Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 40 · 4 October 1901
4printed page
scan 4 of 16
Facsimile · scan 4 of 16
Scan of p. 4
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 4 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 40

(continued from page 3)

…material, such as it has shown itself hitherto in the colonies, we shall not be able to carry through plans of this kind. In all the colonies we have people who come forward with great pretensions and maintain themselves upon their over-encumbered clod of earth by means of constant subventions. — But these are precisely the demoralising conditions to which the new organisation is to put an end! Achad-Haam with full right pointed out at the last general meeting of the Russian "Chowewe-Zion" in Odessa that the blame for all the abuses is to be laid upon the existing system of tutelage. But on the other hand it is not possible to set the men who stand at our disposal to-day quite independently upon a clod of earth and let them husband it. This difficulty is precisely what the principle of the productive co-operative solves. Here every man has from the beginning the feeling of being a co-proprietor with equal rights. He knows that the straining of all his powers will redound to his own benefit, but no obligations are laid upon him to which, as husbandman and organiser, he is not yet equal.

How the co-operative colonies work upon the character of the members Oppenheimer shows by several practical examples, and especially by the settlements of the Quakers and of the Mormons. In the domain of Vincland, New Jersey, U. S. A., the costs of police and of poor relief amounted to 2½ cents per head of the population, as against two dollars in the neighbouring township of Perth Amboy.

This seems to me a more serviceable kind of piece-work, for the saving of overseers' wages, than the kind which Soskin proposes.

One experience published in quite recent times I should like to reproduce here as well:

Count Reventlow at Wulfshagen in Schleswig has for a year past introduced upon his estate a participation of the labourers in the profits. In his report upon the first business year he describes his experiences as follows:

"Small as the shares paid out were, it has nevertheless been demonstrated to every man ad oculos that profit-sharing is not merely "good and useful to read of," but that even in moderate years it lets a real advantage slip into the pocket, upon the amount of which the individual labourer too, within the barriers drawn by the powers of nature, can exercise an influence. From the recognition of this state of things the individual must come to regard his work from a higher point of view than that of bare wage-labour; from this alteration in the character of the work it must follow that the former measure of supervision is no longer requisite. That this twofold "must" does not merely vagabond theoretically in my head, but is present in vera natura, appears from the fact that it has already borne its consequences here in the first year. Even without supervision the work went evenly forward; even during the harvest no words of urging or of reproof were needed. That these consequences, now that profit-sharing has for the first time come agreeably before the individual as a reality, will not weaken but rather strengthen, lies upon the surface."

From all that has been said thus far it at least appears that the Jca, in making an experiment in the direction discussed, would not be treading wholly unknown ground, and that the capital employed for the experiment is not considerably imperilled. For the rest: The eating is the proof of the pudding.


What the Galician Diet Elections Teach.

By Dr. Osias Thon, Cracow.

In one of the last numbers of the "Welt" Adolf Stand has attempted to draw lessons from the Diet elections in Lemberg and Cracow — lessons which, however, so far as I can see, are drawn rather ad memoriam for the unsuccessful candidates. They are now to take note that their hitherto policy of assimilation has lost the ground beneath its feet. The people turns away from its former leaders because it is dissatisfied with the leadership. Such, in substance, is the conclusion there drawn.

This conclusion would doubtless be correct for one — standing at a distance. Whoever has looked on at the matter from near at hand carried away from this electoral struggle in Lemberg and Cracow quite another impression. He was forced to say to himself, with deep affliction, that here one assimilation was vanquished by another — and a substantially worse one.

In Cracow Dr. Leon Horowitz stood as a candidate with the Conservatives as a Jew; thereupon a Jewish Democrat arose and declared that he was standing only as a Democrat — the "only" brought out with great emphasis — and the Jewish masses, the Wholly-Black foremost among them, followed his call. In Lemberg Dr. Emil Byk stood as a candidate with the Democrats as a Jew; thereupon a still "more democratic" Jew arose and stood only as a "concentrated Democrat," and here too more than 1000 Jews followed him.

The Jewish sense of fellowship has here gone grievously to pieces.

Who and what was vanquished here? By whom? And by what? An "also-Jew" by a "not-at-all-Jew"; a dying assimilation by a rising one, for the present by a — "striving" one.

Let us not deceive ourselves — between that older assimilation and that of to-day there still lies a wide gulf. First of all through the personal representatives of these tendencies. The older generation of assimilants issued from a purely Jewish education and environment. They might moult as much as they pleased — their roots still remained always in the soil of Jewry. One will hardly find among these elder men any who do not know at least something Jewish, at the least the reading of it. Their younger "after-strivers," however, are — in at least 99 cases out of 100 — illiterates in puncto Jewry. And this difference is truly not to be lightly esteemed. With the former one could still now and then exchange a serious word; the latter simply do not understand our language at all. Universal suffrage — that is the whole of their care and of their wisdom. Specifically Jewish questions do not concern them in the least.

And then these older assimilants have at least found a formula already — a very meagre and narrow one, to be sure — within which they can confess their Jewry and from time to time represent it. The young assimilatory place-hunters, however, are only beginning to come to an understanding with their non-Jewish allies, and will for long yet find no formula for their belonging to Jewry, the less so as they do not seek such a formula at all. Speak to them of specifically Jewish needs — it is Greek to them.

Beyond doubt — the late Diet elections brought a victory of the Wholly-Bad over the Not-Good.

More than that — I maintain that the late elections signify also a defeat, though only an indirect one, of the Zionist work. For fifteen years we have been labouring that the Jews should accustom themselves to place the Jewish interest in the first line. And now comes the first test — and everything fails: the Jews are everything possible, Democrats and Concentrated, only not Jews.

I held it to be a decided success of the Zionist criers that the older candidates there came forward as Jews, which for a long, long time had no longer been the case. But perhaps it was precisely that which injured them with the Jews. In Cracow an ex-Zionist said this in tolerably plain words. It does not suffice to-day, said he, to emphasise the confessional character of the candidates — he is, as he says, a Zionist emeritus, and therefore speaks only of confession! — To-day, he holds, the Jews vote only according to general political points of view. And I heard how a Jew in Cracow on the day of the election perpetrated with great emphasis the breakneck thesis: "I would rather vote for ten Christians than for one Jew." He was one of the blackest of the orthodox. I stopped him and said to him: "Stay your fierce wrath. But why is the Christian candidate dearer to you?" "Because a Christian can do more for Jews — if he will!" "But, my little friend, he does