"Die Welt" — No. 50 — Page 5.
(continued from page 4)
…surpluses of primary production available for these secondary branches of the economy increase; and thus the one real task of Zionism is the founding of Jewish peasantries: industry and commerce will establish themselves entirely of their own accord if the former prosper.
That, then, is the goal; but which is the best road to this goal? What must under all circumstances be avoided is precisely that means by which, in the present state of the world, a great territory could most easily be settled: the capitalist plantation system. It would perhaps not be over-difficult to sell off the territory which might be placed at the disposal of the Zionist endeavours, in great latifundia, to rich capitalists, and to have it worked by an imported Jewish agricultural proletariat. A good business might perhaps be made of it, and that is naturally the only bait for capital. Yet this thought hardly needs to be seriously put up for discussion. In the first place, this system offers room for so small a number of men that the real purpose of the action would be missed, namely to give a very considerable part of the Jewish proletariat of Eastern Europe a new home; further, there would be little sense in expatriating this population in order to plant it anew as a proletariat; and finally this new form of organisation would run point-blank counter to the last of our conditions, which demands that the private-economic organisation possess the fitness to serve as the foundation of a future political edifice. For the system of great landed property has destroyed every independent State of known history, and capitalist land-magnates go everywhere with the existing power, with which they ally themselves in order to exploit the remainder of the mass of the people. Of that, then, there can be no question! There remain as further possibilities the following: the settlement of independent peasants (middling proprietors) upon property under Roman law, and settlement in co-operative associations. By peasants we understand possessors of an area large enough, according to the quality of the soil and the shaping of the conditions of sale and transport, to occupy and decently nourish one family, at most with a small household of servants.
The first form is the most familiar to us; it rules to-day almost the whole civilised world, and it is no wonder that in Jewish colonisation too it was the first thing hit upon. But it is open to grave objections, in general, and particularly in the circumstances which occupy us here.
In general the peasant holding possessed as property under Roman law is threatened by the danger of uneconomic indebtedness, at the least at every change of generation, through mortgages for dowries and for the settlement of heirs. The holding is thereby burdened more heavily from epoch to epoch, the peasant becomes the debt-slave of the mortgagees, and for the most part he lacks the needful capital and also the needful mental elasticity for technical improvements. By this in turn the whole national economy suffers, since the net national yield, the surplus of food available for industry and commerce, remains below what is possible. And thus the blessed interaction of the forces which work from agriculture upon industry and conversely, and which under healthy conditions bring both to an ever higher flowering, is at the least checked. For the problem of Jewish colonisation, however, this system is to be advised against at least on the ground that only the smaller part of the emigrants will possess that physical strength and technical training which alone can maintain a wholly independent holding.
Chiefly for these reasons — space forbids me to speak of sundry others — the only form which appears to me serviceable and full of promise is settlement in the co-operative association; and indeed every co-operative society should, if possible, be the free and unrestricted mistress of the land assigned to it, upon the value of which it would have to pay interest and amortisation to the first acquirers of the soil, and in a later future perhaps to the administrators of the State or State-like community. This arrangement appears to me, on manifold grounds, preferable to that which has been attempted to-day, for example, in some places in New Zealand, where the society is the tenant of the State and the individual members are sub-tenants. This form is open to various grave objections. On the one hand the society, and with it the individual members, falls into a dangerous dependence upon the State (in our case upon the founding bank), into a twofold dangerous dependence: first in its freedom of movement, which might under circumstances be sorely restricted, since such a relation always creates an enormous discretionary power in the actual lords of the soil; and secondly, what is perhaps more important, in its self-responsibility. Under such conditions the individual will always be inclined to rely upon other resources than those which lie in his own industry and in his own intelligence and thrift. He will not be inclined, in hard times, and especially in the heavy labour of the colonial beginnings, to raise his performance and to screw down his demands upon life, because the loss is borne by strange, distant capitalists who seem to him immeasurably rich, and because he believes himself with justice to be safe in the assurance that an arrear in his interest obligations may not be handled quite so harshly from that quarter. Such a paralysis of self-responsibility must, however, under all circumstances be avoided! It is the death of all husbandry; with alms one solves no social problems. The highly interesting experiments in settlement which the South Australian Government has made on the Murray could apparently fail of full flower for the one reason only, that the colonists were permitted to rely upon the filled coffers of the exchequer. — Here one single form of organisation alone can avoid the road of ruin: the land must be made over in full ownership to the co-operative society of the settlers to be planted there, an ownership which may be limited only by a restriction upon alienation, best of all by a right of pre-emption on the part of the originally founding organisation, to be secured by contract and, where it is possible, in the land register. Then the society, as a juridical person, is liable in joint hand for interest and amortisation, and must be held inexorably to the fulfilment of its obligation. In order to avoid hardships which, in the first beginnings — everywhere very heavy — might destroy the undertaking, one should from the outset undertake a suitable distribution of the burdens over a longer epoch; somewhat in this wise, that a few free years be granted, then a low rate of interest demanded, which from epoch to epoch, say from five years to five years, should grow by 1 per cent., until the colony were in a position to raise the full moderate interest, and likewise to pay interest upon and to extinguish the sums of interest remitted in the first years, which would have to be entered as supplementary mortgages. From these conditions, once fixed, the founding bank, or respectively the fiscal treasury of a future State-like community, might under no circumstances abate the least thing. In the case of heavy misfortunes incurred through no fault, such as failures of harvest, damage by fire and so forth, it may give back with the one hand what it takes with the other, may grant interest-free, amortisable loans of distress, or bestow subventions by way of gift: but never may the least hope arise that any remission whatever will be granted upon the interest obligations.
In this case the society as a body has to hold exclusively to its own members, and the "lord of the soil", as we will for brevity designate the supreme organisation, has not the least thing more to do with the individuals and with their sufferings and grievances. The society may raise and apportion its sum of interest as it will, may levy a regular surcharge in order to cover deficits, or apportion deficits, as they appear, upon those able to pay, or create an organisation of creditors from which a member in distress may obtain loans at interest, or for its own-