its individuality ring itself out in a new conception of life! To set a new kind, a new form, a new play of possibilities before the eyes of infinity! To let a new beauty glow forth for those thirsting after beauty who wait in the darkness, to let a new star rise up in the magical night-sky of the eternities! But first to struggle through, with bloody hands, with undaunted heart, to one's own being, out of which all these wounds will emerge. To discover oneself! To find oneself! To win oneself by struggle!

This way signifies: to seek one's people because one loves it, and to shrink back before no repugnance one finds. To see in one's people the material for a statue, and not to let oneself be confounded by the fact that this material is not marble of Paros or of Carrara, but tough, unwieldy, refractory stone. This way signifies: to will a life for one's people, but not a life that contents itself with living, rather a rich, whole, creative, procreative life.

*

I have only attempted to sketch the principal types. There are yet other ways to Zionism, side-ways as it were. The most peculiar among them is perhaps the way of the social theorist who would fain realize his ideas upon us. Zionism appears to him as the possibility of a gigantic social experiment. The men who come to us thus, usually without any right understanding of the whole beauty of our national idea and incapable of penetrating to it, are nevertheless a fructifying force. They bring new elements into our discussions; they compel us to find a positive attitude towards the great currents of our time.

The remaining ways offer interest of various kinds. There is the way of the Judaic scholar who wishes a secure abode for his science; the way of the artist who seeks understanding and employment for his Jewish creation; of the technologist who will help to build a modern life for his people and at the same time divines great possibilities of a free activity favoured on every side. There is the way of the unsettled man who has found a milieu of his own and clings to it, and the way of the young half-sceptic who joyfully grasps at a native view of life. There is the way of the historiosopher to whom the past gave mysterious hints, and the way of the politician who gazes into Asia's wonderful future. There is the way of the religious man, and there is the beautiful, musing way of the romantic, who, otherwise than the religious man, loves the old soulful traditions and their quiet life. There are base, ignoble ways of which we will not speak. But there is also the great way of the hero, who was born in an age without laurel. There is the straight, ruthless way of the dreamer who will live his dream. And there is also, overhung with young roses, resounding with young lark-song, shone upon by the young morning sun, the way of sorrow of the poet-prophet, who will die without having beheld his longing.

*

And yet the Zionists who have within them more than Zionism, the shimmering Zion itself, have gone none of these ways. They are those who needed to go no way at all. They are the Jewish people.

This people is that material of our sculpture. It by no means becomes capable of being worked through its Zionism. But it covers itself with a great white radiance which resembles that of marble. From this radiance hope proceeds. And from hope, creation. ("Jüdisches Jahrbuch".)

Jewish Settlements.

By Dr. Franz Oppenheimer, Berlin.

(Continued.)

Hitherto we have spoken only of the form of possession; within it, however, there are two extreme forms of possible operation, which may of course be combined with one another in manifold gradations. The one is the co-operative operation, the other the individual operation upon co-operatively owned land. Which of the two is to be recommended? Now, this question cannot in principle be answered at all. The more intensively agricultural cultivation is carried on — that is to say, above all in horticulture and viticulture — the less it is suited for a common operation by a numerous co-operative society; the more extensive it is, the better it is suited thereto, and the lie of the land also makes differences. Extensive corn-growing upon great plains is far more easily carried on by a numerous community than the same corn-growing upon broken hilly ground. Here, then, no general rules can be set up.

If I hold the common operation, in the cases fundamentally suited for it, to be superior to the individual operation, I have for this an important private-economic and an important common-economic ground. The private-economic ground is this, that in my conviction, other circumstances being equal, the large concern in agriculture must prove itself superior to the small concern just as in industry — mark well: other circumstances being equal! These have hitherto been producible only quite in isolated instances. The small concern has hitherto always received an enormous start in the self-interest of the small proprietor, who works with incomparably higher diligence, incomparably higher attention, and incomparably more careful sparing of the living and the dead means of production than the day-labourer of the large concern. For this reason the advantages which the large concern alone possesses on its side could not express themselves clearly in the net yield; they were for the greatest part cancelled, and in part outweighed, by the interestless and wasteful labour of the agricultural proletariat. These advantages are the possibility of engaging an intelligent special-