No. 51. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 7.
(continued from page 6)
…ist, the employment of labour-saving machines, of which, apart from the threshing-machine, scarcely one can be brought to the small concern even through the co-operative organization; further, a systematic administration with all the advantages of the division and the combination of labour, the possibility of undertaking comprehensive improvements, and finally the purchase of the means of production wholesale and sale upon the best market. If it is possible to transform the workers "of the large concern" into interested participators in the net yield, by assigning the net yield to their co-operative society, then it is more than probable that all the advantages of the large concern remain, while all the advantages of the small concern are brought to it. I estimate, after careful calculations, that other circumstances being equal the gross yields would rise through better work by at least 50 per cent. as compared with a capitalistically operated large estate, and that the wear of material would sink by at least 100 per cent.
A collectivist operation, then, but with individualistic distribution of the yield; if one will not break the mainspring of the economic clockwork, self-interest, then the diligent man and the lazy, the intelligent man and the dolt, the deft man and the clumsy must not be paid alike. Where that is the case there are regularly, as the history of all communistic settlements teaches and as a member of the collapsed Ruskin Coiony (North America) aptly characterizes it, "many people who can philosophize well, and few who can dig potatoes." The net yield must be distributed not merely according to the time performed, so that repartition is made not by heads but by recorded working hours; the working hour must further be tariffed according to the performance of the individual. The qualified assistant worker, the foreman, the administrator himself must obtain a higher remuneration per working hour performed than the average adult man, and the latter again a higher one than women, children, and those only in a limited degree capable of work. The calculation is a most simple one if one introduces the working hours as general denominator: if, for example, three are reckoned to the administrator per working hour performed, or 24 per day as a lump sum, if 5/4 hour is reckoned to the foremen etc., 3/4 to the women, 1/4 to the children, per working hour performed, then at the close of the working week it is only necessary to repartition the net profit (remaining over after deduction of interest, amortization moneys and depreciations) upon the reckoned working hours. Have we, all in all, for example 100,000 performed and reckoned working hours and 30,000 marks of net profit, then we pay 30 Pfg. per hour and each has what falls to him. The fixing of this graduated tariff must unconditionally be left to the discretion of the co-operative society itself; then the free competition of the labour forces will bring to each approximately that income which his efficiency can claim. That a provision will be created for the sick, the aged, the incapable of work and so forth out of common means is self-evident, but does not belong in a purely economic consideration. Here another social motive comes in question, the charitable. To be sure, it is to be hoped that here too the purely economic care will one day, in a grand and large-hearted communal insurance, replace the alms.
That was the private-economic ground on which in suitable cases I should prefer the co-operative operation to the single operation upon co-operative soil: diminution of the burden of labour and increase of the national-economic net yield. The national-economic ground is this, that into a community with co-operative operation new elements of population can incorporate themselves far more easily and more amply than into one whose soil is wholly, or even only in great part, handed over to individual usufruct; and here it is a question of two elements for whose immigration and incorporation provision must be made: additional agricultural labour forces and tradesmen attaching themselves.
Where a flourishing village community exists, there a produit net stands at disposal which enters the market as a demand for industrial products. This demand is, for a considerable part of all industrial products, best satisfied by tradesmen who are settled in the place itself. Even the greatest world-market industry does not threaten with its competition a considerable part of the rural auxiliary trades — not the farrier and the wheelwright, the mason, the carpenter, the stove-setter, the glazier and the cabinet-maker, scarcely the shoemaker and the tailor, and not at all the whole of the so-called repairing trade. For such tradesmen the best seat is the settlement itself, where land and foodstuffs are cheaper than in the town, and where they obtain the prices of the nearest urban market without having to bear the costs of transport. Besides these village tradesmen, there belong to every flourishing rural community, of further urban elements, teachers, clergy, medical personnel, be it only a barber-surgeon and a midwife, and representatives of the retail trade — in these settlements, it is to be hoped, only salaried managers of the co-operative consumers' union and of the co-operative inn, for whom a private competition would not be permitted. One leases land to nobody who wishes to begin a private trade; a "law" is not necessary for that.
Where now there attaches itself to a peasantry a larger number of such "urban" producers as consumers of agricultural products, there agriculture of natural necessity becomes more intensive, for several reasons the statement of which would lead us too far here. And where agriculture becomes more intensive, there the area which the individual is able to cultivate with advantage sinks, and the number of working agriculturists who can be employed with advantage upon the same area grows (law of Thünen's zone-formation; cf. J. H. von Thünen, "Der isolierte Staat".) Where the whole soil is already divided up into single farms for the usufruct of the several associates, it is difficult to keep this necessary reduction of the arable units in full accordance with the increase of new agricultural labour forces. One cannot without more ado limit the well-acquired rights of the several usufructuaries, and besides, a peasant holding is a technical unit which one cannot cut up without damage. At the least the buildings become too large for the reduced area, or even, upon a change in the mode of operation, wholly or partly unusable. But where the greatest part of the land is administered in common operation, there nothing is simpler than to keep the size of the arable in accordance with the growing number of settlers. One engages the new labour forces, improves the old cultivation or passes over to higher forms of cultivation — in our latitudes one would, for example, gradually pass over piece by piece from corn-growing to the cultivation of root-crops, which requires far more labour power: and thus the adaptation between the number of workers and the given area accomplishes itself almost automatically. This ground appears to me to be decisive for the Zionist purposes, and that because it is a question of taking in very great masses of immigrants quickly. This elasticity is possessed exclusively by the collectivist agricultural operation with individualistic distribution. And if this economic form proves itself, then a beneficent circle comes into force here: the more agriculturists are settled, the more tradesmen can exist, and the more tradesmen can exist, the denser again can the agricultural population become. Here one wedge drives the other, up to a density of population whose limit has hitherto nowhere been reached and which we are by no means able to foresee. I have calculated that, taking as a basis the highest yields of primary production of to-day, not less than 4000 persons can be fed from the square kilometre of arable land.*) That is naturally neither an ideal, nor is there any probability given that ever the soci-
*) Bevölkerungsgesetz T. A. Malthus, Berlin 1901. Page 158.