Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 46 · 15 November 1901
8printed page
scan 8 of 16

Page 8. — "Die Welt" — No. 46.

(continued from page 7)

…practice of civic and political life, however, nothing or only little of it is to be observed.

Theoretically parity exists in Alsace-Lorraine; practically neither the administration nor the population troubles itself about it. There are indeed a number of Jews who play a political, or at least a local-political, part in the country: one Jew is a member of the Provincial Committee; further, the communal councils of most of the communes in which Jews dwell in larger numbers count Jewish members; there are also a number of Jewish officials. But to draw conclusions as to parity from these facts would be somewhat premature. The great mass does indeed now and then elect Jews, but only such as pass for rich or find themselves in an agreeable position. In Alsace, whose population is enthusiastic for equality, and where it is held self-evident to pay no regard, or but little, to the station or the fortune of Christian candidates, this is particularly striking. Among the seven Jewish members of the communal councils of the largest towns of the country — Strasburg, Mülhausen, Colmar and Hagenau (Metz has at the moment no Jewish representation) — there are to be counted two great manufacturers, two great merchants, one banker and two physicians; the banker is at the same time the Jewish member of the Provincial Committee. The great mass of Jews, however, consists of small tradesmen who laboriously earn their livelihood. These are on principle excluded from every candidature; only in the few places in which they form the majority or a considerable minority have they the possibility of carrying men of their own station at the elections.

Upon the practice of the State in the matter of parity an anonymous writer lately gave information in a publication which bears the title: "Die Parität in Elsass-Lothringen". According to this work there were in the year 1898 in our country, among 4204 officials, 70, that is 1.66 per cent., Jews. This number corresponds neither to the size of the Jewish population, which in the year 1895 amounted to 2 per cent., nor to the number of Jewish pupils at the higher schools, which on the 1st of November 1900 amounted to 8.8 per cent., nor to that of the Jewish matriculants, which from the 1st of November 1888 to the 1st of November 1897 amounted to 4.55 per cent., nor finally to that of the Jewish students, which in the middle of December 1898 amounted to 6.74 per cent. of the total number.

The disproportion becomes still greater when one considers that the anonymous publication does not enumerate at all various categories of officials among whom Jews do not occur at all or only sporadically: thus the military officials, the officer and non-commissioned officer corps, the minor officials, the teachers of the confessionally mixed schools, and the communal officials, who are to be reckoned by several thousands.

As experience shows, however, the people excludes the small Jewish tradesman almost completely from honorary offices, and the State appoints Jews in the smallest possible number. Parity, then, does not exist — at most rudiments of it.

It might well be objected that, so far as the State comes into consideration, a sign of good will in the matter of parity is to be seen in this, that in the educational system and in the administration of justice it has given positions of trust to a relatively large number of Jews: the University counts 17 Jewish lecturers, the Gymnasia and Realschulen 9 Jewish senior masters, the district and local courts 6 Jewish judges and 3 Jewish notaries.

A priori, however, it is to be assumed that the Alsace-Lorraine government, which is composed of similar elements to every other German one, applies in filling the vacant posts the principles that hold good in Old Germany. If in particular departments it departs, or has departed, from these fundamental laws, the reason is to be sought in this, that in Alsace-Lorraine it stood before a special task, for whose solution it needed the Jews, and specially the German Jews. The country, which had been conquered by arms, was not only to be organised upon a German basis; it was above all to be won back intellectually to Germanism. In order to fulfil this double task, the government needed ripened men who by their professional or scientific past and by their whole personality could make an impression upon the population. Scholars and officials of the Christian confession were not to be found in sufficient number: for those who held firm and lucrative positions were not easily to be moved, in spite of financial betterment, in spite of the satisfaction of being able to work at a national task, to enter into new and unaccustomed conditions and to live among a population which would presumably bring them no sympathies. The deficiency was covered by the Jews, who in Old Germany formed in a manner a reserve of officials, and who for years, and sometimes for decades, had waited in vain for State appointment and for a sphere of action corresponding to their attainments.

But now Germanism gains firmer ground from year to year; nor is there any longer a lack of Christian candidates. The Jew, then, is needed no more — he has done his duty.

The State, which has appointed Jews in larger number in the administration of justice and of education, did it therefore not out of regard for parity, but obeying necessity, not its own impulse; the necessity is gradually ceasing — grounds for appointing so many Jews therefore exist no longer.

Many people know well that the political equality of the Jews in Alsace is only a conventional lie; nevertheless their joy is great when they learn that yet another Jew has somewhere been elected or has obtained some office from the State. This is for them a proof that we have after all come a step forward — the Jew is indeed an optimist by nature. Perhaps their joy would be less if they knew how dearly such a step commonly costs Judaism: of 23 lecturers of Jewish descent whom, according to my inquiries, the University of Strasburg counts to-day, we can regard only 6 as still Jews; the remaining 17 are either baptised or have had their children baptised. Among the officials of justice of Jewish origin similar conditions prevail. And as concerns the Jews who are brought to honorary offices, none of them, it is true, are baptised — the Alsatian assimilationists do not yet coquet with the font; but precisely the most influential pass for confidential men of clericalism and for powerful props of the most various clerical foundations, and owe their election to clerical anti-Jewish committees.

For the rest, the study of the conditions of parity alone gives no sufficient information as to the political situation of a section of a people. There is needed besides the consideration of its material and its cultural position, and of the means it has employed in order to better its position or to prevent a worsening of it.

As already appears from my earlier reports, the position of the Alsatian Jews is a brilliant one neither in a material nor in a cultural respect. In the economic respect things go backward with great strides, and of a Jewish culture and a Jewish national consciousness there is scarcely any longer a question.

Our assimilationists console themselves easily enough over the loss of our cultural goods. But with less indifference do they see the prosperity of the Alsatian Jews sink.

They know well that the Vae Victis which vanquished Rome once had to hear has for the economically low-standing Jew a peculiarly tragic significance. The weaker and the poorer the Jew is, the more he must expose his person in the daily struggle for bread, the more openly and the more ruthlessly does anti-Semitism confront him and seek to rob him of his few political rights.

What means, then, do the Alsatian Jews employ in the political struggle in order to defend their interests?

One may well say: none.

Assimilationism has brought the Alsatian Jew so far that for his most immediate and personal interests he no longer takes up the political struggle. Thus in the last decade laws could be deliberated and resolved upon in the Provincial Committee which were bound to injure the Jewish cattle-dealers and the Jewish pedlars most gravely in their means of livelihood. Not one of our Jewish politicians held it necessary to bethink himself of means of defence, or to make his fellow-tribesmen attentive to the danger that threatened them; not a single Jew raised his voice and protested against the grave wrong that was to be inflicted upon the Jewish population.

As electors the Jews march with the most various parties. Whoever puts them off with the phrase, grown stereotyped and meaningless, that he will protect all recognised religions, may reckon upon their vote and their support.

Their policy is, in a word, that of the bird which upon the approach of the hunter thrusts its head into the sand.

To enlightenment and to progress (with these notions they very gladly operate) they leave it to take up the struggle with their enemies.

But they build their hope upon sand: this bill drawn upon the future will never be honoured. The educated and the enlightened are no less their enemies than the uneducated: they only give their hatred other forms. They confront the Jew not driven by blind passion, but with coolly calculating reason. Progress, which makes wars more terrible, only presses new weapons into the hands of our enemies as well; and the brotherhood of man upon which we set our hope recedes ever farther into the distance.

It would be high time that the Alsatian Jews changed their methods of political struggle. Instead of striving after offices and honorary offices, let them set themselves the task of defending their interests and their rights in every direction, and, in the safeguarding of their rights, of trusting in the first place to their own strength. Then too, no doubt, the political struggle will bring many a disappointment; but it will gather Alsatian Jewry together again, and it will awaken anew in the minds of the Jews the sense for Jewish national consciousness and Jewish ideals.