— 12 —
(continued from page 11)
... the socialist doctrine, that abstract theory of an oligarchic science, foreign to the masses, but the universal means as well — the class struggle — adapts itself to the national peculiarity of the several peoples. English socialism, the unpolitical trade-union movement — although in the first place the result of the overpowering development of English industry — nevertheless bears unmistakably the stamp of the national phlegm. The English workman does not feel the need of political power; he does not develop upon traditions violently destroyed, and he is too cautious to surrender, for the sake of an idea buzzing about in the air, a status of possession carefully fenced off from below. The Anglo-Saxon has patience — after happily surmounting the Chartist childhood-malady he has become the good bourgeois trade-unionist, who marches slowly and without temperament, step by step, towards the goal. Development is with him and for him — it cannot slip away from him, so wherefore the haste? Not so the comrade upon the other bank of the Channel, in the land of latent revolution. The Gaul has his own socialism, a mechanical one, in distinction from the organic socialism of the Germans. The history of France, which he knows only in its catastrophes, detached from their causal connection, makes it hard for him to believe in the law of slow evolution. The spirit of Fourier, Saint Simon, Blanqui is still alive in the French proletariat; the socialist, or more correctly the communist, partnership in the gouvernement provisoire is not yet forgotten; the days of the Commune are not for ever — not even for a long while — gone by! Several times already has the proletariat stretched out its hand after power, and always with the help of barricades and the whole revolutionary apparatus — why despair on a sudden? The straw-fire of the French temperament spreads with the speed of the wind from man to man, and to-morrow the Camelot is once more king of Paris! Thus the political, the parliamentary struggle, whose silhouettes stand out sharply against the background of the eternally threatening revolution, is the chief weapon of French socialism. Millerand is not the result of a momentarily favourable constellation, but a creature of the constant lust for power of the French proletariat.
The Rhine forms the watershed between two systems of thought: the extensive system of French intuition and the intensive system of German deduction. On the left bank revolutions are misapprehended, on the right evolutions are apprehended. "The German is learned"; he condescends to enthusiasm only when it has first been legalised by science — and so there grew up in Germania the curious plant of an ideal materialism. Karl Marx, the assimilated Jew, embodies that mighty, typically national capacity for analytical criticism which has earned the Germans the title of "philosophers of humanity." Ferdinand Lassalle gave to the clumsy German theory the wings of the Jewish temperament, and thus Marxism as an applied science was lifted out of the reach of the national law of intellectual gravitation. Germany is the land of classical socialism, "classical" being here understood as the unity of form and content. The opposite, a "symbolic" socialism, is exhibited by the Romance countries, whose proletarian movements give expression to a Marxist content in a Blanquist form. The visible, explosive revolutions are only symbols of a quiet development, advancing without sudden leaps, whose steady yet irresistible character was recognised by Marx and brought by him into a system.
The national particularities within the world-embracing unity of the social movement are undeniable, and it does not appear uninteresting to detach the Jewish method in socialism as well from the foreign-national mother-rock. The Jews are the ancestors of historical democracy. That is a commonplace whose partial justification is over-estimated. Certainly the social legislation of Moses exhibits a whole series of radically democratic institutions; undeniably the Jews, as the only element of the population not susceptible of ennoblement, were the most natural combatants against the feudal aristocracy; the feudal society, however, gave place to the capitalist, and the further struggle of the victorious capital-bourgeoisie against a feudalism that grew ever more insignificant soon appeared purposeless — whereupon the possessing burgher class closed itself off against the demos, and an industrial and financial aristocracy developed. In the palace of government of the ruling classes, nobility and burgher aristocracy now dwell peaceably side by side, and the great gate was quickly shut, that the onstorming mass of the people might not break in. The venerable Jewish democracy is now torn into two parts. The one, the ruling part, do indeed call themselves democrats, yet they stand no longer with the people, but in arms against the people. The others now fight against their former class-fellows and call themselves socialists. The mediators have invented for themselves the title of social reformers, social politicians, and amuse themselves with doing the honours, as the envoys of the bourgeoisie, to the advancing social movement upon the territories wrested from that bourgeoisie. The democracy of the ruling Jews has been crippled into the un-Jewish concept of humanity, and the great reciprocity in giving and receiving is gone. There are now Jews who only give and such as must always take — Jews of the first and of the second class! This perception destroys the nursery-song of the natural democracy of the Jewish people, wherewith the social instincts in Jewry were to be kept down. The rent in the class-unity of the Jewish people lets a broad stream of intellectual force pour over into the socialist collecting-reservoir. We are come to the concept of Jewish socialism, which is not to be confounded with our ideal concept: socialist Jewry. The Jews are a text-book example for Marxism. The theory of catastrophe has here become no inductive but an empirical conclusion, even though the catastrophe does not signify the socialisation of the means of production. The position outside economic and social conformity to law is the cause of this Marxist development, which here can constitute no proof of the correctness of the doctrine.
The modern socialist movement is the social resultant of the economic-technical parallelogram of forces. Industrial technique is the content of the capitalist-socialist form. The sociologist begins the history of the proletarian movement with the words: In the beginning was the machine. Werner Sombart sets at the head of his chronology of the social movement the invention of the steam-engine. In short, outside the sphere of power of industrial technique there is no modern proletariat. The Jewish people stands as yet only in small part within the magic circle of the machine; therefore it has not yet entered into the social movement, therefore in its mass it does not yet fall under the influence of the laws derived from the development of the wage-labourer type. Only the minority is already enclosed within the next higher social formation, and this minority has formed the concept of Jewish socialism. The socialism of the masses is not the class-consciousness of the leaders, but the unconscious impulsion of social instincts. The primary thing is the economic struggle for existence, which compels a purely external defensive organisation. The secondary thing, however, is the psychological process which releases the social instincts mentioned and compresses them, in the thinking heads, into a world-view. And this secondary process exhibits among the Jews also its national-psychological moments. Socialism signifies not only the negation of the capitalist content; it constitutes above all the negation of the social forms, and herein it coincides with the deepest, most secret tendencies of the Jewish national soul. To the Jews, deprived of rights, oppressed, despised, all vital force was for centuries bound fast; every moral, intellectual, economic form of the host peoples was to the Jews foreign, hostile. Thus through the constant isolation positivism was torn out of the Jewish soul, and there was engendered that great contempt which
